Options
It takes money to make money...
It's unfortunate for poor people like me that the more money you have.. the easier it is to make money. There are a lot of good opportunities out there for people with tons of money to make even more. For example, the very rare key dates rise more consistently than normal coins which have a tendency to fluctuate more with the overall market.
A perfect example is the infamous 1913 Liberty Nickel. The Eliasberg coin sold for almost $1.5 million in 1996, then recently Legend bought it for over $4.1 million. If someone had this coin and held on to it for just these 10 years, that's quite a nice profit. Here is exactly what I mean in a quote from Legend Numismatics regarding their purchase:
<< <i>Research shows that 1913 Nickels have NEVER fallen in value-even when the overall coin market has. There is no record of any owner ever losing money with one. >>
So basically if you have millions you can spend on a coin.. buy it because it is pretty much guaranteed to go up in value. Can anyone name a public stock that has never seen A SINGLE down day? If I had millions (not even extra millions to buy it "on the side") I would make an offer to buy one of these 5 nickels. I know this is pretty much obvious and this is all a ramble, but it just seems that once you get rich it is fairly easy to keep a cash flow if you have common sense. There sure are a lot of ways to make money out there if you have the capital to invest...
A perfect example is the infamous 1913 Liberty Nickel. The Eliasberg coin sold for almost $1.5 million in 1996, then recently Legend bought it for over $4.1 million. If someone had this coin and held on to it for just these 10 years, that's quite a nice profit. Here is exactly what I mean in a quote from Legend Numismatics regarding their purchase:
<< <i>Research shows that 1913 Nickels have NEVER fallen in value-even when the overall coin market has. There is no record of any owner ever losing money with one. >>
So basically if you have millions you can spend on a coin.. buy it because it is pretty much guaranteed to go up in value. Can anyone name a public stock that has never seen A SINGLE down day? If I had millions (not even extra millions to buy it "on the side") I would make an offer to buy one of these 5 nickels. I know this is pretty much obvious and this is all a ramble, but it just seems that once you get rich it is fairly easy to keep a cash flow if you have common sense. There sure are a lot of ways to make money out there if you have the capital to invest...
Lincoln Cent & Libertad Collector
0
Comments
NeoNumismaniac
keep buying those Powerball tickets !!
russ/marty make 1000% profits in 1 month (submission time) ..... compared to 150% profit in 10 years. it seems to me that those who really know what they are doing make money, not just the rich. the rich are rich because... well... they're obviously good with money. what dont you see rich people doing? spending 1% of their income on powerball is one of them.
I am still blown away by Legends quote about the 1913 Nickel. I mean, how many coins in this hobby (or investments in general) can you say that NO ONE has EVER lost money on? Ummm.. wow. It's too bad only the super rich can afford to buy a "sure thing". Then again, if anyone could we would all be rich. *Sigh*
Joe
<< <i>ok.... just to play the devil's advocate.
russ/marty make 1000% profits in 1 month (submission time) ..... compared to 150% profit in 10 years. it seems to me that those who really know what they are doing make money, not just the rich. the rich are rich because... well... they're obviously good with money. what dont you see rich people doing? spending 1% of their income on powerball is one of them. >>
Yes but you are forgetting one important difference. Russ and Marty make these impressive profits through their extensive knowledge of their respective numismatic areas not to mention they WORK THEIR BUTTS OFF. I see MadMarty listing a huge submission report on here every other week it seems. Those guys have accumulated a lot of knowledge and are using that to get an edge up on all the rest of us hobbyists. That is great and truly the American way if you ask me. 1000% profits in a month are AWESOME.. BUT.. not ANYONE could go and do what they do, it takes a LOT of skill.
On the other hand, an idiot with no knowledge of numismatics could drop $5million on a 1913 Liberty Nickel and sell it ten years from now with little to no effort, or knowledge.
There is no guarantee. In coins, like stocks, past performance is not necessarily predictive of future performance. In fact, just when everyone thinks that something cannot happen, it usually does happen.
