I've noticed that more often than not the estimated values by the auction houses are low. Sometimes they're not even in the ballpark. At a recent auction there was a gold Philippine coin, 1880 I believe that was estimated at around $5,000 and went for almost $50,000.
I've bought a similar one in PCGS 66 for around $1200 so the estimates not totally off IMO. Of coarse with all the "money blue" and the clean cheek--a bidding war could start easy---
Let me go on the record as stating this coin will easily clear $1000 bucks......I could see it going for more than $1500....common date or not the color looks uncommon in the picture so if it looks anything like the image in hand........$1500 is a reasonable price for a toned coin specialist to pay
If I looks nothing like the picture and the floor bidding is non existant then.....who knows? I personally like it and would love to add it to my holdings if I had some spare cash
<< <i>Let me go on the record as stating this coin will easily clear $1000 bucks......I could see it going for more than $1500....common date or not the color looks uncommon in the picture so if it looks anything like the image in hand........$1500 is a reasonable price for a toned coin specialist to pay >>
<< <i>Let me go on the record as stating this coin will easily clear $1000 bucks......I could see it going for more than $1500....common date or not the color looks uncommon in the picture so if it looks anything like the image in hand........$1500 is a reasonable price for a toned coin specialist to pay >>
Realized $900.
Russ, NCNE >>
Well I guess it didn't measure up to the image......hence the reason I said if the floor bidders aren't touching it then it's not what we are seeing in the image. That's the problem with some end rollers........I have bought a few that looked great in the image and then when you get it in hand...you have to angle it a certain way in the light to find the sweet spot....................that could be the case with this coins but I'm only speculating.
Oh and Russ....maybe copy the whole exceprt from my post not what suits you to try to make your point.
<< <i>Well I guess it didn't measure up to the image......hence the reason I said if the floor bidders aren't touching it then it's not what we are seeing in the image. >>
<< <i>Well I guess it didn't measure up to the image......hence the reason I said if the floor bidders aren't touching it then it's not what we are seeing in the image. >>
Yes, you hedged quite nicely.
Russ, NCNE >>
Why thank you
Honestly....you have bought and sold enough toners to know how a coin can look completely different in an image than in hand.......example...Bondman22's coins I don't know if that's the case here but knowing what I am paying for toners lately I would consider this coin a bargain at $900 if it has that type of color and pop in hand....................the other alterative is that we might be seeing the start of a cool down on toners............oh I only wish that were true
Comments
I wonder if I called them maybe they would let me BUY IT NOW for $800 ???
TC71
<< <i>I've bought a similar one in PCGS 66 for around $1200 so the estimates not totally off IMO. >>
I agree. I don't see it bringing more that $1K. Common date, one-sided, not a monster or an uber-grade.
Russ, NCNE
Rainbow Toned 1923-D $20 St. Gaudens !!
<< <i>I paid that much for this PCGS MS64. >>
The 1886 is a tougher date for nice color.
Russ, NCNE
If I looks nothing like the picture and the floor bidding is non existant then.....who knows? I personally like it and would love to add it to my holdings if I had some spare cash
<< <i>Let me go on the record as stating this coin will easily clear $1000 bucks......I could see it going for more than $1500....common date or not the color looks uncommon in the picture so if it looks anything like the image in hand........$1500 is a reasonable price for a toned coin specialist to pay >>
Realized $900.
Russ, NCNE
Yeah, my bid was $850 before the juice......................
<< <i>
<< <i>Let me go on the record as stating this coin will easily clear $1000 bucks......I could see it going for more than $1500....common date or not the color looks uncommon in the picture so if it looks anything like the image in hand........$1500 is a reasonable price for a toned coin specialist to pay >>
Realized $900.
Russ, NCNE >>
Well I guess it didn't measure up to the image......hence the reason I said if the floor bidders aren't touching it then it's not what we are seeing in the image. That's the problem with some end rollers........I have bought a few that looked great in the image and then when you get it in hand...you have to angle it a certain way in the light to find the sweet spot....................that could be the case with this coins but I'm only speculating.
Oh and Russ....maybe copy the whole exceprt from my post not what suits you to try to make your point.
<< <i>Well I guess it didn't measure up to the image......hence the reason I said if the floor bidders aren't touching it then it's not what we are seeing in the image. >>
Yes, you hedged quite nicely.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>Well I guess it didn't measure up to the image......hence the reason I said if the floor bidders aren't touching it then it's not what we are seeing in the image. >>
Yes, you hedged quite nicely.
Russ, NCNE >>
Why thank you
Honestly....you have bought and sold enough toners to know how a coin can look completely different in an image than in hand.......example...Bondman22's coins