Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

UPDATE FOR: A real life scenario - what should the dealer charge the client for the coin in this sce

coinguy1coinguy1 Posts: 13,484 ✭✭✭
The particulars:

Client contacts (his) dealer about a coin he has seen on another dealer's website, to see if his dealer can check it out, and possibly acquire it for him, if it's nice enough and priced right.

Client's dealer, without having to check out the description or images, is very familiar with the coin, already having tried to buy it over a period of months, from the current seller, as well a previous owner (who probably consigned it to the current seller).

Coin is listed at $4950.

Client's dealer also knows the coin brought $4140 in a public auction last August.

The coin lists for bid of $3200 and ask of $3500 in the CDN and it's desirable enough so that client's dealer would probably pay up to $4000 to stock it.

If client's dealer were to acquire it at $4000 without the client's knowing or asking about the coin in advance, dealer would likely offer it to his client(s) at $4500 in the ordinary course of business.

After a brief conversation, client gives his dealer permission/instructions to offer up to $4500 for the coin.

Dealer makes the call and offers $4300.

Seller tells dealer that coin is on consignment at $4300 (dealer believes this to be true and so should you, for purposes of this thread) and that they will sell it for a $100 profit/$4400.

Client's dealer buys the coin for $4400.

Assuming that client and his dealer have not made ANY advance agreement, what would be THE fairest price for the dealer to charge the client for the coin, under all of the circumstances presented above?
«1

Comments

  • Options
    dthigpendthigpen Posts: 3,932 ✭✭
  • Options
    vega1vega1 Posts: 941 ✭
    Edited to add: I'm an idiot, so never mind my previous answer.image I agree with $4500
  • Options
    RYKRYK Posts: 35,804 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Easy. $4600.

    $4600 is both 15% above $4000 (the amount the dealer would pay for coin for inventory), $200 more than wholesale price (about 5% commission, which is very reasonable). Also, by offering $4300, the dealer has acknowledged that he would do the deal for $200.

    If you lay out the facts for the buyer, and he does not agree that $4600 is realistic, he (client) is being unreasonable.

    Personally, I would never hassle someone over $100 for a $4500 coin. If you do too much of that, no one will want to sell you any coins.
  • Options
    cswcsw Posts: 432 ✭
    $4400 plus a reasonable fee that does not exceed $100.
    --csw
    image

    Tiger trout, Deerfield River, c. 2001.

  • Options
    jonathanbjonathanb Posts: 4,188 ✭✭✭✭✭
    If I were the client, I'd be shocked if the dealer wanted less than $100 for his efforts ($4500). Given the rest of the scenario, I probably wouldn't blink at $4600 or $4700. Anything over $5000 in this case would give me significant pause given your stipulation that no advance agreement was made between the client and the dealer.

    my thoughts, as a client
    jonathan
  • Options
    dorkkarldorkkarl Posts: 12,691 ✭✭✭
    is the client a REAL collector? i mean, does he really REALLY want the coin? if yes, then for crying out loud, buy the danged thing for whatever it takes & flip it for a $250 profit!

    none of this wishy-washy hemming & hawing over a measly 100 bucks!!! (measly in comparision to $4500).

    enough of this (sorry) collector-wannabe nonsense, have your client step up to the plate & pay his dues!

    K S
  • Options
    michaelmichael Posts: 9,524 ✭✭✭
    4650
  • Options
    LongacreLongacre Posts: 16,720 ✭✭✭
    I would give a 5% commission (or a total price of $4620 if I did the math right). Not bad for a few minute's work. image
    Always took candy from strangers
    Didn't wanna get me no trade
    Never want to be like papa
    Working for the boss every night and day
    --"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
  • Options
    $4500

    is the dealer a REAL businessperson? i mean, does he really REALLY want a loyal clientele? if yes, the for crying out loud, buy the danged thing for whatever it takes & flip it for any profit!

    none of this wishy-washy hemming & hawing over a measly 100 bucks!!! (measly in comparison to $4500 - the ORIGINAL offer)