Still, the coin hasn't even so much as dipped in almost 100 years and I don't know how many investment opportunities you can say that about. Would anyone be surprised if a 1913 Nickel sold for over $10 million within 10 years?
While there is no 100% guarantee on anything (you could have a heartattack and die 5 minutes after buying the coin, from owning it) but it doesn't get much better than this and there sure aren't any coins in my price range with such a nice track record.
there sure aren't any coins in my price range with such a nice track record.
There may be more than you think. Look into 1916-D merc dimes and 1877 IHCs in circ.
There are plenty of coins, classic and modern, that have enjoyed incredible returns over the past (10) years in nearly all price ranges. For example, what about a 1995(w) Silver Eagle which was available directly from the mint in 1995 for a few hundred dollars as I recall and is now over $5,000 .00+ in PR69DC grade (PR70DC grade is basically "name your price) and has basically moved up in a "straight line" over the past (10) years? There are numerous examples of coins going from a few hundred dollars to mulit-thousands in the past 5-10 years, many of which were available directly from the Mint.
Wondercoin
<< <i>If you feel so certain that the 1913 Lib nickel is a "sure thing", you could get a group of collectors/investors together to buy one. If necessary, borrow the money against your house(s) and 401k's. There's no way to lose, right?
there sure aren't any coins in my price range with such a nice track record.
There may be more than you think. Look into 1916-D merc dimes and 1877 IHCs in circ. >>
Haha you really dont understand my price range.
Thats a good idea about the 1913, except I would want it at my house all the time!!!
I know I'm wrong about this.. but it seems that as the value of the coins goes up, you have to do less homework because the coins are more well known and there is constant public interest. Like you said in your article Legend... over 250 various news and reporting agencies were knocking on your door after your purchase. All of this infatuation with the super rare coin just drives it's value up more.
I guess my point is that the Russ' and Marty's have done A LOT of homework and it pays off tremendously... and your average non-hobbyist could not do what they do, no matter how rich they were to start with. However, a non-hobbyist can buy the 1913 Nickel knowing nothing more than the fact that there are only 5 in the world, everyone wants one, and it hasn't dipped in value yet. Legend, obviously you are a true collector/investor and have done tons of homework.. I'm definitely not trying to say Legend Numismatics is any less respectable in my eyes... that would just about be the stupidest most uninformed comment I could make. I'm talking about the non-hobbyist rich investor who reads a few articles in a magazine about the 1913 Nickel and decides to buy one.
I liken his analogy to what's happened in real estate. Somebody buys a house for 80k, wakes up and through no merit (and virtually no risk), it suddenly has tripled in value. He's done well, but what about a person who buys a million-dollar estate and finds it is now worth $4 million? What he says is absolutely true--it takes money to make money.
I feel strongly about this because I bought a condominium in Connectict 20 years ago when I was a kid making 25k a year. I paid 116k for it, it was all I could afford. A year later, the government converted a large apartment a block away to Section 8 housing, and the condo immediately plummeted in value. Ten years later, it still was only worth 40k. There was no way out of this for me at the time--if I sold the bank would want 60k in cash plus I'd need another huge down payment on a house in a better neighborhood, when these houses continued to escalate in value. Most people dropped the keys off at the bank or else declared bankruptcy (a lesson in what low character MOST people demonstrate when faced with a crisis). My dad told me he'd be disappointed if I didn't stand by my word and try to pay the house off. That's what I did.
The people who could afford a better house than I at the outset watched their investment grow many, many times over. All because they simply had more money in the first place. There are ways for people of modest means to invest and watch it grow, but don't even start to compare them with people who have a lot to begin with. Their capacity to accumulate wealth is exponential.
Thats a good idea about the 1913, except I would want it at my house all the time!!! And no one would let me do that since I could only put $20 towards the purchase
Well, what do you expect? Do you want me to buy you a 1913 Lib nickel so that you do not miss the next move up?
