I need help determining a price for an 1846 dime

DIMEMAN · February 22, 2006 3:46AM

It's a PCGS25.

The PCGS price guide list Fine at 144 and EF at 1000. If you split that a VF20 would be 428. And then split for 25 and 30 and 35. Each one of those would be a 190 jump.

Making a VF25 428 + 190 = 618

What does anybody think?????????

Thanks Jon

Julian · February 22, 2006 4:02AM

The CDN lists VF @ 280 theorhetically making a VF-25 retailing about 375-400. The Reiver coin was listed a s VG, damaged and realized 253. The price that you listed may actually be a fair retail price. It is a very scarce coin.

DeputyPud · February 22, 2006 4:12AM

Heritage lists wholesale value at $408 for VF25.
I didn't see any sales recently with an 1846 in VF25, but the last sale for VF30 brought $609.50 (fees included). That was in an ANACS slab.

DIMEMAN · February 22, 2006 4:21AM

Thanks guys, you have been a big help. Based on the numbers here I think I will offer 575 and go as high as 625 (maybe).

Later Jon

Cladiator · February 22, 2006 4:32AM

Dimeman,

Get yourself a Draped Bust Dime in that sigline of yours and you'll be lookin' might fine.

ziggy29 · February 22, 2006 4:47AM

Don't know the specific coin you're talking about, but don't expect an 1846 dime with high eye appeal for the grade to go for what the "trends" say they should.

I need help determining a price for an 1846 dime

Comments

Leave a Comment