Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

Can anybody name even a single example where PCGS did not stand behind the authenticity of their coi

RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭
I didn't think so.

Russ, NCNE

Comments

  • Options
    I certailny hope there is no such incident. But that begs the question as to whether PCGS customers are entitled to a meaningful guaranty of authenticity.

  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭


    << <i>I certailny hope there is no such incident. >>



    There isn't. Which, of course, makes your little crusade nothing more than the actions of a childish troll.

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options


    << <i>

    << <i>I certailny hope there is no such incident. >>



    There isn't. Which, of course, makes your little crusade nothing more than the actions of a childish troll.

    Russ, NCNE >>





    I take it you do not believe PCGS customers are entitled to a meaningful guaranty of authenticity.
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭


    << <i>I take it you do not believe PCGS customers are entitled to a meaningful guaranty of authenticity. >>



    We already have one. Every customer who has ever submitted under the guarantee has been compensated. What was your point, again?

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options


    << <i>

    << <i>I take it you do not believe PCGS customers are entitled to a meaningful guaranty of authenticity. >>



    We already have one. Every customer who has ever submitted under the guarantee has been compensated. What was your point, again?

    Russ, NCNE >>



    Having been referred to as a blowhard, I will not reiterate a point that has been articulated ad nauseam on these boards for someone who apparantly cannot grasp simple concepts.
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭
    Ah, so you have not point. As expected.

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    foodudefoodude Posts: 3,591 ✭✭✭
    Nope. Over the last 20 years, I have occasionally had issues/problems come up, and PCGS has always taken care of them. (Note, I have not had an authenticity issue).
    Greg Allen Coins, LLC Show Schedule: https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/573044/our-show-schedule-updated-10-2-16 Authorized dealer for NGC, PCGS, CAC, and QA. Member of PNG, RTT (Founding Platinum Member), FUN, MSNS, and NCBA (formerly ICTA); Life Member of ANA and CSNS. NCBA Board member. "GA3" on CCE.
  • Options
    mrearlygoldmrearlygold Posts: 17,862 ✭✭✭
    Many millions of dollars over the years and never an issue of authenticity.
  • Options
    I thought there was a question regarding the 1903 Micro "O" Morgan Dollar ?
  • Options
    jdimmickjdimmick Posts: 10,001 ✭✭✭✭✭
    The only coin that I have actually seen in person which was an altered date where PCGS overlooked it was a 1950-d Jefferson altered from a 59-d. It was owned by an alabama coin dealer, he had it at an ANA show a few years back. I am sure that if it were sent back to PCGS , it would have been honored, but becuase the value is so insignificant, the dealer kept it intack as a show piece. Becuase of its very low value, PCGS probably didnt look at it that close to begin with and just graded it. I cant remember the grade, maybe ms-64??

    jim
  • Options
    CUSTOMER BILL OF RIGHTS

    #6. GUARANTEED GRADE AND AUTHENTICITY. As a owner of the PCGS-graded coin, the Customer will have the benefit of PCGS' Guarantee of Grade and Authenticity..."

    That's all I need.



    Jerry
  • Options


    << <i>CUSTOMER BILL OF RIGHTS

    #6. GUARANTEED GRADE AND AUTHENTICITY. As a owner of the PCGS-graded coin, the Customer will have the benefit of PCGS' Guarantee of Grade and Authenticity..."

    That's all I need.



    Jerry >>



    Well, not good enough for MBT. He thinks that is something PCGS can deny in court later. He apparently thinks that is not legally binding.

    MBT doesn't seem to know that the statement #6 is an admission and will prove the guarantee exists.

    The ONLY way it can be illusory is if it isn't a guarantee of authenticity, and they can plausibly say, under oath, in court, that they didn't mean to guarantee authenticity and the court would have to believe they didn't mean authenticity. What are the chances?

    Illusory promises are ones that never have to be performed. This promise (guarantee of authenticity) can be sued on successfully and therefore is not illusory. I do not see anyone at PCGS foolish enough to deny the guarantee.

    Once you write that you guarantee something, it is all over but arguing about how much money to pay when something goes wrong.


    Next, MBT wants a "one size fits all" explanation of how much money is guaranteed to be returned.

    Well, once you have determined that PCGS is responsible for what they slab, the sole question is money. Evey coin is unique. Every counterfeit has an unique set of circumstances surrounding it.