There are ways for people of modest means to invest and watch it grow, but don't even start to compare them with people who have a lot to begin with.
Excellent point.
<< <i>Its funny you say that sandhawk! I just bought one for the first time in a long time. Didn't match a single number though.
I am still blown away by Legends quote about the 1913 Nickel. I mean, how many coins in this hobby (or investments in general) can you say that NO ONE has EVER lost money on? Ummm.. wow. It's too bad only the super rich can afford to buy a "sure thing". Then again, if anyone could we would all be rich. *Sigh*
Joe >>
Myself? I am not rich--not in anyone's book.(At least, anyone from the U.S.) However, I have never lost a cent on any coin I have ever bought.
Of course, I have never sold one, either!
Jim
But I agree it takes money to make money. If you have ready cash people who don't come to you with opportunities...
<< <i>BUT.. not ANYONE could go and do what they do, it takes a LOT of skill. >>
Frankly, anyone can do what Marty and I do. It really involves work far more than it does skill.
Russ, NCNE
I find your advise to save up and buy key dates rather than buy a lot of halfass coins particularly important and thankfully someone told me that a long time ago. It is very tempting for new collectors to buy a lot of coins for cheap because they want to watch their collections grow, I remember I was like that for a while. I would like to hear anyone elses thoughts about this as well just because I find it interesting.
Also here is a hypothetical I was wondering:
If a billionare took an interest in these nickels and decided to try and buy them all (or at least the 3 that aren't in museums, but hey I'm sure they have their price too) and then held on to all of them for say... 25 years. Neglecting inflation, do you think the coins would have risen or fallen in value after that 25 years? If they just kind of "disappeared from the numismatic community's eye" for a while and then resurfaced... what effect do you think it would have on prices? Has a complete hoard ever happened like this before with an extremely low mintage coin?
I think this is a myth to a certain extent that this country is addicted to.... I know lots of people who work hard and have skills, but they never become wealthy. The inequities in this society run deep, and the reality is far more complex than "if you work hard, you'll make it- and if you didn't make it, that means you must not have worked hard"......
<< <i>Frankly, anyone can do what Marty and I do. It really involves work far more than it does skill. >>
That's really not true. The more who DO it will decrease the opportunity to continue.
Anyone CAN learn more about coins than someone else, but for general purposes more money makes more money.
Taking for instance that 1913 nickel, the PERCENTAGE of profit may be meager, but like any dealer of high end stuff, it's not the percentage but the AMOUNT you can make on a larger outlay.
And getting more so. Starting ANYTHING from scratch is getting more and more difficult every day.
IMO
It has been a successful campaign. People are now BLAMING THEMSELVES for failures of their LEADERSHIP.
It is an old ploy, but an effective one.
I forgot to try and track that auction and see what the price realized was, maybe someone around here remembers the auction house or could post a link to it? 1 isn't a hoard, but it's dang close when the pop is only a handful (3?). I'm sure 80 years provided one heck of an $$ increase, percentage wise I have no idea though.
If you think you can't make much money off your $30, talk to anyone who bought a 1999 US Silver Proof Set direct from the US Mint and is sitting on a 1500% profit.
<< <i> It doesn't take money to make money. It takes hard work and skill to make money. >>
hard work and skill are over-rated, welfare is so much easier. vote for Bread and Circuses
Need more $$$ for coins?
Learn from and about coins. Don't try to become rich from them.
The ultra rarities tend to rise with the income of the second most successful person interested in them [ie: the underbidder]. They've averaged about 9% per annum for a long, long time. They tend to be held in strong hands and only sell for tidy profits ... although I certainly can imagine a circumstance under which they would be sold for a loss in the future.
<< <i>It doesn't take money to make money. It takes hard work and skill to make money. >>
These both make money. The first just doesn't always require all the work.
Just catching up on the thread...
But it also takes money to LOSE money
My posts viewed
since 8/1/6
<< <i>BUT.. not ANYONE could go and do what they do, it takes a LOT of skill. >>
Frankly, anyone can do what Marty and I do. It really involves work far more than it does skill.
