<< <i>The turning point in that thread was the people who simply cannot control the urge to bash Laura no matter what she says. The most innocent comment from her is somehow transmuted by these people in to an attack on mom, hotdogs, and apple pie.
Russ, NCNE >>
BINGO Russ.....
And I bet 1/2 of them have no reason whatsoever besides the "I think I look cool factor" -- They should realize what they really look like...
<< <i>I've hung around this forum for 5 years now. I've been [mostly] a gentleman in the CF. I've tried to only say complimentary things. I've ignored the ebay threads, the modern threads, the pocket change threads. If I don't collect what's in the thread, I don't disparage those that do.
I expect the same consideration back if I start a thread about the things that interest me. >>
I read your thread and thought it was interesting. It covered an unfamilar topic so I read it and did not post.
I think that the true collectors on this site do appreciate your posts (especially on very expensive coins). If you are true collector, then you are nothing but excited to see and hear about a 100k+ coin. (See all the threads about the '33 double eagles or the case of Dahlonega coins). To those "collectors" that become jealous when they see an interesting, rare, and expensive coin, maybe you should re-evaluate why you collect in the first place.
Like pocket change threads, ebay threads, and Frankie threads, I had nothing to contribute to yours so I stayed out of it. It might have taken on a different tone if Stewart or Lloyd or JPK came around, rather than the usual Legend-bashing Posse™.
I was recently called out as an elitist for initiating one of my threads about gold coins. My sarcastic reply was that perhaps we should only discuss pocket change, lest we offend someone who does not have means to purchase coins. It would be a shame to become a least common denominator coin forum. >>
This is absolutely ridiculous. RYK has been one of the most helpful and patient members on this board. I have PM'ed him countless times and he always responds and is willing to help me out. RYK does collect an interesting series of coins and it is just too bad people are jealous.
Don't know what I missed but I agree. I have only been based once here in five years and made an apology because I was wrong even though I didn't know what I did was wrong at the time. I TTT'd more than once in one day.
I agree with TDN. We should follow his example and treat each other with civility; even when we disagree with each other, we should do so respectfully.
The civility IMHO does not need to be extended to bad sellers on eBay.
An authorized PCGS dealer, and a contributor to the Red Book.
TDN, I'd need to move a decimal place (well actually two decimal places) to reach that level for a coin purchase-but I enjoy reading about most transactions-particularly when there's a "backstory" discussing motivation and decision making. As long as a post is sincere (and your thread was)-"Good on ya". Don
Don't let a few bad apples spoil the fun. Ignore it, most of us (I think shown by the number of posts in this thread) have no issues and completely agree.
Different persons means different collecting interests, different budgets, different coins and different collections.
For anyone to react negatively to a TDN post about the coins he collects (6 figures or otherwise) is as distasteful as others who react negatively to persons who post about their "modern" from pocket change collection or most recent circulation find.
If a particular post is not of interest to you or if you react negatively to it (out of jealously, condescension, etc.) do not look at it or at least keep your trap shut.
A give and take on the pro and cons of hobby issues and differences is warranted and useful here. However, sniping and criticism of others because they do not collect what you do is simply out of line.
I like all areas of the hobby, some more than others. What I really like is being able to look at and learn about coins that are cool and make me say "WOW" (even if the coin is one I would never think of collecting; i.e. a 6 or 7 figure rarity, or a Mad Marty Cook Island x rated coin, or a 1968 toned clad quarter).
I enjoy all the threads whether they be about pocket change or $8,000,000 coins or anything inbetween. Maybe someday the pocket change searchers will be 6 figure buyers - you never know what the future holds-never say never. I have bought coins costing from 5 cents to $10,000 over the years and whether it be a 5 cent coin or a $5000 coin, if i need it and like it, i will buy it. I was on vacation and missed the thread in question. I don't care what others collect, i still find the threads interesting whether i collect the series or not. Over the years i probably collected it at one time or another...Not 6 figure coins though- but i still appreciate the information-maybe one day one will come my way. WELLL--I can dream can't I? Bob
Gone but not forgotten: IGWT, Speedy, Bear, BigE, HokieFore, John Burns, Russ, TahoeDale, Dahlonega, Astrorat, Stewart Blay, Oldhoopster, Ricko, Big Moose, Cardinal, CoinsAreFun.
I know I can't afford six figure coins nor can most people.
So I think the six-figure coin group is a really small percentage here - and there is a much higher percentage of people who are jealous of people who own six-figure coins.
I'd like to own a six-figure coin but I'll have to settle for just being able to look at them.
It's really sad that this thread ended up with more posts than the orginal "six figure" thread.
TDN, please resurrect that thread and put back the story. Like me, I suspect many of us on this board "collect" vicarously through the likes of you, Saintguru, Sunnywood and others with top-notch collections, and appreciate ya'll sharing them with us!!