    I believe each remedy for this type of guarantee must be decided as it comes up. I think PCGS agrees.


    Please, MBT write out exactly what the guarantee should say, since you know all about this.

    I like the simplicity of what PCGS wrote. Let's see what you have.
  • Options


    << <i>[
    Please, MBT write out exactly what the guarantee should say, since you know all about this.

    I like the simplicity of what PCGS wrote. Let's see what you have. >>





    I already have provided simple suggested wording with the help of another forum member --see post :"A meaningful guaranty of authenticity--a challenge to PCGS!!!!!"
  • Options
    MyqqyMyqqy Posts: 9,777 ✭
    Ah, so you have not point. As expected.

    When one has no life, one usually has no point either....
    My style is impetuous, my defense is impregnable !
  • Options
    coindeucecoindeuce Posts: 13,534 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Russ, would the counterfeit 1909-S VDB in the PCGS-63 BN holder that I saw last year at the A.N.A. Summer Seminar Counterfeit & Altered Coin Detection course be a good test? It was in the hands of a very high profile dealer who conclusively proved to a classroom of numismatists that it was a counterfeit.

    "Everything is on its way to somewhere. Everything." - George Malley, Phenomenon
    http://www.american-legacy-coins.com

  • Options
    TACloughTAClough Posts: 1,598 ✭


    << <i>Russ, would the counterfeit 1909-S VDB in the PCGS-63 BN holder that I saw last year at the A.N.A. Summer Seminar Counterfeit & Altered Coin Detection course be a good test? It was in the hands of a very high profile dealer who conclusively proved to a classroom of numismatists that it was a counterfeit. >>



    If the above mentioned coin was re - submitted to PCGS in the PCGS holder, something tells me that Mr. Hall would pay market value for the coin or find another 1909S VDB in same or better condition for a replacement. What more of or better GUARANTEE could we ask for?image
  • Options
    jabbajabba Posts: 3,177 ✭✭✭✭✭
    If some one has a problem with the PCGS authenticity then take it up with PCGS? If after talking to PCGS you are not happy with them then dont buy PCGS graded coins or have them grade your coins! But coming here and being a whiner pig about it is a wast of every one time, please go away!
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭


    << <i>Russ, would the counterfeit 1909-S VDB in the PCGS-63 BN holder that I saw last year at the A.N.A. Summer Seminar Counterfeit & Altered Coin Detection course be a good test? It was in the hands of a very high profile dealer who conclusively proved to a classroom of numismatists that it was a counterfeit. >>



    If it's a coin that is being used in the ANA grading seminars, then it's obvious that the owner has never sent it back to PCGS under the guarantee program. If they did, I have no doubt that PCGS would take care of it.

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    DNADaveDNADave Posts: 7,350 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I am only posting to this because when I post, threads tend to die.


    DIE thread DIE.
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭
    Hey, don't be trying to kill my thread! We need Laura to post, so it'll zoom to 100 and beyond.

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    check their stats i think they speak for them-selfs and clearly answers any doubting thomas or any major big time collector.

    IF IN DOUBT GO WITH OUT, OR IN THIS CASE SOME WHERE ELSE YOU TRUST FOR GRADING
    "SAY NO TO SULFIDE MINING"
    US ARMY WITH THE BIG RED 1, MI NATL. GAURD--1982-1997
  • Options
    MyqqyMyqqy Posts: 9,777 ✭
    DIE thread DIE.

    image
    My style is impetuous, my defense is impregnable !
  • Options
    JulioJulio Posts: 2,501 ✭
    Not me and I strongly believe that is why they are highly respected and still in business. jws

    Proofs in the pudding. jws
    image
  • Options
    sinin1sinin1 Posts: 7,500 ✭
    how about Laura's 20K gold piece or Jade's large cent?
  • Options
    LucyBopLucyBop Posts: 14,001 ✭✭✭
    I think every graded Kennedy Hairyhead coin is a farce and sham!
    imageBe Bop A Lula!!
    "Senorita HepKitty"
    "I want a real cool Kitty from Hepcat City, to stay in step with me" - Bill Carter
  • Options
    I already posted this in another thread, same subject, different header. the subject that would not go away.


