Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

1858 Flying Eagle Cent DDO -- variety and grade?

I recently BINed a raw 1858 Flying Eagle Cent on eBay (guess I felt lucky -- or just irrational!).
Here it is:

image


I eventually noticed that there was some CCW doubling of 'RICA' and the eagle's tail feathers
on the obverse. I hope that this image shows some of this detail:

image


My questions for the experts on the board include, is this die doubling and, if so, which variety is
it? It doesn't appear to be the Snow-2 that is pictured in the Cherrypicker's Guide. Any idea
how rare it is? And how would you grade it? I would guess it might grade AU details, corroded,
net EF-40 at ANACS, but what do I know? image

Thanks in advance for your comments!

John

Comments

  • Options
    while as far from expert as one could be, i happened to pick up FE attribution guide by Rick Snow.

    here is what if gives for the 1858 LL FE S3 obv.

    <<"Obv.3: (B) Moderate offset doubling mostly visible on the eagle's head, tail and "RICA". Die crack from the rim at 8:00 through the eagle's beakand the wing.">>

    the picture looks similar to yours, if i squint. image seriously though, the "RICA" looks right on, as far as i can tell from the similar (though MS state) close-up given in the book. while if i do squint, and try to imagine the wear and corrosion undone, i can also see the doubling on the eye, inside of beak, and bottom side of the "U", and the tail feathers.

    as for any die crack, not sure if the coin is even from that late in the dies life, and with the wear/corrosion it's hard to tell from any pic.

    if it's an S3, 1858 LL FE, it's given "two stars" in the FE guide i'm referencing, which is equal to the S2 you mentioned, and listed as, "worthy of significant premium, probably between 2X and 3X."

    as for grade,...i'm with you mostly, maybe EF details, corroded, net VF-30/35, and ANACS for the attributions and grading.

    NICE SCORE!! image

    i often dream of snatching a good attributable FE die variety on a BIN for plain FE money, in any grade from VF-up, but i haven't convinced myself that i've seen anything yet from the pics i've been staring at. i only go check out the FE's at e-bay once in a while though, so many get listed i can get lost there looking at pics zoomed so far i see the individual pixels. i'm sure there are varieties to be picked off, but the pictures usually suck and don't tell the story. it's not as if i'd ask for a clearer picture of an obviously less that EF, perhaps problem FE that has a decent enough shot taken from most sellers, nor ask them, "hey, is there some doubing there?", and tip my hand before a snipe.

    peace
    peace
    imageimage
  • Options
    MrScienceMrScience Posts: 788 ✭✭✭
    ychange,

    Thank you very much for your insight! I must admit that I wasn't looking for a variety and, as in most cases, it would have been impossible to tell its existence from the auction images. I was just looking for an inexpensive FE better than the one I picked up as a kid, which was labeled 'ungood' on the 2x2 (is 'ungood' part of the ANA grading standards image?)!

    Thanks again. I owe you a beer!

    John

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file