Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

Contest/Giveaway: We all make mistakes

RYKRYK Posts: 35,804 ✭✭✭✭✭
We all make coin buying mistakes. I opened my safe and The Chief Justice John Marshall Coin and Chronicles Set fell out. I asked myself, "WTF did you buy that thing?" I have no clue. I can barely tell you who John Marshall is (beyond the obvious). The sets are sealed in plastic, so if I open it, it will drop in value. If I leave it sealed, I will have know idea what's inside. Catch-22.

Here's the contest: Tell the forum about one of your coin buying mistakes. Best, funniest (extra points for funny), most interesting story gets to have my Chief Justice John Marshall Coin and Chronicles Set. These have sold recently on ebay in the $50-70 range, and you can do with it whatever you like (open it, keep it, sell it, give it away, toss it into a swimming pool, etc.).

The fine print: Contest ends by Friday Sept. 15, but if the responses trickle before then, I reserve the right to end the contest. Multiple entries okay. Edits okay (mgoodm3 image ). There will be no ties (I only have one of these...fortunately). No returns or trades. I will have a secret judge or two help pick the winner. If there are fewer than ten entries by Friday Sept. 15, I will void the contest and sell the damn thing myself. I will not ttt the thread. That covers about everything. Remember, be truthful but funny...if you are not funny, have someone funny help you. image

Comments

  • Options

    My worst coin buying mistake was taking the free Marshal C&C set and only getting $30 for it on eBay.
  • Options
    lasvegasteddylasvegasteddy Posts: 10,492 ✭✭✭
    as an 8yr old in missuori in 1970.i mowed yards for a coin on a bid board.a 1914-d penny.i didn't know what "alterred date" mean't at the time and won it and took it home and acquired so much distaste for my foolishness that i placed it in circulation.from then on i knew mistakes by me were to be lessons.thanks for the chance but i'm sure many have me beat but as an 8 year old i was all beat-up on that one
    everything in life is but merely on loan to us by our appreciation....lose your appreciation and see


  • Options
    So I'm down in South Georgia (Columbus, as a matter of fact) and my dad and I come across a little coin shop. We go inside and I poke around amid the offerings for sale. I move toward a case of Indian Head Cents and in the dark, shadowy corner of the case this one catches my eye.

    imageimage

    I buy it for 30 bucks, a LOT of money to me because I like it so much. I don't know why, but it just looked really nice to me at the time. The shop was full of cigar smoke. I must have been confuzzled. image Yeah, that's it.

    I thought, SURELY this can't be only 30 dollars. (I'm still thinking it's a nice red IHC at this point.) So I get it and I think it's a great deal for my money. Silly me. image

    I put it in my Dansco and it looks ever so nice. But then I show it here and I learn that it was cleaned, indeed possibly whizzed! image

    So my 30 dollar "find" becomes my 30 dollar lesson.

    I'm sure my face was as red as the coin when I learned I had been taken! image

    So, I keep in around as a reminder of my past incompetence and as motivation to learn more about coins. image

    Plus, there's a really cool clash on the reverse! image

    I do like to show it to non-numismatic types and gauge their reactions when they see a 100+ year old cent that looks like one of the brand-new Lincolns out of their pocket.

    Then I break the bad news to them and explain that cleaning is bad so they never do that to any old coins they happen to find.

    Thanks for the chance, RYK!

    -Amanda
    image

    I'm a YN working on a type set!

    My Buffalo Nickel Website Home of the Quirky Buffaloes Collection!

    Proud member of the CUFYNA
  • Options
    mirabelamirabela Posts: 5,205 ✭✭✭✭✭
    The last I knew, the thread documenting my worst to date (thank goodness!) had well over 1,000 posts. You know the story.

    image
    mirabela
  • Options
    airplanenutairplanenut Posts: 22,816 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I really blew a purchase once...