    A short time ago PCGS admitted that it had slabbed around 100 or so counterfeit New Orleans Mint Morgan's of the Small O variety. They made a public offer to purchase all those slabbed coins back at the current fair market value then established for them.

    Thus not only did they discover the items slabbed prior were spurious, they self admitted it and they purchased them back at current trends. What more evidence does one need of their willingness to do so?

    "To know the road ahead, ask those coming back"
  • Options
    Conder101Conder101 Posts: 10,536 ✭


    << <i>We already have one. Every customer who has ever submitted under the guarantee has been compensated. What was your point, again? >>


    You can't submit under a guarantee that doesn't esist. But you can say "hey this is a fake what are you going to do about it?". And then the company can decide if it is to their greater benefit to ignore you or to stand behind their product. To date, and to their credit, PCGS has ALWAYS stood behind their product. But at any time, since they DON'T have a guarantee of authenticity, they can decide not to. Just because they have done something in the past that they didn't have to do does not mean they have to do so in the future. In 1989 PCGS, in order to protect the reputation of their product, bought back all of the fake PCGS slabs presented to them. That does NOT obligate them to do the same thing if I were to start flooding the market with fake PCGS slabs with over graded 1893-S dollars in them (say I call them all MS-68.) or some other mega priced coin.



    << <i>something tells me that Mr. Hall would pay market value for the coin or find another 1909S VDB in same or better condition for a replacement. What more of or better GUARANTEE could we ask for? >>


    "Something tells me" Oh yeah, I guess you can't get a better guarantee than that. image



    << <i>But coming here and being a whiner pig about it is a wast of every one time, please go away! >>


    Amazing, they don't want advocates for consumer protection, and they DON'T want a written protection in the matter of authenticity. Maybe they would be happier if PCGS got rid of the written grade guarantee as well.
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭


    << <i>To date, and to their credit, PCGS has ALWAYS stood behind their product. >>



    Game, set, match.

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    Many members still want to know , not that, it appears that PCGS has ALWAYS stood behind their product----but how far behind !
  • Options
    BAJJERFANBAJJERFAN Posts: 31,694 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>That does NOT obligate them to do the same thing if I were to start flooding the market with fake PCGS slabs with over graded 1893-S dollars in them (say I call them all MS-68.) or some other mega priced coin. >>



    Why would anyone even think of expecting them to do that?
    theknowitalltroll;
  • Options
    19Lyds19Lyds Posts: 26,524 ✭✭✭✭
    I just love it when Russ beats up MBT.............. yet one more time!! image

    I have complete confidence in PCGS's authenticity guarantee! They did not have to come out with the notification regarding the recent discovery of the "micro o" Morgans but they did and it cost them a whole bunch of money!

    If anybody has a problem with PCGS's grading or authenticity guarantee's then they just shouldn't be buying PCGS slabs or submitting coins for grading to PCGS!

    Now.........................hit him again Russ......maybe he'll stop trying to cause trouble and just go directly to HRH!

    I decided to change calling the bathroom the John and renamed it the Jim. I feel so much better saying I went to the Jim this morning.



    The name is LEE!
  • Options


    << <i>[Amazing, they don't want advocates for consumer protection, and they DON'T want a written protection in the matter of authenticity. Maybe they would be happier if PCGS got rid of the written grade guarantee as well. >>







    I, too, am perplexed by the attitude of many on these boards.
  • Options
    Conder101Conder101 Posts: 10,536 ✭


    << <i><< To date, and to their credit, PCGS has ALWAYS stood behind their product. >>

    Game, set, match. >>


    But to whom? No one has ever claimed that they haven't stood behind them, just that they have no written obligation to do so. And they can chose to do otherwise at any time. So the above quote does not justify the "We don't want a written guarantee" crowd.



    << <i><< That does NOT obligate them to do the same thing if I were to start flooding the market with fake PCGS slabs with over graded 1893-S dollars in them (say I call them all MS-68.) or some other mega priced coin. >>

    Why would anyone even think of expecting them to do that? >>


    Well everyone seems to think that since they have bought back fake coins in their slabs they will always do so so we don't need a guarantee. Well by the same logic, since they bought the earlier fake slabs they would naturally be expected to buy my fake slabs as well. Of course obviously it is silly to expect them to do the latter, so why would they be expected to do the former?
  • Options
    JcarneyJcarney Posts: 3,154 ✭


    << <i>Having been referred to as a blowhard, I will not reiterate a point that has been articulated ad nauseam on these boards for someone who apparantly cannot grasp simple concepts. >>



    Simple concepts. Such as the one that PCGS has always stood behind every single submission with regard to authenticity? Seems like a simple concept to me.
    “When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic.” — Benjamin Franklin


    My icon IS my coin. It is a gem 1949 FBL Franklin.
  • Options


    << <i>

    << <i>To date, and to their credit, PCGS has ALWAYS stood behind their product. >>



    Game, set, match.