    Ralph
    image
  • Options
    RYKRYK Posts: 35,804 ✭✭✭✭✭
    So, Mark, what are you, ahem, er, the dealer, going to do?
  • Options
    JulianJulian Posts: 3,370 ✭✭✭
    <FONT style="BACKGROUND-COLOR: #c0c0c0">My commission for transactions like this is 5%, therefore $4620. No one would normally mind that. If the client did not wish to pay it, I would accept whatever he wished to pay and make a mental note of it. </FONT>
    PNG member, numismatic dealer since 1965. Operates a retail store, also has exhibited at over 1000 shows.
    I firmly believe in numismatics as the world's greatest hobby, but recognize that this is a luxury and without collectors, we can all spend/melt our collections/inventories.

    eBaystore
  • Options
    TheNumishTheNumish Posts: 1,628 ✭✭
    gotta agree with dorkkarl.
  • Options
    UncleJoeUncleJoe Posts: 2,552 ✭✭✭
    $4400. plus your agreed upon fee and/or commission.

    Joe.
  • Options
    LeeGLeeG Posts: 12,162 ✭


    << <i>After a brief conversation, client gives his dealer permission/instructions to offer up to $4500 for the coin >>



    $4,500 + normal/reasonable commission.

    Edited to Add: After careful consideration should be $4,400 + normal/reasonable commission.
  • Options
    cswcsw Posts: 432 ✭
    client gives his dealer permission/instructions to offer up to $4500 for the coin.

    I interpreted client's authorization as setting an upper limit on the price he was willing to pay, regardless of to whom. If that interpretation is correct, client's dealer cannot "fairly" charge more than $4500.

    If, however, client and client's dealer agreed beforehand that client's dealer would purchase the coin for not more than $4500, and then client would pay some additional sum on top of that, then client's delaer should charge that additional sum. If client and client's dealer had not agreed on precisely what that additional sum should be, client's dealer should charge an amount that is reasonable under all the circumstances, including but not necessarily limited to the fee client's dealer customarily receives for providing such services and the fee for providing such services that is customarily received among client's dealer's competitors. Presumably that fee would take into account the amount of time spent in acquiring the coin, any associated costs (e.g., telephone calls or wire transfer fees), and any financial risks that the client's dealer faced (e.g., buying the coin only to find that client no longer wanted it or couldn't pay). I have no idea what a "fair" fee would be under your hypothetical.
    image

    Tiger trout, Deerfield River, c. 2001.

  • Options
    RYKRYK Posts: 35,804 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I interpreted the scenario as the client was offering to pay up to $4500 for the coin. No matter, if I were the client, I would have no problem paying the additional $100 (or $120 or whatever) for the service and the coin. I make it a policy not to dicker over these small (in percentage terms) amounts. I am with Dorkkarl; if you really want the coin, step up and buy it.
  • Options
    mgoodm3mgoodm3 Posts: 17,497 ✭✭✭
    $4500
    coinimaging.com/my photography articles Check out the new macro lens testing section
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭


    << <i>$4400. plus your agreed upon fee and/or commission. >>





    << <i>Assuming that client and his dealer have not made ANY advance agreement. >>



    I'd go with $4675, splitting the difference between the list price and the acquisition cost with the client.

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    ms70ms70 Posts: 13,957 ✭✭✭✭✭

    If the coin is offered for sale on a website, why doesn't the collector buy it himself without a middle man?

    Edit: spelling.
  • Options
    LanLordLanLord Posts: 11,764 ✭✭✭✭✭
    If I am the customer, and I say, upto $4500. I'll pay $4500. I assume you worked your profit into that price. If not, too bad, you will keep the coin because I said $4500.
  • Options
    krankykranky Posts: 8,709 ✭✭✭
    The client's dealer might feel that $100 isn't quite enough. The collector authorized a max of $4500. If the client's dealer wanted more than $4500, he/she should inform the client that $4500 isn't going to be enough and see if the client would go higher, BEFORE buying the coin from the selling dealer.

    But that isn't the question that was asked, so I'm going to say $4500 is all the client's dealer can ask for since that's as high as the client said to go. Would the client then be skeptical since he got maxed out? Maybe, but that's a function of how much confidence the client has in the dealer.

    New collectors, please educate yourself before spending money on coins; there are people who believe that using numismatic knowledge to rip the naïve is what this hobby is all about.

  • Options
    UncleJoeUncleJoe Posts: 2,552 ✭✭✭
    If the coin is offered for sale on a website, why doesn't the collector buy it himself without a midde man?