Russ, NCNE >>
I think you underestimate your skill. And yes, your skill has developed from hardwork. You know very well that you know more about Kennedy halves than 99.9% of the people on these forums and that is through hard work, like you said, and you have developed the skill to cherrypick halves better than almost anyone. I think it would be a lot more difficult for a wealthy newbie to enter into your market and seriously compete than it would be for someone wealthy to enter in to the ultra rarities of coins. You're point about it involving work is 100% true. A billionare who picks up a 1913 or two and sits on them for a decade would have to do infinitely less in comparison.
One thing I want to make clear is that I don't think anyone should be able to get rich, at least without doing enough work to deserve it. Obviously if you want to make big bucks, you gotta play with the big boys and girls. I'm just pointing out how once you accumulate a very large amount of money, you can basically just live off of interest/earnings off of that money and not have to work as hard if you don't want to. I'm not trying to complain about how some people are born rich and some have to earn it, that's just life. I guess my original intent in creating this thread was just to put my thoughts at the time on paper, as they were coin related after reading Legend's cool article.
PS: I really enjoyed the "history of the coin" at the very bottom.
<< <i>It has been a successful campaign. People are now BLAMING THEMSELVES for failures of their LEADERSHIP. >>
Too bad., since the beginning of time there have been people that can make it and people that can't. Rich people fail and poor people prosper, it happens every day. The leadership has not made one difference to me or my purchases. That's an excuse for failure.
<< <i>That's an excuse for failure. >>
Not entirely. Yes it is for some.
But the rich AND the poor have seen their dollar's worldwide purchasing power DECLINE by 30-40% over the past couple years and that's not anything that the folks DID. Or DIDN'T do. Unless you consider NOT running everyone in Washington out on a rail a "failure" of inaction.
The wise are hedging their dollars to keep what they have. The industrious are working like hell to accumulate MORE. And if they are wise, they will also hedge THOSE.
Got gold? Don't ....FAIL ........ to realize how important it can be.
Be sure the money you GOT is REAL money.
<< <i>
<< <i>BUT.. not ANYONE could go and do what they do, it takes a LOT of skill. >>
Frankly, anyone can do what Marty and I do. It really involves work far more than it does skill.
Russ, NCNE >>
I think you underestimate your skill. And yes, your skill has developed from hardwork. You know very well that you know more about Kennedy halves than 99.9% of the people on these forums and that is through hard work, like you said, and you have developed the skill to cherrypick halves better than almost anyone. >>
joefro, you might not know that Russ hasn't been in the hobby very long. Look at his join date - April 2002 - he didn't know diddly when he joined here and he'd be the first to admit it. Now indeed he has put in a lot of work and I believe that he also has an innate ability to grade which not everyone has. He learned by submitting coins, analyzing the clunkers, and putting that newly improved ability to work on the next batch. I have tremendous respect for him - and Marty and a lot of others - who put in serious effort to get good at the niche they are in.
Don't believe you can't do the same, and you don't have to send coins in for grading. Join a coin club. Go to shows and look at as many coins as you can. Join the ANA and borrow books free (cost of postage only) from their immense library. If you have the time and the desire, you can accumulate knowledge and skill at a tremendous pace. Learn from others. Most people in this hobby are gracious and generous with their time.
Notice what Russ and Marty have in common - for the most part, they became highly skilled in a particular niche and use that knowledge to find good deals. Even if you don't have the innate natural grading skills they do, that doesn't mean you can't use superior knowledge that you acquire.
Let's say you are a poor grader. Fine - learn about varieties. There are tons of them out there unrecognized, even in the price range you are shopping in. Did you see the recent thread about the $80 coin that was sold for $2,000? That was achieved because the guy recognized a rare variety that the seller didn't. The knowledge was available to anyone. One person had it and the other didn't.
Your knowledge will keep you from making mistakes and that is a large factor in being successful. To pick an example, you could learn why it's dangerous to buy certain mintmarked Buffalo nickels raw without carefully inspecting the edge first.