    Russ, NCNE >>





    Hold on a minute--who appointed you head linesman??

    I don't believe the game is over yet, not by a longshot--like any investor adviser will tell you "past results are not necessarily indicative of future performance."

    I have no reason to believe PCGS will not continue to stand behind their product--but I cannot understand why they have not clarified the published "fuzzy" so-called "guarantee" of authenticity. If they are not engaging in an intentional "Where's Waldo", I beleive they should say what they mean and mean what they say.

    If you prefer to take it on blind faith, that's your perogative. I'd prefer something more concrete.
  • Options
    JcarneyJcarney Posts: 3,154 ✭


    << <i>I am only posting to this because when I post, threads tend to die. >>



    Nah, that would be me Dave. Just watch. image
    “When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic.” — Benjamin Franklin


    My icon IS my coin. It is a gem 1949 FBL Franklin.
  • Options
    << CUSTOMER BILL OF RIGHTS

    #6. GUARANTEED GRADE AND AUTHENTICITY. As a owner of the PCGS-graded coin, the Customer will have the benefit of PCGS' Guarantee of Grade and Authenticity..."



    Is this not a guarantee of authenticity?


    You can't submit under a guarantee that doesn't esist. But you can say "hey this is a fake what are you going to do about it?". And then the company can decide if it is to their greater benefit to ignore you or to stand behind their product. To date, and to their credit, PCGS has ALWAYS stood behind their product. But at any time, since they DON'T have a guarantee of authenticity, they can decide not to.

    And then you can sue PCGS. And, once they state they do guarantee, as the above quote, exactly how will they deny it in court?


    What would you do if your car's manufacturer refused to take care of a problem that is under warrantee? How about when anyone doesn't honor a guarantee?


    In 1989 PCGS, in order to protect the reputation of their product, bought back all of the fake PCGS slabs presented to them. That does NOT obligate them to do the same thing if I were to start flooding the market with fake PCGS slabs with over graded 1893-S dollars in them (say I call them all MS-68.) or some other mega priced coin.

    Why should they guarantee "fake" slabs AT ALL? If they were willing to do that to protect their reputation, then what makes you think they won't homor genuine slabs with fake coins in them?

    What kind of analogy is that?

    Any guarantee is only as good as the issuer.

    Where do you get the notion that there is no guarantee?

    Do you just write stuff and no even look at the other info?



    #6. GUARANTEED GRADE AND AUTHENTICITY. As a owner of the PCGS-graded coin, the Customer will have the benefit of PCGS' Guarantee of Grade and Authenticity..."

    Is a written guarantee of authenticity. Ask any lawyer or judge.


    So go ahead, what exactly is it you would like added? Be specific.

  • Options


    << <i>
    So go ahead, what exactly is it you would like added? Be specific. >>





    Been there, done that with the help of another member--see post:
    A meaningful guaranty of authenticity--a challenge to PCGS!!!!!
  • Options


    << <i>

    << <i>
    So go ahead, what exactly is it you would like added? Be specific. >>





    Been there, done that with the help of another member--see post:
    A meaningful guaranty of authenticity--a challenge to PCGS!!!!! >>



    Already heard from you, and your added verbiage adds nothing to the guarantee that is in effect.

    If they refuse to honor the guarantee in effect to your satisfaction, then you would have to sue, right? Show me a guarantee that would not have to be sued upon if the aggrieved party is not satisfied with the money offered by the maker of the guarantee.

    What do you want, a guarantee that you would never have to sue to enforce?

    Any time that PCGS refuses to correct their problem to your satisfaction, you might have to go to court. How would adding those words prevent going to court or make it easier to win?


