Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

POLL FINIS: How many still consider this is a Proof Morgan? ANSWER IN FIRST POST: 2 to 1 NO

ER's original poll results 11/04:
Total Votes: 94


yes 19 (votes) 20.21 (%)
no 48 (votes) 51.06 (%)
undecided 27 (votes) 28.72 (%)


Current Poll:
Total Votes: 61


YES 16 (votes) 26.23 (%)
NO 33 (votes) 54.10 (%)
Don't know 12 (votes) 19.67 (%)


Now, if I could just recall how to end a poll.......the results, still more than 2 to 1, very much surprise me. And I had hoped maybe 1 person would write maybe 1 sentence explainging WHY they think this is a Proof. Oh well. Condor101 and James and others added yet more info to the wealth of data and rendered opinions to the contrary and that is appreciated, but was really hoping to learn the "diagnostics" others are using who think this Proof. Maybe I should have showed the 4 dies against the "coin" instead of linking them? Would it matter? How does it get 26% with no explanation and no resemblance to a Proof Morgan?

Best and thanks,
Billy



---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
<<I could not see much from those photographs. There are images of the 4 obverse 1895 Morgan Proof dies on the 9th page of this thread about a coin some people thought was Proof despite its appearance. I still don't think it was a Proof - not until someone can show me how numerals and fonts can be struck from dies that clearly do not share those characteristics.>> - Billy

<<And I gave you a Heritage auction link (in the same thread) which showed the same obverse die on an 1895 Proof. You were wrong then
Billy, still wrong, and won't drop it despite knowing zippo about Proof Morgans.>> - Wolf359

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Hi All,
Many people who would know wrote this coin off as NOT a Proof. Some still insist it is. Enough time has passed for a new poll with new fresh opinions. What do you think from the images shown? If I handed this to you raw, which it apparently was, what would you say? Proof or altered date etc? Does it even look Proof? Check out the details provided below as well. There are images of the 4 obverse 1895 Morgan Proof dies on the 9th page of this thread. If you do think it is Proof - please explain why. Thanks!

Billy (forgive any red x's, images will be back up quickly...)

image
The Questioned "Proof" coin

imageimage
Proof 1895 Morgan as posted by Andy Lustig

image
Questioned "Proof" coin on top and Heritage NGC Proof 50 on bottom

image
On the top - the questioned "Proof" coin, on the left an 1885 Deep Mirror Mint State Prooflike, on the right a Proof 1895

Comments

  • Options
    dragondragon Posts: 4,548 ✭✭
    That 1895 Morgan in your post is an obvious proof at first glance and without question.
  • Options


    << <i>That 1895 Morgan in your post is an obvious proof at first glance and without question. >>



    image I did not say that Jack!


    Billy

    PS - really, nothing against Jack/wolf or anyone else in here - I just would like to see what percentage of the room still thinks this coin is Proof.
  • Options
    dragondragon Posts: 4,548 ✭✭
    Well the top pic didn't show when I first looked at this thread. The top coin (above the obvious toned proof coin) is not a proof coin IMO and lacks all the necessary criteria for a proof coin, and also is not a genuine 1895 either.
  • Options
    nwcsnwcs Posts: 13,386 ✭✭✭
    Need an option for who cares anymore?
  • Options
    Hi,
    If voting yes, please explain why you believe so. What attributes? Mirrors or strike/definiton of detail? Denticles and placement of numerals etc? Color? What says "Proof" to you? Thanks! This coin was said to be slabbed but NOT by PCGS or NGC..

    Billy
  • Options
    ERER Posts: 7,345 ✭
    Billy, you don't know Jack about Morgan.image
  • Options


    << <i>Billy, you don't know Jack about Morgan.image >>




    Please, lets stick to the topic guys! I quoted wolf359 because of his knowledge of Morgans - I am not looking to enrage anyone.


    Billy
  • Options
    ziggy29ziggy29 Posts: 18,669 ✭✭✭
    There's a bit of a Catch-22 here.

    In order to prove it's not a Proof, you'd possibly have to show they were struck from different dies. (Anything less might be evidence, but not proof. It's possible for business strikes to be struck from proof dies, but if the coin is circulated, it will be assumed an "impaired proof.")

    But if you show an alleged 1895 Morgan struck from different dies, it would likely be immediately disregarded as a fake.

    It's theoretically possible, I guess, that at least a few business strike '95s got out -- and possibly struck with the same dies as the proofs. But none have been in mint state and clearly not struck as proofs. As a result, the preponderance of the evidence, IMO, is that none of the 12,000 business strikes reached circulation...though anything's possible.
  • Options
    K6AZK6AZ Posts: 9,295 ✭
    First wooden boxes, now 95 proof Morgans, what's next? image
  • Options
    messydeskmessydesk Posts: 20,919 ✭✭✭✭✭
    It's definitely a proof red X.
  • Options
    Hi,

    Pic are fixed - sorry image
    Voters, please feel free to add your rationale.