    It was July 2003, and I was attracted to a cleaned (!) 1829 bust dime. Like a mosquito to a bug zapper, I just had to go to the light, and I purchased it for a nominal price. The coin, though, became a product of severe neglect and mishandling, showing that over time, it was a poor purchase. You see, first, I accidentally drove a nail through it. Then, it found its way in the oven followed by a torch. After that, a razor blade carved my initials and the year into Liberty's poor, abused face (after first trying to add detail to said abused face). Then, as if it wasn't enough, somehow the coin found its way between to pliers and was bent! image

    So what I thought was an innocent purchase brought out the worst of the collector in me. I doubt I could repent enough to ever be forgiven for causing such a tragedy to occur. Clearly, this was my worst purchase ever.

    As one step towards repentence, though, I did have the decency to entomb this coin, and did everything I could to ensure an accurate tombstone--a tribute to a life of suffering.

    image
    image
    image
    JK Coin Photography - eBay Consignments | High Quality Photos | LOW Prices | 20% of Consignment Proceeds Go to Pancreatic Cancer Research
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭
    At the PNNA three years ago I bought two widly toned Indian Head Cents from an Idaho fireman part-time coin dealer. I submitted them to PCGS and, of course, they were bodybagged for questionable color. Shortly after I posted the coins and the results I get a PM from another forum member - who lives in Idaho. He says, "HMM, those coins sure look familiar. Did you buy them from so and so?"

    Turns out this was the second time they'd been bodybagged. He'd bought them from the same Idaho fireman part-time dealer and returned them after PCGS gave them the toe-tag. Funny that the dealer didn't mention that to me when I bought them.

    Coins is a very small world.

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    MadMartyMadMarty Posts: 16,697 ✭✭✭
    My worse coin buying mistake is the coin I didn't get to buy because if sheer stupidity! Yep the AH and the cameraphone! For those of you who weren't here for that, I hit this little shop and start looking though flat pack proof sets. I grab a 64 with a MONSTER DEEP CAMEO ACCENT HAIR. I'm thinking to myself, IN YOUR FACE RUSS!!!. I had to rub it in so I whip out the camera phone and snap a pic. Standing behind me is this little snot nosed teenager. He sees what I'm doing and says very loudly, "That a DCAM Accent Hair Kennedy! They are worth thousands!". The dealer hearing this, takes the set and says this one isn't for sale!


    Moral of the story, leave the camera in the car!!!
    It is not exactly cheating, I prefer to consider it creative problem solving!!!

  • Options
    This not a coin purchase, but a coin back in change. I remember it so clearly, I didn't even think about it until I joined this board and saw somehthing about a 1955 DD penny. I received this penny with some change (back when I was about 17, I am now 50) and I remember looking at this coin and saying someone really messed up, they stamped over this date twice so I just tossed it away. I now know the person who messed up, ME! Not a great story, but a true story. I wish I had started collecting coins back then, I would have wiser.
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭


    << <i>My worse coin buying mistake is the coin I didn't get to buy because if sheer stupidity! Yep the AH and the cameraphone! For those of you who weren't here for that, I hit this little shop and start looking though flat pack proof sets. I grab a 64 with a MONSTER DEEP CAMEO ACCENT HAIR. I'm thinking to myself, IN YOUR FACE RUSS!!!. I had to rub it in so I whip out the camera phone and snap a pic. Standing behind me is this little snot nosed teenager. He sees what I'm doing and says very loudly, "That a DCAM Accent Hair Kennedy! They are worth thousands!". The dealer hearing this, takes the set and says this one isn't for sale! >>



    I don't want to bias the judge, but that is going to be my favorite no matter what else is posted. image

    image

    image

    image

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    MrSpudMrSpud Posts: 4,499 ✭✭✭
    This story is about a PCGS MS63 nickel III cent piece that me and my wife bought off of e-bay. It is the first slabbed coin we ever owned. This is right when I was starting to get back into collecting coins when my wife became interested in them and was our introduction into the world of slabbed coins and the 70 point grading system.

    I had not collected coins for many years and I got back into it just a couple of years ago when my wife started to get interested in collecting. We were just starting to figure the whole grading thing out. The MS grading system didn't really exist (at least for me) when I used to collect as a kid. There was pretty much just G, VG, F, VF, XF, and uncirculated back then. Well, we were looking at e-bay and a MS63 Nickel III cent piece was up in just a few minutes. We had found and saved the PCGS price guide in our favorites just a couple of days earlier and quickly looked up the III cent piece because it looked like a nice uncirculated version of a III cent piece that my brother had bought for me when I was a kid.

