Yo, stop with the conspiracy already, man. #1- The dude has a right to run a business and grade as he sees fit just the same as PCGS, NGC, ANACS and everyone else does...AFTERALL, GRADING IS SUBJECTIVE AND NOT A SCIENCE!
I cannot believe that you, a newbie, come on here an incite some hairbrain conspiracy to leave this man negatives when you have not so much as looked at one of his coins, IN YOUR HAND let alone buy one. Dude, this isn't grade school and looking to be accepted in such a childish manner is Bull$#!+
Here's a plan for you. Why don't you buy some of those MS and PF 70 coins from him, like more people around here do but don't care to admit, crack those babies out, send them to PCGS and make yourself some serious money. If you've noticed, if you've read his ditties, he's serious about customer satisfaction. So pick up some of these coins for next to nothing and presto-chang-o, have them become PCGS coins and make a killing before you run in here and show your backside.
I couldn't help but notice all the people responding so I decided I would. Now, take that and give it some serious thought! By the way, welcome to our house.
Sorry for making a post. You know, I am only 15 and have seen SGS coins (I didnt buy them though). I have been collecting for about 3 years now and I know quite well that most of his coins make the MS scale at about 63. Im not sure if you are on eBay but I read with my parents account about all the people complaining about being ripped off and paying 80.00 for about 3 dollars worth of coins. I thought maybe I could get some people to join the cause and help out if I posted here... The fact is that very few coins are MS70, they would virtually have to be untouched by another coin and never have a nick from the minting process. The chances of that are astronomical. So call me a newbie (I still consider myself one) but dont think you are better than me just because I am young and new at this. Also, it is against ANA standards to grade and sell your own companies coins isnt it? Just some food for thought since I am obviously not worthy of trying to help out the newer incoming members of our hobby. Thanks for the welcome.
Your heart might be in the right place and yes, realistically very few coin grade 70 BUT say they are 65/66 and you can pick decent stuff up for next to nothing, then what a great opportunity for a young Numismatist to fatten your own Bank Account. A lot of people buy his stuff and turn a profit although I must say, this just occurred to me recently when another forum member pointed him out to me. If I would buy from him (and believe me, I'm checking him out), the very first thing I would do is crack those coins out and get them in better holders and turn a profit. Also, check out how busy this guy is. He must move a lot of merchandise.
You'll be alright but it's not cool to run around looking to thrash someone when they could very easily turn out to be your "Honey Hole"....you know, like a favorite, secret fishing spot. There are some REAL BAD people on eBay, the kind that steal your items' descriptions and photos and sell unsuspecting people nothing but thin air or people with feedback so terrible that how they manage to stay on eBay is nothing short of amazing. Glad to have you with us and yes, I sell on eBay. I just haven't listed anything yet for the week. Stop by anytime.
p8nt, You have a right to express your opinions on this site without having the site bullies cream you for your opinion. They of course have the right to their opinions as well and if they want to argue that if fine. Body slam you,no!!! I am glad to see you followed up with more information but I don't think you owe anyone an apology. I think someone owes you one. Everyone on this forum was a "newbie" at one time. Also this "status" in no way indicates the level of numismatic knowledge attained by someone who just happened to join the forum recently. Welcome
Boom, get lost! Do you sell this crap or something? SGS and some of these other TPG are really causing financial harm in a big way. There was a post on the rec.coin.coolecting about an old guy who lost more than $200K on SGS slabs. It sounds like a good idea to me.
Since when does it become alright for a greaseball to rip people off just because one member here thinks he might be able to get a good coin or two at the expense of hundreds of others!
This young YN comes on with a good idea and gets scalded because of one persons greed. Yes, greed!
I think Mr. Boom owes a whole lot of apologies on this one!
p8nt, Welcome to the boards. Please excuse others who offend. I agree with the whole notion that TPG like SGS PCC others are dishing out MS & PF 70's like there's no tomorrow. This is ruining the hobby for many new collectors and some old one too. Nothing turns you off more then to find out you bought and VERY Overgraded coin thinking because it slabbed it's a good buy. Keep a thick skin and keep posting, Again Welcome and I like the way you think.
Boom, you did come down on him a little hard. I've seen quite a few SGS coins in person, and let's just say SGS dwells among the bottom feeders.
P8nt, a lot of what you say is true. But bidding in an auction just to post negative feedback is wrong. I've had it happen to me, and it is not a pleasant experience. Say what you will about aboncom and SGS, but don't try to correct a wrong with a wrong.