    K6 - what do you think though? Do you see any Proof attributes?

    Ziggy - all dies were shown in the original thread - linked in this thread.

    Billy

  • Options
    K6AZK6AZ Posts: 9,295 ✭
    On second though, let me read the first thread again.
  • Options
    K6AZK6AZ Posts: 9,295 ✭
    First of all, why is this subject being dredged up again?

    If this were a 95-S in that high a grade, no one in their right mind would mess with it given the value of high grade 95-S Morgans.

    I think you need to give it a rest, and stop beating dead horses for months at a time.
  • Options
    ziggy29ziggy29 Posts: 18,669 ✭✭✭


    << <i>If this were a 95-S in that high a grade, no one in their right mind would mess with it given the value of high grade 95-S Morgans. >>

    I'm not saying this as an expert in Morgan die varieties (I'm not), but...what if this were an altered '85-P? Unless we can confirm that none of the known '85-P dies match this '95, that's a possibility, too.

    Far easier (financially) to mess with an '85-P than a '95-S.
  • Options


    << <i>First of all, why is this subject being dredged up again?

    If this were a 95-S in that high a grade, no one in their right mind would mess with it given the value of high grade 95-S Morgans.

    I think you need to give it a rest, and stop beating dead horses for months at a time. >>



    I brought it up in regard to another 1895 Morgan thread. A good # of members vote this a Proof coin and you don't think that is interesting? In the last poll lots of people changed opnions and it was not reflected in the final result. Some are firmly convinced this is a Proof and I am trying to understand why - to educate myself.


    Billy
  • Options


    << <i>

    << <i>If this were a 95-S in that high a grade, no one in their right mind would mess with it given the value of high grade 95-S Morgans. >>

    I'm not saying this as an expert in Morgan die varieties (I'm not), but...what if this were an altered '85-P? Unless we can confirm that none of the known '85-P dies match this '95, that's a possibility, too.

    Far easier (financially) to mess with an '85-P than a '95-S. >>



    M. Eureka suggested a VAM search starting with the 1885-P to ID it as such.

    Billy
  • Options
    Anyone else having trouble with these poll results? Will NO ONE post ANYTHING about why they think this coin is Proof? Check out the wear pattern on the left wing too...


    Billy
  • Options
    messydeskmessydesk Posts: 20,919 ✭✭✭✭✭
    OK, now that I don't get the red X anymore, I'll say it's an ugly coin. Based on the shape of the 5, I'd say it's not an 1885. Referring to page 124 of my VAM book, you can see that the upright shaft of the 5 is shaped differently on 1885 and 1895 coins. For 1885, the shaft is wider at the top, for 1895, it is wider at the bottom (in both cases, ever so slightly). In addition, if a line were drawn from the inner edge of the shaft to the ball of the 5, it would hit close to the midde of the ball on the 1885, and glance off the inside edge on the 1895.

    Looking at the dates of the 4 known proof dies for the 1895, the position is closest to the third one, which is slightly to the right of normal position, although perhaps not enough to qualify as a "far date," and it slants up to the right. There is no mention of an 1895-S with a date in that position in the VAM book, but there are two 1895-O mentioned with far dates. Of course, there's no picture of it, but I do have a VAM 3, which does line up pretty well with the picture of the questionable coin. Of course, if this were an altered VAM 3, there'd be a telltale sign of a doubled flag on the 5, which I don't see. The VAM 4 is also listed with a far date, and no doubling, with no mention of the slant of the date. The date also looks a little fatter than the proofs listed, but that could just be the picture.

    As for general proof characteristics, where are the breast feathers? The rim looks proofish on the obverse near the top, but elsewhere on the coin it doesn't.

    If it's an alteration, I'd say it's an altered and heavily processed 1895-O VAM 4. No way I'd buy that coin over the internet raw, and the eye appeal is well deserving of a low-ball bid if it's good.
  • Options
    K6AZK6AZ Posts: 9,295 ✭
    I want to know why you carry on with a subject forever, in this case over seven months. Time to give it a rest.
  • Options


    << <i>I want to know why you carry on with a subject forever, in this case over seven months. Time to give it a rest. >>



    Because very few people, including you, have posted any information explaining WHY they think this is Proof. People in this Forum get all up in arms over "tightening" and "gradeflation" and 1 point here and 2 points there - yet you don't find it interesting to say the least that so many think this coin a Proof?

    Billy
  • Options
    K6AZK6AZ Posts: 9,295 ✭
    The onus is on you to prove it isn't a proof.

    You've proved yourself here many times, including your claims that scanners provide better images of coin than digital cameras.
  • Options


    << <i>The onus is on you to prove it isn't a proof.

