Options
Coin image ownership
OK, hypothetical q
I take a picture of a coin
I sell the coin.
Do I still own the image and can use it as I wish (of course not counting fraud)?
Does the new owner of the coin have any rights to the picture?
If they ask "hey Lou can I have a picture" and I email it to them without making any claims to my ownership, do they THEN have rights to the picture?
Gracias a todos
I take a picture of a coin
I sell the coin.
Do I still own the image and can use it as I wish (of course not counting fraud)?
Does the new owner of the coin have any rights to the picture?
If they ask "hey Lou can I have a picture" and I email it to them without making any claims to my ownership, do they THEN have rights to the picture?
Gracias a todos
Philately will get you nowhere....
0
Comments
<< <i>Do I still own the image and can use it as I wish (of course not counting fraud)? >>
Yes.
<< <i>Does the new owner of the coin have any rights to the picture? >>
Not unless you grant permission.
<< <i>If they ask "hey Lou can I have a picture" and I email it to them without making any claims to my ownership, do they THEN have rights to the picture? >>
Unless you explicitly transfer the rights, you always own them.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>So when people post Newp pics using the sellers pics, there is some type of law broken here?......Unless a pic is copyrighted, isnt it up for grabs ? >>
Technically? Probably so. The reality is that most of the time, the copyright owner won't care if you bought the coin from them and you're not using it for commercial purposes.
The main reasons a copyright owner who sold the coin that's imaged would care is if (a) they are professional photographers, (b) you are trying to use their work for your own profit or (c) you are using their images in a scam attempt.
Having said all that, technically yeah, it's probably not kosher to use those images. But under normal circumstances if you post their images on a coin you bought from them, almost no one would care.
<< <i>Unless a pic is copyrighted, isnt it up for grabs ? >>
Copyright is automatic.
Russ, NCNE
Best,
Sunnywood
Sunnywood's Rainbow-Toned Morgans (Retired)
Sunnywood's Barber Quarters (Retired)
<< <i>I must say I find that concept somewhat annoying ... if I pay for it, I think I should own it !!! >>
When you hire a wedding photographer, you're paying for it but they still own the rights. It's the same throughout the photography industry.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Interesting note, even though you pay PCGS for True View™ images, they say that they retain all copyrights in the image. I must say I find that concept somewhat annoying ... if I pay for it, I think I should own it !!! However, PCGS also retains the images in their database for use in with their cert verification service, which I think is great. So I guess I don't mind them retaining the right to use the images for their other purposes ... but I should certainly have unrestricted rights to use the images for my own purposes as well !! >>
My understanding is that *you* can use them pretty much any way you like, but that right can not be granted to others or transferred as it would if you owned the copyright. Am I off base there?
If someone takes a picture of you, he owns the rights to the picture but he cannot use the picture unless he has your pemission, right?
San Diego, CA
<< <i>If someone takes a picture of you, he owns the rights to the picture but he cannot use the picture unless he has your pemission, right? >>
Not necessary so. But if the image is to be used for a commercial purpose, you likely have rights.
<< <i>If someone takes a picture of you, he owns the rights to the picture but he cannot use the picture unless he has your pemission, right? >>
That depends. If the picture was shot in a public place, no the photographer does not need to have permission from the subject to publish the image. Semi-public, it's iffy. Private they generally would need permission.
Russ, NCNE
Dont use my pic to defraud anyone
Dont try to make any compensation from my pic (if I know you own the coin and you ask me nice if you can use it in a sale I'll probably say "OK" unless I start taking pics commercially)
Dont say you took the pic when you didnt
<< <i>If the picture was shot in a public place, no the photographer does not need to have permission from the subject to publish the image. Semi-public, it's iffy. Private they generally would need permission. >>
Yes, this is why paparazzi are able to profit from their photos, except for those instances where the celebrity is able to show an intrusion on privacy (i.e., shooting over a wall to get a photo of celebrity sunning topless by her own pool).
-Amanda
I'm a YN working on a type set!
My Buffalo Nickel Website Home of the Quirky Buffaloes Collection!
Proud member of the CUFYNA
<< <i>When I buy the coin the right to use the pictures is mine too. >>
Without permission, you have no rights to use of the image.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i> When I buy the coin the right to use the pictures is mine too. >>
No. The copyright belongs to the artist not the owner of the pictured property.
If someone takes your picture who owns the image
you or the photographer
Jim
Menomonee Falls Wisconsin USA
<< <i>If someone takes your picture who owns the image >>
This question was addressed earlier in the thread.
<< <i>So when people post Newp pics using the sellers pics, there is some type of law broken here?......Unless a pic is copyrighted, isnt it up for grabs ? >>
It depends on how it is posted. If you post a link to the sellers image then it is most likely OK because he still has the image and control of it. If you post the picture here using the img tags and linking to the url where he has the image stored that is a litle more questionable but probably still ok because he still has control of the image. If you copy the image and store it somewhere else and then link or post it from there using the img tags then you have definitely violated his copyright unless you have his permission or he has granted you the rights to the image.
Due to my photographic skills, this is, and always will be a non-issue for me.
My posts viewed
since 8/1/6
John
SFC, US Army (Ret.) 1974-1994
<< <i>
<< <i>When I buy the coin the right to use the pictures is mine too. >>
Without permission, you have no rights to use of the image.
Russ, NCNE >>
I think Russ is correct here, as much as I would like to agree with Laura.
Here's an example of a coin I bought on the basis of an image and a good relationship with a full time dealer who offered it as a proof 65.
His image:
My first images from a scanner show pretty much how it looked the first time I laid eyes on it:
My best digital camera images of the same coin, after NGC bodybagged it as "polished":
... and my most recent image of it, entombed in a slab with an opinion by an expert on Seated Liberty Coins:
I add that the coin has not been altered in any way since the seller took his pictures of it.
If I inherited the right to the seller's original image of the coin simply by purchasing it, then I could use his image to drag his name in the mud. He has told me he's too busy to read this forum, so I cross my fingers that he won't get upset at me for this post. We are still good firends, despite this dime.
Eric
Chicolini: Mint? No, no, I no like a mint. Uh - what other flavor you got?
Does the new owner of the coin have any rights to the picture?
If they ask "hey Lou can I have a picture" and I email it to them without making any claims to my ownership, do they THEN have rights to the picture?"
Yes, no and it depends on what you mean by rights.
De nada.
Will’sProoflikes
I had no problems duplicating it in Tijuana.
professional studio portrait of yourself from grammar school
Can that original studio use your image without your permisson?
San Diego, CA
<< <i>So, if you take a picture of a photographer taking a picture of you holding the coin, and you just bought a coin from him, who owns the picture and the image of the coin? >>
The IRS.
1/2 Cents
U.S. Revenue Stamps