Why the value on an 1883 Liberty Nickle?

OK guys, Why, according to the Red Book and the PCGS Price guide is an 1883 liberty Nickle, without cents, mintage of 5,474,300, worth less than an 1883 Liberty Nickle, with cents, with a lot larger mintage of 16,026,200?
0
Comments
-Daniel
-Aristotle
Dum loquimur fugerit invida aetas. Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero.
-Horace
Of course, if the first year is really low mintage, it won't help that much (example: 1916 SLQ).
saved in large numbers by collectors or the public will always have lower prices and those
which mostly circulate will do far better in the long run.
Before the 1860's when collecting got more popular this was not so dramatic. Coins tended
to be saved in proportion to their mintages rather than their popularity.