    Well, new as we were, we accidently looked it up in the proof section of the price and thought it was worth over $1000. We bid on it in a hurry and ended up getting it for $135. We felt like we hit the lottery. Afterwards, I looked it up again after I did some reading (and ended up joining these forums) and realized our mistake. Fortunately we got it for pretty much what it is worth. Even more fortunately, it is a nice PCGS coin, very solid for a MS63 with no marks on it and just a hint of light even toning that makes it look really nice. It is one of my favorite coins now.

    image
  • Options
    bidaskbidask Posts: 14,057 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Which one?
    I manage money. I earn money. I save money .
    I give away money. I collect money.
    I don’t love money . I do love the Lord God.




  • Options
    Well this is more embarassing than funny but hind site makes me laugh.... I started collecting 4 years ago after I found a Morgan dollar in a house I was renovating (being from canada I had never seen one). Morgans became a passion.... no morgan on ebay was safe from me... I was going to corner the market...and get rich. I found an auction for an 1884s morgan, 1916d dime, 1913 buffalo cent, 1927 quarter, and several other coins... wow I hit the jackpot and got into a bit of a bidding war with another ebay member at the last minute...but I prevailed and won..... ready to cash in... sent in my money and got my coins.... wooooo hoooo... I have since given the morgan to my grand daughter as she really liked it but I did keep the 1916d mercury as it comes in handy....
    image
    image

    and it does serve as a reminder to read the entire auction before bidding......

    image
    There is nothing more powerful than the power of goodbye
  • Options
    STONESTONE Posts: 15,275 ✭
    OKAY, so one night I was on Ebay a year or two ago and am looking at some Wheat Cents. This one guy (a "Powerseller") is selling a complete set on Wheats in really high grade EF-MS+. I'm scrolling down the list of coins and I see what I think is a 1914-D in MS+ condition and toned; it looked RB and was labeled so. I put in a $45 bid with about 3 days left. NOTE: I had never spent more than $35 on a coin before that date. So I leave the coin till the final day, Friday and see how my bid is doing. I figure that I'll be outbid big time and I was only contributing to increasing the bid of the coin. So I enter MyEbay and see that my bid is still the highest at $35. I go in to examine the coin one more time and notice that the coin is dated 1941-D not 1914-D. I'm freaking out right there because the seller has no return policy, so all I can do is hope and pray someone stupid out there over bids me.

    I end up winning the coin for a total of $38.25 after all shipping costs. I get the coin 5 days later and otice that it is a more-or-less solid BN and only a hint of toning when tilted to a certain angle, it was a nice MS though-easily 64/65. "GREAT, A 20 CENT COIN FOR ALMOST $40". It still sits in my safe as a reminder of that stupid mistake and that I should always be thorough about every coin purchase and to second guess Ebay.

    Hope you like the story.
  • Options
    kiyotekiyote Posts: 5,636 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I got caught up in the "early date!" Bison nickels in 2005. Never mind I already have 5 boxes of two set rolls dated only 6 days after they were first available, I had to have EARLIER! I saw a box from the first known stamped date! My head swimmed with images of speared Bison! I had to have it. It went to a bidding war, and I ended up paying about $40 all told for a 2-roll set of bison nickels. Later, the mint came out and pooh-poohed at the dates stamped on the side of the bison boxes. I sold all of mine, and the earliest date box I had went for $13.00. image
    "I'll split the atom! I am the fifth dimension! I am the eighth wonder of the world!" -Gef the talking mongoose.
  • Options
    tizofthetizofthe Posts: 1,365 ✭✭✭
    Sweet and short. I started collecting about 6 years ago and knew like the rest of us very little about dates, condition etc. When I I was at a garage sale near my house about 5 or so years ago the owner had a little box which had 3 or 4 silver dollars and a couple of other types of coins in the box. I asked her how much she wanted and she replied and said I will take 5.00 each or 20.00 for the box. I said ok and looked at them for a minute or so and decided to go with the 1922 peace dollar because it was the oldest one she had. On the way home my wife said why did you not get the other one ibecause it was 40 years before my birthday and looked to be in better shape. As I think back on it now it looked to be a AU58 or MS60. I told my wife because this one is older and I should be able to get more for it as the years go on. The joke is on me because my wife was born in 1968.
    Transactions..
    wondercoin, duffman,PiecesOfMe, Smittys, LogPotato, Bumanchu, Tydye, segoja, Harry779, FullCameo, Twosidestoeverycoin, jmdm1194, rkfish, drewsef, Chrischampeo, Kaelasdad, Ahrensdad, Dabigkahuna, Barbwire, sebrown, mkman123, Gerard
  • Options
    cheezhedcheezhed Posts: 6,463 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Mine is a non-buying mistake.