    Because the coin is listed for $4950. He is paying his dealer for his opinion and I believe his ability to maybe get a better price.

    Joe.
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭


    << <i>If the coin is offered for sale on a website, why doesn't the collector buy it himself without a midde man? >>



    Maybe the coin is being offered by a wannabe and the client only wants to buy from a real dealer.

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    I always worry about $100. If I said I was willing to pay up to $4,500 that is what I really meant. When I say I'm willing to pay $100 I won't pay $101. If I asked someone to buy something for me at the $4,500 and they called me and said: "no can do, it will take $4,600 to own that coin", I would have a decision to make. That is fine. However if I asked for the coin up to $4,500 and got a call that said "I've got your coin and that will be $4,600", I would be upset.

    Now if I really wanted the coin I would ask the dealer "how much will it cost to own that coin?". If you really want a specific coin you sometimes have to be flexible.
  • Options
    Let's try this from the buyers point of view. The amount offered for the deal was $4500.

    If you can't strike up a deal that $4500 gives you enough profit, DON'T DO THE DEAL. Seems to me $100 is better than $0 and you don't go around pi$$ing off your clients by nickel and diming them. JMHO

    Ralph
    image
  • Options
    UncleJoeUncleJoe Posts: 2,552 ✭✭✭
    After a brief conversation, client gives his dealer permission/instructions to offer up to $4500 for the coin

    I think this is the key to the question (with something left out).

    The offer is to the seller. Since the dealer only paid $4400. that's all the buyer should pay for the coin. However, IMO there was additional conversation (or prior experience) as to what compensation his dealer would receive for purchasing the coin for him.

    Joe.

  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭
    I think some of you are misreading it. The client did not say he was only willing to pay up to $4500.



    << <i>client gives his dealer permission/instructions to offer up to $4500 for the coin. >>



    If he gives the dealer permission to OFFER $4500 for the coin, how can he possibly expect to buy it for $4500? Remember, there is also:



    << <i>client and his dealer have not made ANY advance agreement >>



    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    cswcsw Posts: 432 ✭
    For all you people who think it's okay to charge $4500 (or more) plus (or without) a commission, I'd like to hear your reasons, given that the coin was purchased for only $4400.

    Suppose dealer acquired the coin for $3400. Would it still be okay for dealer to charge client $4500? Or, even worse, $4500 plus comission?

    In other words, if a dealer is acquiring a coin for a client, is it acceptable for the dealer to pocket any difference between the price the dealer acquires the coin for and upper limit the client has set?

    If my dealer did that I'd be royally p!ssed. Note that I'm not saying that the dealer isn't entitled to something for the effort. In my view, the dealer should turn the coin over to the client for precisely what the dealer paid (in coinguy's hypothetical, $4400) and collect a reasonable commission for his efforts. Dealer should not charge client more than dealer paid, with or without a commission.

    image

    Tiger trout, Deerfield River, c. 2001.

  • Options
    coinguy1coinguy1 Posts: 13,484 ✭✭✭
    Some comments and replies to your posts:


    << <i>is the client a REAL collector? i mean, does he really REALLY want the coin? >>

    In my opinion the client is a real collector. He has not yet seen the coin in person, but based upon what I said about it, he wants it.



    << <i>if yes, then for crying out loud, buy the danged thing for whatever it takes & flip it for a $250 profit! >>

    Easy, Karl - I already bought itimage



    << <i>I would give a 5% commission (or a total price of $4620 if I did the math right). Not bad for a few minute's work >>

    I wont address the price that I think should be charged, at this time, though I will later. I will say, however, that even though it was only "a few minute's work", the dealer had previously spent time studying and trying to buy the coin, was therefore instantly familiar with it and almost certainly was able to buy it for less than the client would have been able to on his own.



    << <i>is the dealer a REAL businessperson? i mean, does he really REALLY want a loyal clientele? >>

    I'd like to THINK I am a "real businessperson" and I KNOW I want loyal clientele.



    << <i>So, Mark, what are you, ahem, er, the dealer, going to do? >>

    Robert, I'm, ahem the dealer had determined that before I started this thread and I will reveal the number tomorrow.



