Options
Colonial experts -- comments on Maris 21 1/2-R just sold on eBay?
It's not too often that you see a raw coin sell for $30K on eBay. I'm pretty sure it's a real sale, too -- I recognize the winning biddder and the underbidder, at least by name. Could one of the colonial experts on the board wax eloquent about what is apparently an incredibly rare piece?
eBay listing
(The winning bid and underbid were $32K, and the third-place bid was $10K. How annoyed do you suppose the winning bidder is at the underbidder?
)

eBay listing
(The winning bid and underbid were $32K, and the third-place bid was $10K. How annoyed do you suppose the winning bidder is at the underbidder?
0
Comments
A healthy debate is raging at the moment on the colonial coin chatroom (C4) with various theories being floated. I would summarize those comments by saying that the assessment of the coin's authenticity seems to be being based as much or more on the reputation of some of the underbidders (though not the direct underbidder) and on the ebay bidding pattern itself as it is on the coin's attributes.
There have long been 2 known of this variety with this 3rd, assuming its genuine, appearing out of the woodwork.
For my $32K, I'd prefer one with a known provenance - but of course one of those isn't on the market now or is likely to be at anytime in the near future.
So, if you are a serious collector and you want this variety, and you are confident in your ability to authenticate it, then this ebay offer may be the one and only chance to acquire this variety in your lifetime.
From the discussion in the eBay listing, it sounds like the Ford sale had one of these? What did that one sell for?
novacaesarea
<< <i>(The winning bid and underbid were $32K, and the third-place bid was $10K. How annoyed do you suppose the winning bidder is at the underbidder?
Probably not at all...drop a couple of zeros and this happens to me all the time. I just think "dang, if this guy had gotten busy and forgot to bid...OTOH, sometimes the other bidder doesn't show up and I get a deal...but on the board here when you get a deal they call it a "rip". Negativity abounds!!!
--Jerry
Yeah, I saw that auction when it was first listed. My first impression was, "yeah, right". I downloaded the images and examined them over and over. Just can't be. Or could it? I would want a specific gravity test done for that much cabbage. It has a "cast" look to me, but that's probably influenced by my sense of disbelief. Based on the whos-who on the bidder list, it is more than likely genuine, or at least comes with a very solid return priviledge.
K S
New collectors, please educate yourself before spending money on coins; there are people who believe that using numismatic knowledge to rip the naïve is what this hobby is all about.
<< <i>no way is this a cast - what would they cast if from? >>
Bingo. You hit the nail on the head.
It couldn't be a cast. It doesn't mean it is real, just that it isn't a cast.
Coin Rarities Online
<< <i>
<< <i>no way is this a cast - what would they cast if from? >>
Bingo. You hit the nail on the head.
It couldn't be a cast. It doesn't mean it is real, just that it isn't a cast. >>
Valid point. Only 2 known, so no host coin is the presumption. But who's to say that there aren't 2 or 3 other examples of this variety "out there" in collections? It still has a funny look to me. Maybe it's the images? Maybe I just can't believe it!!! Of course there have been more than one rare variety show up on eBay. We all know that.
I have owned many electro-type colonials over the years and some are very, very good. It is my understanding that main reason for the vintage electros was to provide variety collectors a means of having a tough variety to fill the hole, and for museum purposes.
I can't wait to get the news on this great find!
<< <i>The new owner is convinced the coin is real, and the piece is now in a collection. So I would not anticipate any updates or information to be forthcoming about this coin. >>
I did not know that. Great story. My understanding is that the owner knew that it was rare, but did not know the true value. Is that the case.
K S