Options
The best compliment that a dealer can be paid by a collector????
coinguy1
Posts: 13,484 ✭✭✭
Recently, I was privy to the comments below (edited ever-so-slightly to help keep the author's identity and whereabouts private and posted with his permission), which a collector conveyed to one of the dealers he works with.
<< <i>I had a chance to review what I had collected over time and I note the marked improvement in quality of the coins in my collection since I met you in..... Time, experience and great mentoring has improved my purchases from unpredictable and often mundane to a very nice selection of quality coins. I have learned a lot and you have had the greatest impact on my maturation as a collector >>
I think the collector paid a great compliment to the dealer.
What are your thoughts on this, and what, if anything, do you think would be a greater compliment? Thanks.
<< <i>I had a chance to review what I had collected over time and I note the marked improvement in quality of the coins in my collection since I met you in..... Time, experience and great mentoring has improved my purchases from unpredictable and often mundane to a very nice selection of quality coins. I have learned a lot and you have had the greatest impact on my maturation as a collector >>
I think the collector paid a great compliment to the dealer.
What are your thoughts on this, and what, if anything, do you think would be a greater compliment? Thanks.
0
Comments
<< <i>what, if anything, do you think would be a greater compliment? >>
"I had a chance to review my coin purchases over time and realize I've been ripping you a new one and making obscene profits for years. I have earned a lot and you have had the greatest impact on my income."
Russ, NCNE
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
Mark
It was great that the collector let the dealer know how he truly felt. I bet that dealer has a customer for life. You don't find too many businesses (coins or otherwise) that are willing to invest some time into educating their customers. All too often there is a desire for a quick sale and move on to the next deal.
I have also learned alot from a number of patient dealers - their wisdom has helped me assemble a great set of coins plus the ability and confidence to know what I am looking at and buying. I make as many purchases as possible from the guys that tought me what I know. That's the least I can do - but I think will also let them know how appreciative I am of them.
Great post
“In matters of style, swim with the current; in matters of principle, stand like a rock." - Thomas Jefferson
My digital cameo album 1950-64 Cameos - take a look!
Just kidding. Actually, it sounds like the ultimate compliment.
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
Win win.
<< <i>what, if anything, do you think would be a greater compliment? >>
"Nice shirt."
<< <i>
<< <i>what, if anything, do you think would be a greater compliment? >>
"I had a chance to review my coin purchases over time and realize I've been ripping you a new one and making obscene profits for years. I have earned a lot and you have had the greatest impact on my income."
Russ, NCNE >>
Hilarious! Russ's softly contrasting response illustrates the wonderful multi-faceted pursuits coins offer - collecting, investing, selling and every combination thereof.
Doug
As a collector, I view this as another way of saying "this is my dealer".
"Mark,
You need to start buying some junky widgets, 'cause every time I get your newp update, I contact you within 48 hours, and everything I want is already gone, with a back-up waiting list in place if the piece comes back (which it never does). Dang it, I'm waiting to send you gobs of money, but your stuff is too good, so every one keeps beating me to it!"
Quite a compliment for a dealer when his material (and rep) is so good, he can't keep'em in stock more than a few days, IMO.
09/07/2006
The best compliment, in my book, is being able to say the dealer is honest. The presence of honesty usually tends to imply there will be other nice qualities. If there is no honesty, who cares how much high power coin experience a dealer has?
KJ
Tom
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
Mark, it looks like I got smoe good news on the job front today, my pre employment physical results are in.
Have to wait untill Tuesday to officially hear those magic words "your hired" but at this point I think that is little more then a formality. The reason I mention this here is because if I am back in the hobby again soon, I won't forget those dealers who treated me well and I include you on that list along with Larry & Mike.
Les
I need to thank a few dealers that have taken the time to educate me over the years.
Some are no longer here to thank.
I owe a few a compliment, a thank you and a hand shake for the years.
In any profession and/or job there are different types of reward. For me the respect, trust and appreciation of the people I interact with are of extreme importance and only second to my own self confidence that I have done my job in the best fashion I am capable. The financial reward often follows. Mark's comments and actions suggest he values similar traits.
There are many types of collectors and many types of dealers. Numismatics is a highly technical field requiring many levels of knowledge. I doubt that anyone fully masters the all nuances of the discipline. It takes years of study, discipline, personal experience and mentoring to reach a level of relative competence.
Mentoring is a big help in the learning process and a a mentor can be found in many guises.
Much of the talk on this forum suggests an adverserial relation between the dealer (who buys low, sells high and whose idea of a good day is finding a unsuspecting mark to deceive) and the collector who is always suspicious of every dealer and who yearns to match the above negative description. It is not hard to find both dealers and collectors who fill this bill.
However,I have had the good experience of interacting with a few dealers that serve a much different role. These dealers have served as mentors, advisors, and critics. They serve as important sources of quality coins at fair prices that have enhanced the quality of my collection. They have learned my interests and tastes in coins and opened my eyes to important aspects of evaluating and selecting quality coins. As a mutual trust develops between a serious collector and his/her preferred dealer(s) the collector benefits as does the dealer. There are many ways to acquire rare coins. I have used most of them. Each has potential a advantages and inherent risks. After years of experimentation I am a firm believer in the value of a trusted and experienced dealer to a serious collector. Most of the great collectors have acquired their collections through partnering with selected professionals.
Collectors:Choose your dealer(s) carefully, set high standards and be direct and honest in your interactions. It will pay off.
Dealers: There are many business models but for those who want to be remembered and appreciated by your clients try to select great role models and set high standards; you are judged by the integrity and professionalism you offer every day. Many thanks to those of you that have met these standards for me.
The best compliment (similar to Russ')
Gee, not only did I get the nice coins I wanted at attractive prices but I made significant money as well as upgrades over the years from your wise selections. I couldn't be happier."
The above statement probably applies to less than 10% of the current population of dealers. Maybe even < 5%.
roadrunner
I am gratified that this thread remained non-adversarial and elicited some important and thoughtful feedback about interactions and relationships between dealers and their customers.
Every sophisticated investor, businessman and coin collector knows that appearance need to backed up by performance. Since rare coins are pricey and collections are assets, value retention and growth is an important component and a reasonable goal of many collectors. It is easy to be deceived by nice talk and sharp deals. Thus it behoves the collector to become as knowledgeable as possible and always be responsible for his/her own decisions. That does not devalue a dealer who appreciates the long term value of a strong reputation and repeat customers. Nurturing a positive relationship and when appropriate educating the clientel is a valuable start. I am sure that there are many different ways for a collector to participate in the coin world . This runs from sniping on E-bay to bidding under grey sheet bid on every auction to close ties to a superior dealer. My point is that dealer/collector interactions can be very positive if each sets high standards and contributes to the relationship. As in every aspect of life "be selective".