    << <i>$4400. plus your agreed upon fee and/or commission. >>

    Joe, in this case, there was no "agreed upon fee and/or commission" discussed.




    << <i>I interpreted client's authorization as setting an upper limit on the price he was willing to pay, regardless of to whom. If that interpretation is correct, client's dealer cannot "fairly" charge more than $4500. >>

    CSW, that is a fair interpretation, though I did not interpret it that way. If I didn't already have an excellent relationship with the client, I would have cleared that up in advance. In this case I wasn't concerned about it.



    << <i>If the coin is offered for sale on a website, why doesn't the collector buy it himself without a middle man? >>

    The client wanted the dealer to screen the coin for him and if it met with his approval, handle the transaction. There are more times than you might imagine, when a client can have his dealer act as a middleman and still obtain the coin for less than he would have been able to on his own.
  • Options
    coinguy1coinguy1 Posts: 13,484 ✭✭✭
    Russ, thanks for clarifying/highlighting (the lack of a specifc agreement between the dealer and the client), as per your post below:


    I think some of you are misreading it. The client did not say he was only willing to pay up to $4500.



    << client gives his dealer permission/instructions to offer up to $4500 for the coin. >>



    If he gives the dealer permission to OFFER $4500 for the coin, how can he possibly expect to buy it for $4500? Remember, there is also:



    << client and his dealer have not made ANY advance agreement >>

  • Options
    cswcsw Posts: 432 ✭
    Russ's observation has convinced me that my initial response, $4400 plus a commission not to exceed $100 (so that the buyer isn't on the hook for more than $4500) is incorrect.

    Upon reflection, I hereby modify my answer as follows:

    $4400 plus a reasonable commission.

    I still think that the baseline is $4400 (not $4500) plus commission and would like to hear from those who think otherwise.

    I already set out some of the factors I thought might be appropriate as to how to determine what's reasonable. Another factor should be (as Russ mentioned) the amount of money the dealer saved the client. That one might be a bit difficult to calculate, since it's likely that the client could purchased the coin on his own for at least a little bit less than the list price.
    image

    Tiger trout, Deerfield River, c. 2001.

  • Options
    BigD5BigD5 Posts: 3,433 ✭
    apparently I misunderstood the parameters of this transaction
    BigD5
    LSCC#1864

    Ebay Stuff
  • Options
    I would say $4550 would be fair.......
  • Options
    Coinguy,
    No disrespect to you as a businessperson. Just playing devils advocate to Karl's statement.



    I guess this all boils down to the conversation and how well you understand you client. Was the $4500 mentioned for the coin OR for the coin and your time? Does the buyer have the expectation that you will be compensated above the cost of the coin ($4500 max) or was the $4500 stated for the "whole deal"?

    If I say I want to pay $4500 for a coin, that's what I'm willing to pay however; if I'm in an auction scenario, I have the expectation of an extra 15%. More clear cut in this scenario, but I know $4500 means $5175.

    Ralph
    image
  • Options
    gemtone65gemtone65 Posts: 963 ✭✭✭
    Obviously the client wasn't expecting you to secure the coin for up to $4500 and for you not to receive some compensation in return. Ideally, that compensation should have been worked out beforehand. In this case apparently not. But, if your charge for such a transaction like this is 5%, then add that perentage to whatever is your actual cost, assuming that cost is no more than $4500.
  • Options
    krankykranky Posts: 8,709 ✭✭✭
    Well, I guess I didn't follow. If the client "gives his dealer permission/instructions to offer up to $4500 for the coin" then I figure the client was offering to pay no more than $4500. Now it appears it's understood by both parties that the offer of $4500 does not include commission. That's fine as long as everyone understands.

    If that's the case, I guess the client already knows, from prior transactions, what the commission will be.

    New collectors, please educate yourself before spending money on coins; there are people who believe that using numismatic knowledge to rip the naïve is what this hobby is all about.

  • Options
    nwcsnwcs Posts: 13,386 ✭✭✭
    $4500
  • Options
    Mark,

    Sounds like a 5% fee would be appropriate given the scenerio. The cost of time, effort and good will should be worth $220 in MHO.
    Bob Green
    bgreen@parkavenumis.com
    800-992-9881
    Visit us at www.parkavenumis.com
  • Options
    RYKRYK Posts: 35,804 ✭✭✭✭✭
    5% is the typical commission for a "no-risk" transaction (ie. auction representation). I believe that you are entitled to that. In the future, I guess it is best to clarify with the client what are the terms.

