Options
A matter of ethics/opinions wanted
Here's the situation. You post a coin on the BST boards. You recieve an email and a PM(from two differnt people), about an hour apart requesting pictures. You send pictures to both and tell both potential buyers the situation. Do you give the first responder the option to buy the coin, or to you sell it to the first one to say YES?
Thanks, Wayne
Thanks, Wayne
0
Comments
<< <i>Here's the situation. You post a coin on the BST boards. You recieve an email and a PM(from two differnt people), about an hour apart requesting pictures. You send pictures to both and tell both potential buyers the situation. Do you give the first responder the option to buy the coin, or to you sell it to the first one to say YES?
Thanks, Wayne >>
I would sell the first person to say they are a buyer of the coin.
- Marcus Tullius Cicero, 106-43 BC
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>If the image you want to see is not posted, please call and we will move that one to the front of the box and put it on hold until you can see it. >>
I have just asked him a question before, he answered and when I called to order the coin...... he didn't know it was me at first and said the coin was on hold until he heard back from an email inquiry. Not many dealers will do this, they all start shaking with greed and take the first dollar bill waved in front of their mug. Might not be anything wrong with it, but it's not a hard choice who will get my business in the long run.
<< <i>First contact gets right of first refusal.
Russ, NCNE >>
By asking about the coin, they have expressed the first interest in buying the coin. They should have first shot... think of it like you were at a coin show... say I see Russ standing at a table looking through proof sets with a sign clearly displaying the price of each set, and I look over his shoulder and he's holding a set with the absolute most awesomest, moosiest AH Kennedy ever! And I say to the dealer, "I'll buy that set." Do you think the dealer is going to sell it to me?
42/92
<< <i>
<< <i>First contact gets right of first refusal.
Russ, NCNE >>
By asking about the coin, they have expressed the first interest in buying the coin. They should have first shot... think of it like you were at a coin show... say I see Russ standing at a table looking through proof sets with a sign clearly displaying the price of each set, and I look over his shoulder and he's holding a set with the absolute most awesomest, moosiest AH Kennedy ever! And I say to the dealer, "I'll buy that set." Do you think the dealer is going to sell it to me? >>
Not necessarily.
<< <i>you tell both responders the price you want and the first to respond telling you they want it at your price, ITS THERES. >>
That is the standard practice on virtually every similar buy/sell forum on the internet. Interest does not equate to willingness to spend money. Speaking as a former moderator of such a forum, I wouldn't back the claim of an interested party if they weren't the first to actually offer money.
<< <i>Asking for a photo does not equal 'dibs' IMO. >>
True, but in this case that's what both interested parties had done.
Russ, NCNE
I typically offer to place an item on hold for a set time period (24 hours/whatever) when a client asks for an image. If I receive a subsequent request from another client, I then let him know that the item is on hold for the first person until the hold period has expired.
" Now that I've got you boy's attention, check this out on ebay !
They'll probably never talk to you again, but if you got two who want it, it is PRIMETIME baby.
edit to add:
Just throwin in that greed factor, Russ
<< <i>True, but in this case that's what both interested parties had done. >>
Disagree. I read it as 2 people asked for PICTURES.
2nd one said he wanted it. Now, tell him someone else wanted a PICTURE so he can't have it unless that guy drops out. What if 1st contact doesn't want it after seeing pic? Then 2nd "contact" has spent his money on gumdrops.
<< <i>I typically offer to place an item on hold for a set time period (24 hours/whatever) when a client asks for an image. If I receive a subsequent request from another client, I then let him know that the item is on hold for the first person until the hold period has expired. >>
This is good business sense. I've been emailed from shows, called on the phone and offered coins. I thought I did pretty good by responding within two hours, only to be told it was SOLD. Yes, they got their money, but probably lost a customer in the long run. I know, they don't care it's a "HOT" market. But not forever and some low-life collectors such as myself remember these guys. I do have to say that once I explained my position to one of them, they tried to make it right after and waited for my response.
Some folks need to realize that some people are not sitting by a PC or a phone at all times.
https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/quarters/washington-quarters-major-sets/washington-quarters-date-set-circulation-strikes-1932-present/publishedset/209923
https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/quarters/washington-quarters-major-sets/washington-quarters-date-set-circulation-strikes-1932-present/album/209923
<< <i>Like the whorehouse, It's "first come, first served" >>
<< <i>Yep--just like a whorehouse -- The first guy that says he's interested, not just jerking around.
Interesting analogies
As to the coin, the first to say I would like to purchase it would be the one who owns it. A sale would possibly be lost if I told that interested buyer that I needed to get back to them later.
If your gonna take longer to decide ......well ...linger all you want ...there's another buyer.......JMO.............
Money seperates the buyers from the lookers
My posts viewed
since 8/1/6