    I didn't get a GSA dollar when they were being sold in the 70's.
    Many happy BST transactions
  • Options
    I have made lots of mistakes, but the best story is my near miss.......About five or six years ago I had placed a winning bid on an Isabella Quarter, it was an MS66 and in a holder I had never heard of, since I didnt collect a lot of coins and I had really only just started to be interested.......

    Then I found this place and some of you guys were kind enougth to tell me what you would pay for an Isabella MS66 slabbed by ACGimage

    I declined to honor my bid, learned never to do that again and have been coming back ever since......
  • Options
    MadMartyMadMarty Posts: 16,697 ✭✭✭
    image

    I don't know why, I was hoping that my picture story would just fade away like a bad dream!
    It is not exactly cheating, I prefer to consider it creative problem solving!!!

  • Options
    richardshipprichardshipp Posts: 5,647 ✭✭✭
    Once upon a time as a "Child Coin Collector" (CCC™), I frequented a local shop in Scottsdale, Az. It was during these formative years that due to the "Limited Expendable Income Gained From Mowing Yards" (LEIGFMY™) I often dug through the dealers boxes of "junk". I usually tried to put together date runs and then stuff them into a Whitman Folder. Well somewhere along the way, my interest in coin collecting slipped away and more focus was placed on girls, cars, and sports.... (Hmmm... why am I back into coins????).

    At any rate, in the last 6 months or so I've kind of gone into a "Resurrected Coin Collecting Binge" (RCCB™). One of the first discoveries was made while looking at my "date run" of Liberty Nickels. Much to my surprise, the 1912 that I'd stuffed into my album had an "S" on the back image.

    So now I'm thinking, that dealer wasn't doing his job too well if he let a kid snag that nickel for the price of a pack of gum. Wonder what other treasure I might have made off with. I continue to go through the folders and BAM RIGHT IN FRONT OF ME (BRIFOM™) in the best looking 1943 Steel Cent. Its got some beautiful tone to boot (BTTB™). I start to thinking, I wonder how rare these are this nice. I do a browse through fleabay and can't find anything even close to this nice of looking. My image starts pounding. I brag about my luck to my ever loving wife and daughter.

    It was about this time when I'd just started participating in this forum. Surely these "Internet Coin Forum Gods" (ICFG™) will be able to tell me what this MONSTER was worth. Just think, as a kid I'd snagged what might be the NICEST KNOWN EXAMPLE of a steel cent. NO DOUBT the forum members will throw a "YOU SUCK" my way.

    Well, I managed to get an image up of my prize:

    image

    And within moments I learn the "Most Troubling Truth" (MTT™). image

    It took a few posts for me to realize and accept that I'd been had. Whats worse is I at first denied the fact to some people here (I apologize). It was a very good learning experience. Next time I'll try to not get my hopes up so high.