<< <i>TDN, please resurrect that thread and put back the story. Like me, I suspect many of us on this board "collect" vicarously through the likes of you, Saintguru, Sunnywood and others with top-notch collections, and appreciate ya'll sharing them with us!! >>
This forum is place where a guy with a few circulated Morgans left to him by his grandfather can interact with somebody with six or seven figure coins. I see this as being positive.
Comments
Check out my PQ selection of Morgan & Peace Dollars, and more at:
WWW.PQDOLLARS.COM or WWW.GILBERTCOINS.COM
siliconvalleycoins.com
Actually, I NEVER notice who started a thread, who commented in it, or whose comments I'll be quoting.
I respond to what's written.
As I write this, I don't even remember your User Name.
So I guess if respond to a thread of yours in a way you don't like, I'll apologize in advance, cause as soon as I hit enter, this is ancient history.
<< <i>The turning point in that thread was the people who simply cannot control the urge to bash Laura no matter what she says. The most innocent comment from her is somehow transmuted by these people in to an attack on mom, hotdogs, and apple pie.
Russ, NCNE >>
BINGO Russ.....
And I bet 1/2 of them have no reason whatsoever besides the "I think I look cool factor" -- They should realize what they really look like...
So lets talk about Trade Dollars....
I can't remember a single instance to the contrary.
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
<< <i>I've hung around this forum for 5 years now. I've been [mostly] a gentleman in the CF. I've tried to only say complimentary things. I've ignored the ebay threads, the modern threads, the pocket change threads. If I don't collect what's in the thread, I don't disparage those that do.
I expect the same consideration back if I start a thread about the things that interest me. >>
I read your thread and thought it was interesting. It covered an unfamilar topic so I read it and did not post.
I think that the true collectors on this site do appreciate your posts (especially on very expensive coins). If you are true collector, then you are nothing but excited to see and hear about a 100k+ coin. (See all the threads about the '33 double eagles or the case of Dahlonega coins). To those "collectors" that become jealous when they see an interesting, rare, and expensive coin, maybe you should re-evaluate why you collect in the first place.
<< <i>Sounds fair to me.
Like pocket change threads, ebay threads, and Frankie threads, I had nothing to contribute to yours so I stayed out of it. It might have taken on a different tone if Stewart or Lloyd or JPK came around, rather than the usual Legend-bashing Posse™.
I was recently called out as an elitist for initiating one of my threads about gold coins. My sarcastic reply was that perhaps we should only discuss pocket change, lest we offend someone who does not have means to purchase coins. It would be a shame to become a least common denominator coin forum. >>
This is absolutely ridiculous. RYK has been one of the most helpful and patient members on this board. I have PM'ed him countless times and he always responds and is willing to help me out. RYK does collect an interesting series of coins and it is just too bad people are jealous.
An elitist, methinks not.....
My 1866 Philly Mint Set
Honesty is awesome and you are the appitimy of it.
The civility IMHO does not need to be extended to bad sellers on eBay.
An authorized PCGS dealer, and a contributor to the Red Book.
I'd need to move a decimal place (well actually two decimal places) to reach that level for a coin purchase-but I enjoy reading about most transactions-particularly when there's a "backstory" discussing motivation and decision making.
As long as a post is sincere (and your thread was)-"Good on ya".
Don
Ben
For anyone to react negatively to a TDN post about the coins he collects (6 figures or otherwise) is as distasteful as others who react negatively to persons who post about their "modern" from pocket change collection or most recent circulation find.
If a particular post is not of interest to you or if you react negatively to it (out of jealously, condescension, etc.) do not look at it or at least keep your trap shut.
A give and take on the pro and cons of hobby issues and differences is warranted and useful here. However, sniping and criticism of others because they do not collect what you do is simply out of line.
I like all areas of the hobby, some more than others. What I really like is being able to look at and learn about coins that are cool and make me say "WOW" (even if the coin is one I would never think of collecting; i.e. a 6 or 7 figure rarity, or a Mad Marty Cook Island x rated coin, or a 1968 toned clad quarter).
sell them to me...PLEASE!
Tradedollarnut has always been a high end contributor to these forums in my opinion.
Camelot
<< <i>Repeat after me....TDN is a class act. >>
consider it repeated
myCCset
I know I can't afford six figure coins nor can most people.
So I think the six-figure coin group is a really small percentage here - and there is a much higher percentage of people who are jealous of people who own six-figure coins.
I'd like to own a six-figure coin but I'll have to settle for just being able to look at them.
TDN, please resurrect that thread and put back the story. Like me, I suspect many of us on this board "collect" vicarously through the likes of you, Saintguru, Sunnywood and others with top-notch collections, and appreciate ya'll sharing them with us!!
<< <i>TDN, please resurrect that thread and put back the story. Like me, I suspect many of us on this board "collect" vicarously through the likes of you, Saintguru, Sunnywood and others with top-notch collections, and appreciate ya'll sharing them with us!! >>
myCCset