    Either a coin is counterfeit or it is not. The ONLY argument PCGS could make in court under the guarantee they have now is damages: "How much does the owner of the coin get"

    Show me where you can write a guarantee for a product that varies in price like coins do that also eliminates the need for the two sides to either agree on the issue of damages or for the owner to have to prove damages in court if necessary.

    Go ahead, because so long as you can't do it, you have no right to demand that PCGS do it. It can't be done.


  • Options

    imageimage
  • Options
    TomBTomB Posts: 23,357 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I'm not clear on this point, so this is an honest question; is it believed that the guarantee extends to designations on coins?
    Thomas Bush Numismatics & Numismatic Photography

    In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson

    image
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭


    << <i>is it believed that the guarantee extends to designations on coins? >>



    If you're defining designations as such things like Full Steps, FBL, Cameo, etc., yes it does.

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    TomBTomB Posts: 23,357 ✭✭✭✭✭
    If that is the case, what was the resolution of the 1945 Merc that Mark Feld bought sight-unseen in a PCGS MS65FB holder? If I remember correctly, the coin had no bands at all and was removed from the holder by PCGS, after being submitted for review and compensation, and was reholdered as MS65 without any compensation being offered. The PCGS stance, again if I recall correctly, was that this was a case of a mechanical error and that the difference in value (approximately $5,000 vs $30) was not the responsibility of PCGS.

    If I recall the details somewhat correctly, and I have not looked them up, and if PCGS never ended up compensating Mark Feld, then their guarantee either does not cover designations or is not as sound as many have assumed. Again, please note that I do not know the final resolution to this matter and they may very well have covered the loss.
    Thomas Bush Numismatics & Numismatic Photography

    In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson

    image
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭
    That's surprising, since they just paid out about $10 grand on a Jefferson Nickel that was designated FS and wasn't.

    Edited to add: Of course, that's not an authenticity issue, which is the topic of this thread. It's a grading issue.

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options


    << <i>If that is the case, what was the resolution of the 1945 Merc that Mark Feld bought sight-unseen in a PCGS MS65FB holder? If I remember correctly, the coin had no bands at all and was removed from the holder by PCGS, after being submitted for review and compensation, and was reholdered as MS65 without any compensation being offered. The PCGS stance, again if I recall correctly, was that this was a case of a mechanical error and that the difference in value (approximately $5,000 vs $30) was not the responsibility of PCGS.

    If I recall the details somewhat correctly, and I have not looked them up, and if PCGS never ended up compensating Mark Feld, then their guarantee either does not cover designations or is not as sound as many have assumed. Again, please note that I do not know the final resolution to this matter and they may very well have covered the loss. >>



    And the resolution of that issue would affect the GRADE guarantee, which is so specific, not the AUTHENTICATION guarantee that is the purpose of the thread. It does however, absolutely show that the specific guarantee is only as good as the people behind it.


    "Can anybody name even a single example where PCGS did not stand behind the authenticity of their coins?"

  • Options
    TomBTomB Posts: 23,357 ✭✭✭✭✭
    To be honest, I have no clue as to the resolution of the dispute, so they very well might have paid for the coin. However, I do not remember anything posted on the issue after Mark posted a long write up of the events and at that point it appeared PCGS would not budge from their conclusion that they were not liable for what they deemed a mechanical error.
    Thomas Bush Numismatics & Numismatic Photography

    In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson

    image
  • Options


    << <i>...... at that point it appeared PCGS would not budge from their conclusion that they were not liable for what they deemed a mechanical error. >>




    All the more reason for a definative guaranty!
  • Options
    coinguy1coinguy1 Posts: 13,484 ✭✭✭
    To the best of my recollection, this was the resolution with respect to the 1945 (no-bands) Mercury Dime transaction from years ago:

    I was asked by PCGS to try to get my credit card company to reverse the Paypal charge, which I, and they did. There was a difference of several hundred dollars which I was initially out (I think that was due the difference between what I had in my Paypal account at the time I made the purchase vs. the full cost of the coin, but am not positive).

    The company I worked for at the time was eventually reimbursed the several hundred(?) dollars difference by PCGS.

    However, frankly, I didn't think I should have been asked to reverse the credit card charge, the reimbursement process was much more difficult and took far longer than it should have, and I felt as if the original submitter of the coin (who had tried to sell it at least twice previously, knowing it wasn't FB) was treated way too leniently.

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file