Options
Two damaged coins What to do?
TraderGio
Posts: 252
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 08561639 1051 1800 1/2C US Damage or ToolingBN
2 1 08561640 901374 1794 1C Head of 1794 US G06BN
3 1 08561641 1434 1798 1C 2nd Hair Style US G04BN
3 2 08561642 1434 1798 1C 2nd Hair Style US Enviromental DamageBN
3 3 08561643 1434 1798 1C 2nd Hair Style US AG03BN
4 1 08561644 2020 1858 1C Small Letters US AG03
5 1 08561645 3576 1864 2C Large Motto US VG08BN
6 1 08561646 3665 1851-O 3CS US VF25
Total Items: 8
Should I send these items elsewhere for regrading or should I keep them in their PCGS cases? Do they have numismatic value as graded?
2 1 08561640 901374 1794 1C Head of 1794 US G06BN
3 2 08561642 1434 1798 1C 2nd Hair Style US Enviromental DamageBN
1 1 08561639 1051 1800 1/2C US Damage or ToolingBN
2 1 08561640 901374 1794 1C Head of 1794 US G06BN
3 1 08561641 1434 1798 1C 2nd Hair Style US G04BN
3 2 08561642 1434 1798 1C 2nd Hair Style US Enviromental DamageBN
3 3 08561643 1434 1798 1C 2nd Hair Style US AG03BN
4 1 08561644 2020 1858 1C Small Letters US AG03
5 1 08561645 3576 1864 2C Large Motto US VG08BN
6 1 08561646 3665 1851-O 3CS US VF25
Total Items: 8
Should I send these items elsewhere for regrading or should I keep them in their PCGS cases? Do they have numismatic value as graded?
2 1 08561640 901374 1794 1C Head of 1794 US G06BN
3 2 08561642 1434 1798 1C 2nd Hair Style US Enviromental DamageBN
0
Comments
1 1 08561639 1051 1800 1/2C US Damage or ToolingBN
3 2 08561642 1434 1798 1C 2nd Hair Style US Enviromental DamageBN
<< <i>Correction...These are the damaged coins 1 1 08561639 1051 1800 1/2C US Damage or ToolingBN 3 2 08561642 1434 1798 1C 2nd Hair Style US Enviromental DamageBN >>
Depends on what damage you have. The one with the Tooling comment might be a problem. The other one is probably similar to one I have that has very minor pitting. It was returned "Environmental Damage". I plan to post a photo when I get my camera working better and get opinions.
--Jerry
<< <i> Should I send these items elsewhere for regrading or should I keep them in their PCGS cases? Do they have numismatic value as graded? >>
I didn't notice this in my first reply. Their "PCGS Case" is known as a bodybag (BB). The will be returned to you in their flip, ungraded, in full ignominy with a little blue piece of paper indicating what it says on your report.
That sure sounds offensive.
Mark
Is sending a coin to NCS considered unethical if they solve the problem and the coin ends up in a nice NGC holder?