Options
Not so hypothetical: you list on coin on eBay, you learn it is probably AT, what do you do?
I hope I don't get somebody mad at me, I'm really not trying to promote an auction or anything, I just want to hear opinions on how to handle this situation.
I listed a Toned Texas Commem for a client on eBay. I thought it was probably NT. Someone posted a thread asking if it were AT or NT. A toning expert, TomB, has seen these coins before and is certain it is AT.
Should I pull the auction?
Should I add to the description that the coin could be (or is) AT and would be bagged by PCGS?
Should I do nothing outside of honoring my normal return policy?
Any other options?
I listed a Toned Texas Commem for a client on eBay. I thought it was probably NT. Someone posted a thread asking if it were AT or NT. A toning expert, TomB, has seen these coins before and is certain it is AT.
Should I pull the auction?
Should I add to the description that the coin could be (or is) AT and would be bagged by PCGS?
Should I do nothing outside of honoring my normal return policy?
Any other options?
0
Comments
When we are planning for posterity, we ought to remember that virtue is not hereditary.
Thomas Paine
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>I would close the auction, and relist it with a condensed version of Tom's explanation. Many bidders don't scroll down and read text that is added. >>
Possibly, cancel the bids, update the description, honestly, saying there is doubt as to whether or not it is AT or NT (no disrepect to TomB intended), and that it most likely would not slab at PCGS/NGC/potentially anywhere else.
There are people who will buy pretty coins, if the price is right. ebay lets people decide what the right price is. Just be honest in the desc and the picture and start low....let people decide what they want/don't want.
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
<< <i>I would close the auction, and relist it with a condensed version of Tom's explanation. Many bidders don't scroll down and read text that is added.
Russ, NCNE >>
I agree. The other option, depending on your relationship with the consignor, is to refuse to sell the coin at all and return it to him.
Sean Reynolds
"Keep in mind that most of what passes as numismatic information is no more than tested opinion at best, and marketing blather at worst. However, I try to choose my words carefully, since I know that you guys are always watching." - Joe O'Connor
Looks pretty good to me.
Is the other person 100% certain...did they do it or know who did? If not, that coin look good to me, then I'd let it go.
It's hard to get reds etc like this coin has. However did it (if AT) is scary!
Ike Specialist
Finest Toned Ike I've Ever Seen, been looking since 1986
Of course I know you happen to care about what you sell Carl, and will do the right thing.
--Jerry
<< <i>Well, as the coin stands now the high bidder knows the coin is AT and as long as he is the high bidder, why kill the auction? >>
Nobody KNOWS unless they were there....
<< <i><< Well, as the coin stands now the high bidder knows the coin is AT and as long as he is the high bidder, why kill the auction? >>
Nobody KNOWS unless they were there.... >>
The high bidder is the guy who posted that. What he's saying is that he's in it with his eyes open.
<< <i>Unfortunately the link to the auction has been deleted so I can't look at the auction >>
The link is in the first post in this thread.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i><< Well, as the coin stands now the high bidder knows the coin is AT and as long as he is the high bidder, why kill the auction? >> Nobody KNOWS unless they were there.... >>
The high bidder is the guy who posted that. What he's saying is that he's in it with his eyes open.
<< <i>Unfortunately the link to the auction has been deleted so I can't look at the auction >>
The link is in the first post in this thread. Russ, NCNE >>
Russ,
Yea, I found the link (thanks) and what I meant to say was actually pretty much agreeing with you. The bidder has his eyes open and he may even have another opinion on whether the coin is AT or not. Perhaps he's a "buy the coin, not the plastic" guy!!!
--Jerry
"I will offer to cancel any current bids at the bidder's request without prejudice. Bids placed after this addendum will be held to contract.
PCGS, ANACS, & NGC Certified Coins on My Website.
sentiment. Relist the coin with the proper discription so that
everyone is aware what they are bidding on. It is the right and
proper thing to do.
Camelot
Will’sProoflikes
Just because the current high bidder understands that it may be AT has no bearing on what you should do. The current high bidder may not win the auction.
Relist the coin with an updated description with as much info as you know. The bidders will come back.
You will sleep better at night - I know I would.
“In matters of style, swim with the current; in matters of principle, stand like a rock." - Thomas Jefferson
My digital cameo album 1950-64 Cameos - take a look!
unless TomB actually did what he suspects as AT, it is only that -> his suspicion
congratulations on your silver nickel sales - they sold for more than I was willing to pay
maybe as he sez -their on the lookout for that "look" now.
Can someone pleeeeeze "prove" to my good friend Farmer that the piece
is doctored !? He`s getting all worked up over this .