    You've proved yourself here many times, including your claims that scanners provide better images of coin than digital cameras. >>




    I never said scanners were better - only that one could get a decent photo of a Proof coin with a good scanner - such as the Seated and Merc in my sigline. I can't capture luster with a scanner but you can catch some color as I have said repeatedly. As far as proving this dollar to be other than a 95 Pr I have shown all the evidence that I can - so have others. Few collectors, less than the last poll, think it is a Proof and no one has been able to provide any detailed analysis of why - old post or new. Many advanced collectors and dealers etc. have provided a lot of evidence to the contrary though - most consider this a "no-brainer" to borrow a term from a PM.


    Billy

  • Options
    magikbillymagikbilly Posts: 6,780 ✭


    << <i>OK, now that I don't get the red X anymore, I'll say it's an ugly coin. Based on the shape of the 5, I'd say it's not an 1885. Referring to page 124 of my VAM book, you can see that the upright shaft of the 5 is shaped differently on 1885 and 1895 coins. For 1885, the shaft is wider at the top, for 1895, it is wider at the bottom (in both cases, ever so slightly). In addition, if a line were drawn from the inner edge of the shaft to the ball of the 5, it would hit close to the midde of the ball on the 1885, and glance off the inside edge on the 1895.

    Looking at the dates of the 4 known proof dies for the 1895, the position is closest to the third one, which is slightly to the right of normal position, although perhaps not enough to qualify as a "far date," and it slants up to the right. There is no mention of an 1895-S with a date in that position in the VAM book, but there are two 1895-O mentioned with far dates. Of course, there's no picture of it, but I do have a VAM 3, which does line up pretty well with the picture of the questionable coin. Of course, if this were an altered VAM 3, there'd be a telltale sign of a doubled flag on the 5, which I don't see. The VAM 4 is also listed with a far date, and no doubling, with no mention of the slant of the date. The date also looks a little fatter than the proofs listed, but that could just be the picture.

    As for general proof characteristics, where are the breast feathers? The rim looks proofish on the obverse near the top, but elsewhere on the coin it doesn't.

    If it's an alteration, I'd say it's an altered and heavily processed 1895-O VAM 4. No way I'd buy that coin over the internet raw, and the eye appeal is well deserving of a low-ball bid if it's good. >>




    Thank you John for sharing your opnion image

    Billy
  • Options
    Conder101Conder101 Posts: 10,536 ✭
    I do not believe the questioned coin is an 1895 proof and I think it is an altered date.

    image
    On the genuine 95 proof the flag of the 5 is thin and comes to a sharp point. On the questioned coin the flag is much thicker and does not come to a sharp point.

    On the genuine 95 the vertical of the 5 comes to a sharp point above the ball of the 5 and then curves around to the right in a smooth curve. On the questioned coin the vertical ends in a blunt squared off point above the ball and the curve inside the lower part of the 5 is not smoothbut seems to have a definite "point" at both the top and bottom of the loop. The inside of the bottom of the 5 is also much more open on the genuine 95 than on the questioned coin.

    The ball of the 5 on the genuine 95 is just slightly larger than the ball on the 9. On the questioned coin the ball on the 5 seems to be considerably larger than that on the 9. On this point I could be mistaken though because of the slight differences in size of the pictures.
  • Options
    tradedollarnuttradedollarnut Posts: 20,810 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I want to know why you carry on with a subject forever, in this case over seven months. Time to give it a rest.

    This could be interpreted to be quite an amusing comment! image
  • Options
    magikbillymagikbilly Posts: 6,780 ✭
    Thanks Conder for sharing your observations - if you recall this coin you might remember even more interesting differences on the reverse as well. Conder, to what do you attribute this coin being perceived as a Proof by some? NO ONE seems willing to say why they voted "Proof".

    And thanks TDN image I remember your opinion of this coin when you saw the dates compared - "Ouch. That's gotta hurt....".

    image

    Thanks,
    Billy

  • Options
    magikbillymagikbilly Posts: 6,780 ✭
    ER's poll results 11/04:
    Total Votes: 94


    yes 19 (votes) 20.21 (%)
    no 48 (votes) 51.06 (%)
    undecided 27 (votes) 28.72 (%)


    Current Poll:
    Total Votes: 61


    YES 16 (votes) 26.23 (%)
    NO 33 (votes) 54.10 (%)
    Don't know 12 (votes) 19.67 (%)


    Now, if I could just recall how to end a poll.......the results, still more than 2 to 1, very much surprise me. And I had hoped maybe 1 person would write maybe 1 sentence explainging WHY they think this is a Proof. Oh well. Condor101 and James and others added yet more info to the wealth of data and rendered opinions to the contrary and that is appreciated, but was really hoping to learn the "diagnostics" others are using who think this Proof. Maybe I should have showed the 4 dies against the "coin" instead of linking them? image Would it matter? How does it get 26% with no explanation and no resemblance to a Proof Morgan?

    Best and thanks,
    Billy

    PS - is "cancel poll" the button to end it? Or "update poll"?

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file