    Thats it and thanks for the opportunity. I'll promise to not throw out or sell your set.... Hell I even kept my steel cent, cause even replated, I still think its pretty image
  • Options
    LongacreLongacre Posts: 16,720 ✭✭✭
    Great contest. I am not sure if I have any funny stories, but hopefully this post will stay on page 1.
    Always took candy from strangers
    Didn't wanna get me no trade
    Never want to be like papa
    Working for the boss every night and day
    --"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
  • Options
    PipestonePetePipestonePete Posts: 1,988 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Back in 1982 I answered an ad in Coin World which advertised an XF+ 1909-s VDB Lincoln Cent. The coin was being offered in trade for silver bullion. I responded to the ad by mailing off $40 face value of silver coins which I had pulled from circulation over the years as a kid. I believe that silver was at $12 oz. at that time so it represented nearly a $500 investment.....a pretty big deal for me in those days. The coin arrived and looked fantastic. I sent if off to ANACS immediately. ANACS determined that it was a total forgery. Of course, the seller was no longer to be found (P. O. Box for an address, etc.).
  • Options
    VeepVeep Posts: 1,525 ✭✭✭✭
    A few years back I convinced myself that gold was going to rise and that $5 Liberties would be a nice way to hold some. So, I ordered 20 of them in VF from a dealer who still has a weekly ad in Coin World. When they arrived and were spread out on the table, I was reminded that one man's VF is another man's G. Not only that, but two of them were unquestionably fakes. I got my money back with no problems, but I'm sure someone else became the stuck-ee.
    "Let me tell ya Bud, you can buy junk anytime!"
  • Options
    dthigpendthigpen Posts: 3,932 ✭✭
    I put the lime in the coconut, but I didn't shake it all up.
  • Options
    mhammermanmhammerman Posts: 3,769 ✭✭✭
    My story pales by comparison to some of the wild ones here but it is real and painful none the less. I was in a reputable shop here and was in the indian hunting mood so the owner brought out a moderately difficult to find '14 $5 indian holdered as a green pcgs ms62. It wasn't too pricey but it was still retail price. The oberse was very nice as was the reverse albeit a light staple scratch across the field. Pcgs didn't attribute the scratch and I questioned the seller about the scratch...he said that it was fine and that it wasn't attributed so it was a non-issue. I wavered a little and then snapped it up like a redfish grabbing a softshelled crab. When I got home, I didn't like it. Everytime I took out my tribe I would avoid looking at the reverse, it just grew worse and worse and then I sold it along with some strays and extras. I showed it to a very astute coin friend of mine and he only said one thing..."It's got a scratch."

    I bought it at the low end of the market and finally sold it into an up market so the story ended well...I got some buks for my pain and got rid of the source of the pain at a modest profit. You got to prune the tribe from time to time. Don't ever buy a coin that the dealer tells you is fine but you mind tells you it is bad...it will never get better no matter how long you own it or how hard it is to find. You must learn to trust yourself. I make a lot of mistakes but the upside of it is I only make the same mistake once.

    Coin ON!
  • Options
    MadMartyMadMarty Posts: 16,697 ✭✭✭
    image
    It is not exactly cheating, I prefer to consider it creative problem solving!!!

  • Options
    carlcarl Posts: 2,054 ✭
    I was over a relative's house some years back and one of thier sons was telling me he has started to use ebay. I warned him that he should be really carefull on that ebay stuff because a kid in his teens may not be to smart and get pretty well scammed. He then showed me a coin he bought on ebay and had it checked out at a local coin shop as real. It was a US,$5 dollar gold coin in a 2x2. I don't remember the date but the condition was at least AU. The cost is what shocked me. He paid $5 for it and the seller paid the postage.
    Carl
  • Options
    The only experience involving purchasing a coin that could have been a mistake was one that turned out to be the dealers mistake. 3 years ago I bought a '95 SAE, it was the only one left I needed to complete the series at the time. I looked at several other dates of different coins and then asked the dealer if he had a '95 SAE and he asked me if I was the person that had called that morning and at the same time turned around to the counter behind him and passed a beautiful example to me . I never answered him whether or not I called but took the eagle out of the envelope and knew immediately it was for me. I went away that day quite happy, not my mistake but a mistake none the less.
    "If I had a nickel for every nickel I ever had, I'd have all my nickels back".
  • Options
    Got an email from RYK that I won... woo hooo.... I'm gonna send him a very nice slightly circulated (with a few beer stains)
    1927 quarter
    image
    There is nothing more powerful than the power of goodbye

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file