    Many of us were not clear whether the $4500 was the most the client would pay for the coin or the amount you should pay for the coin, and some of the answers were predicated on the former. The fact that you "saved" $100 by buying the coin for $4400 is a savings that should be passed on to the client (IMO), just as if the client purchased a coin at auction under his max bid.

    I like these hypothetical and non-hypothetical scenarios. image
  • Options
    nwcsnwcs Posts: 13,386 ✭✭✭
    Having read some of the clarifications I will add that I think that $4400 is the base price and Mark and the customer need to negotiate a fair purchase price between them. If they have a good relationship, no problem. I think the issue is that there were some assumptions made that should probably be cleared up before acting as the customer's agent.
  • Options
    OKbustchaserOKbustchaser Posts: 5,570 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I have used dealers as middlemen before. It seems that on average I pay about 5 percent for the service. In this case--already having a prior relationship with this dealer I would have no problem paying such a commission over the amount that I authorized him to offer. I would have figured that into my authorization the same way I figure a buyers fee into a max bid at aution. That said, I would trust the dealer to charge his commission based on actual cost not my max.

    Jim
    Just because I'm old doesn't mean I don't love to look at a pretty bust.
  • Options
    dthigpendthigpen Posts: 3,932 ✭✭
    Mark,

    Now that you've clarified that $4500 is the max he wanted you to pay and it was understood your commision would be charged, and when your standard commision is 5% (Or whatever it is), I'd suggest that you charge him $4400 + 5% (Or whatever your standard commision is). It'll prove your worth as a buying agent to him once again and reaffirm his loyalty towards you. Most importantly though, it's the ethical thing to do.
  • Options
    GeomanGeoman Posts: 2,491 ✭✭✭
    ...After a brief conversation, client gives his dealer permission/instructions to offer up to $4500 for the coin....

    $4500.


    Client said up to $4500. Why would a dealer charge more than $4500 after the client told him "up to $4500?" I would say a quick $100 profit is okay in this situation.
  • Options
    streeterstreeter Posts: 4,311 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Does the dealer have a standing deal to represent the client for a percentage basis or a per coin fee?

    I was a lic. broker in CA for 17 years selling COMM prop and I NEVER would have represented ANYONE including my father unless I had either a written agreement or complete handshake understanding and a hammer to enforce it.

    If it was me....ahem....I'd say 100 bucks and split the grind. 4500-4400=100/2=50 bucks on the grind...so marks gross profit would be 150 on the coin. If my math is correct.
    Have a nice day
  • Options
    dimplesdimples Posts: 1,286 ✭✭✭
    $4400 + future agreed upon commission usually 5%
  • Options
    relayerrelayer Posts: 10,570 ✭

    $4,599 ( plus S/H )
    image
    My posts viewed image times
    since 8/1/6
  • Options
    UncleJoeUncleJoe Posts: 2,552 ✭✭✭
    Client said up to $4500. Why would a dealer charge more than $4500 after the client told him "up to $4500?"

    Client said to offer the SELLER up to $4,500.

    I think it goes without saying that the buyer does not think that his dealer does not get compensated. IMO the payment to his dealer is the actual price paid the seller plus dhis dealer's compensation which most everyone seems to agree is 5%.

    Joe.
  • Options
    CommemDudeCommemDude Posts: 2,447 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Based on a similar experience I had, I would say $ 4700 is fair, the buyer should expect to compensate you $300 over your cost when you were able to get the coin at such a substantial discount from retail list for him. It also depends on whether the owner generally gives discounts for immediate check, etc, but in my experience that discount would have been maybe $150 for a desirable coin, so this coin could not be had for less than $ 4800 under the best circumstances, and he got it for less.


    Dr Mikey
    Commems and Early Type
  • Options
    291fifth291fifth Posts: 25,268 ✭✭✭✭✭
    $4,567.87
    All glory is fleeting.
  • Options
    dimplesdimples Posts: 1,286 ✭✭✭


    << <i>$4,567.87 >>



    and not a penny more! image

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file