I really do not believe you should say that it is AT because Tom thinks so. On the contrary, grading (and this includes EYE APPEAL) is subjective
I think I've made my stance pretty clear about toners since I showed up last year..... but
Ummmm
well, the coin has drawn the attention of very smart people. KEETS and BRADDICK being two that I've seen bid.
Now, I am not fond of them toners, but the TEXAS is my nephew's favorite and in an album, that particular coin has outstanding eye appeal. NT or AT.... CT or TT....
it's truly a beautiful coin.
... and I can't stand toners.
I think you should let it run it's course. If at auction end you want to notify the buyer of this "SUSPICION" by an expert, then do so. If Braddick wins , I can guarantee you it won't be at the current bid
I am torn between relisting the coin and adding (in large type) to it.
I want to make it clear that there is some question as to the toning being natural and that it seems likely PCGS wouldn't grade it, or something like that.
Honestly, not being in your shoes right now, cannot tell you what to do.
If the coin was RAW and you believed it to be AT, I think it would be proper to close the auction and restart it with appropriate info.
The coin is already certified by a TPG, credible or not, that is what it is. I don't think Heritage or other auction houses would refund money spent on such a coin should it fail being crossed into a more reputable holder.
edited to add: you need to put at the end of your auction "Carl is a great guy!"
<< <i>Clearly state the new information in a revision to the current auction. >>
It's not "information" It's an opinion from someone on the internet made based on a photo.
CU Forum memebers are automatically exempt from backlash for selling AT or doctored coins - so you're safe.
But if you didn't post here there would be a 500 count thread about you and you would receive 100 emails threatening your very existance.
So you're cool - carry on.
You don't sound as if you have met Tom, know his background or have seen the other coins he has, which he described as likely having come from the same source.
Regardless of what Carl ends up doing, kudos to him for caring enough to start this thread - no wonder I like him.
I still think its a beautiful coin regardless of whether someone thinks its AT or NT. I see no harm in continuing the auction esp. if the high bidder is aware of the current debate and perfectly willing to pony up for the coin come auctions end.
Thumbs up for the guts do post this in response to the inquiry.
On the other hand you cant let polls and posts dictate your auctions.
Your selling a coin, graded, slabbed and even put a disclaimer about the grading leniency. Youve gone above and beyond.
<< <i>..........yes , `dat be A.T .....but i have a couple of Franklins (slabbed a few years back) in PCGS holders by the same Doc ......
maybe as he sez -their on the lookout for that "look" now.
Can someone pleeeeeze "prove" to my good friend Farmer that the piece
is doctored !? He`s getting all worked up over this . >>
Dam. You made me laugh. What's up with that?
Whut we have heah is a fail-yuh to uh-gree.
Frankly, I can't believe that one person's opinion carries enough weight to effect Carl's auction, and thus his financial position in this. But hey, if Carl ain't gonna stand up for his own coin, why should I?
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
<< <i>I would stand by SEGS's opinion (who examined it in person) over some know-it-all who is making a judgement based on a photo. >>
TomB's opinion is as good as it gets. Nuff said.
<< <i>I would stand by SEGS's opinion (who examined it in person) over some know-it-all who is making a judgement based on a photo. >>
On the issue of toning, I will take Tom's opinion any day, any time, over the opinion of SEGS. It's clear from your stupid statement that you have little experience with either.
Russ, NCNE
of integrity, knowledge, wisdom and common sense. A well done
to the entire Forum. In fact, you are all awarded my
"GROWL OF APPROVAL, FOR MERITORIOUS CONDUCT"
Camelot
Anyway Carl... a valid post is made about the seller's character by using the boards to bring attention to the coin.
I will not pass such judgement as promotion is not criminal....maybe cheeky, but not immoral
And to those who want to pass this judgement , you all should sit on your fingers and talk coins, instead of character assassination. Cripes, we got enough of that
Joe
As for TomB--- like has been said- When he talks-I Listen...
Cause it already was as high as it was possible
to go.
Camelot
<< <i>Clearly state the new information in a revision to the current auction. >>
Correct answer!
John
SFC, US Army (Ret.) 1974-1994
<< <i>
You don't sound as if you have met Tom, know his background or have seen the other coins he has, which he described as likely having come from the same source.
>>
No, but I know Larry Briggs quite well....
There's obvious fake toning, and obvious real, also a vast spread of "arguable" toning. Some clown used to troll the
Heritage auctions in Dallas, telling Leo Frese or potential bidders that "this coin has fake toning and should be
withdrawn." or "this coin has a clever alteration that the TPG missed and should be withdrawn."
HE was the one eventually withdrawn.
You added it MIGHT be AT to your text.
You have a return priviledge.
Braddick's going to win it anyway.
Don't worry about it.
If you really want to impress me with your ethics then pull the auction and in the future refuse to deal in junky 3rd world slabs which are a blight on our hobby.