I know a guy who visits different small town shops and goes through the recent purchases the dealer bought from the public. He knows his varieties and while he happens to be a very good grader as well, he can cherrypick varieties because those dealers don't care about them. There are many ways to enjoy this hobby even on a small budget. Find an area that you are very interested in, apply yourself, and learn all you can. I guarantee that will put you ahead of 95% of the others.
New collectors, please educate yourself before spending money on coins; there are people who believe that using numismatic knowledge to rip the naïve is what this hobby is all about.
Guess what, JoeFro. The stock market has a similar historical rate of return and you can participate in it for as little as $25/month.
And since the beginning of time, there has also been racism, slavery, prejudice, sexism, ageism, etc etc, and these very real dynamics go a long ways in determining who has power, influence, and money. There has never been a level playing field, and socio-economic realities can't be broken down into black & white rules that we can put on a poster and frame on our walls.
<< <i>There has never been a level playing field >>
Yep....That's life.
Persue what you enjoy, learn everything you can, learn from your mistakes, remember what you did on the winners, ask for advice.
Sounds trite, but it works. Find a niche, a coin or a series that offers promise. Buying a coin in a low grade with a pop in the 1,000s is a safe but not promising investment. It won't double next year or the year after.
A dealer collector is not a oxymoron. If you buy three coins for $50 each, and sell 2 for $75 ea, your third coin is now free. You can build a nice collection with other people's money.
I'm a relative newbie to coins and I've bought and sold it all: gold proof sets, foreign gold, 1986-2003 MS69 silver eagles, Kennedy registry set (53 coins!) 95-W proof set, '82 Washington ms69 Commemorative - it goes on and on. Some have done well, others not so well. I've learned a lot and I know where to focus.
Russ looks at 500 proof sets to get a plum, Marty drives 500 miles to visit 10 coins shops, Don flips every slab looking for a rotated reverse (or is it a rotated obverse?)
This hobby has room for everyone. Have fun.
Joe
One things for sure, being givin a collection that is 100% raw coins with no ryhme or reason to it makes it fun and a huge learning guide!.................some are shiny and some are not......................
<< <i>Frankly, anyone can do what Marty and I do. It really involves work far more than it does skill. >>
I have been buying alot of raw coins and submitting them for resale. It's a great way to finance my coin purchases.
They will have either a written or thought out direction and/or goals that they want to reach/attain. For whatever reason (can't be the design
The real question is: What are YOUR goals? what is YOUR direction? What do YOU want to accomplish? Pick something, write it down and figure out how to do it. Doesn't mean you will be successful right out of the box but as you start to go down that path you will learn what to do and what not to do. Success a lot of times is the ability to not repeat your past failures. Too many people make excuses or color their failures with the result that they do the very same thing with the very same result. Acknowledge your failures/lack of knowledge and don't repeat the failed steps and/or get the knowledge you need to be successful ...
and STOP yer belly-aching!!!
Joe.
Edit: missing word
<< <i>It doesn't take money to make money. It takes hard work and skill to make money.
I think this is a myth to a certain extent that this country is addicted to.... I know lots of people who work hard and have skills, but they never become wealthy. The inequities in this society run deep, and the reality is far more complex than "if you work hard, you'll make it- and if you didn't make it, that means you must not have worked hard"...... >>
This is a more pragmatic, and ultimately more accurate, view of real life in a capitalist society.
<< <i>Don't think it isn't a HUGE risk to layout big money for anything. >>
100% true!
I still like the 27-S SLQ. Back in the mid 90's I'd buy them at $6 for a good and $8 for a VG. As recent as the this year's FUN convention I bought over a dozen off the bourse for $12-$17 each in good, a few were really VG's. Grey sheet shows them at $21 for Good and $27 for a VG now.
The key to making money in coins for newbies is buy the best you can. Keys and semi-keys rule!
NoEbayAuctionsForNow