Hey P8nt, don't take it personally. Getting flamed just means someone took issue with your words, not you. I'm going to go out on a limb and say Boom didn't like your idea. No big deal, don't let it get to ya. If your not getting flamed your not getting involved!
<< <i>I think Mr. Boom owes a whole lot of apologies on this one! >>
Surely you jest!
Let's get this straight, like RIGHT NOW... I could give a rat's behind about SGS graded coins or this ridiculous seller that claims everything is a Perfect 70. Anyone, including the seller, that actually believes that every single coin he has to offer is perfect is either Numismatically and or Mentally challenged. This has nothing to do with particulars and everything to do with Principle.
My position is simply this. It is not acceptable to instigate a conspiracy for any and every one to leave unwarranted negatives. Two wrongs do not make a right. If you want to run him out of town, take it to eBay or a higher level and make your case.
To my fellow senior members I say that excusing such "misconduct" is just as disturbing. If and when I am wrong, I will be the first to stand up and admit it...PUBLICLY! Conversely, I WILL NOT apologize when I feel strongly enough to state my position in a Public Forum. Obviously, I have been misunderstood but there will be no apology from me regarding my position on this issue.
This is NOT about a particular seller or grading service. If you have an issue with any seller there is a right way to go about things and a whole bunch of wrong ways. THIS proposal is definitely a WRONG way! End of argument. Enough said.
p8nt, Pay no attention to being flamed !!!! Some people here seem to feed thier egos in this manner>
“A nation can survive its fools, and even the ambitious. But it cannot survive treason from within. An enemy at the gates is less formidable, for he is known and carries his banner openly."
All of the SGS coins that I've purchased, all came back a grade or two higer when submitted to the top tier graders like ACG, New- MIS- trust & PCCS. I just can't see what the problem is here.
Boom...Calm down, BRO.
Tom
What is money, in reality, but dirty pieces of paper and metal upon which privilege is stamped?
<< <i>Why don't you buy some of those MS and PF 70 coins from him, like more people around here do but don't care to admit, crack those babies out, send them to PCGS and make yourself some serious money. >>
Thanks for all of your input guys. But please, seriously, let this thread go away. I realize my intention was in the right place but my method was not. Hope no one has hurt feelings...
BTW, I'd still like to know who on this forum buys SGS and cracks them out and resells for serious money..
Razor, you're confusing SGS with SEGS. The young man does have a valid point and I applaud him wanting to help clean up eBay. Many of us feel the exact same way. It's just that his proposed method of acomplishing this dauntless task, is not ethical and if not careful he could find himself on the wrong side of civil litigation for damages. Right or wrong this seller has a right to earn a living. It is up to individual buyers to educate themselves. "Buy the Book before you buy the coin."
This is a perfect example...an EXTREME example of taking the "Grading is subjective" argument to the limit. Taking matters into one's own hands, inciting a conspiracy and quite possibly causing the seller damages could lead to litigation for said damages with the Courts' seeing this "Grading is subjective" as the deciding factor.
Old post`s never die, they reside farther down the list.....
“A nation can survive its fools, and even the ambitious. But it cannot survive treason from within. An enemy at the gates is less formidable, for he is known and carries his banner openly."
Comments
I cannot believe that you, a newbie, come on here an incite some hairbrain conspiracy to leave this man negatives when you have not so much as looked at one of his coins, IN YOUR HAND let alone buy one. Dude, this isn't grade school and looking to be accepted in such a childish manner is Bull$#!+
Here's a plan for you. Why don't you buy some of those MS and PF 70 coins from him, like more people around here do but don't care to admit, crack those babies out, send them to PCGS and make yourself some serious money. If you've noticed, if you've read his ditties, he's serious about customer satisfaction. So pick up some of these coins for next to nothing and presto-chang-o, have them become PCGS coins and make a killing before you run in here and show your backside.
I couldn't help but notice all the people responding so I decided I would. Now, take that and give it some serious thought!
By the way, welcome to our house.
You'll be alright but it's not cool to run around looking to thrash someone when they could very easily turn out to be your "Honey Hole"....you know, like a favorite, secret fishing spot. There are some REAL BAD people on eBay, the kind that steal your items' descriptions and photos and sell unsuspecting people nothing but thin air or people with feedback so terrible that how they manage to stay on eBay is nothing short of amazing. Glad to have you with us and yes, I sell on eBay. I just haven't listed anything yet for the week. Stop by anytime.
Peace
B00M-aka- pittbreeder
edited for spelling corrections
You stomped on him pretty hard for just expressing an idea you didn't like.
<< <i>You stomped on him pretty hard for just expressing an idea you didn't like. >>
Initiating a conspiracy to start leaving unjustified negatives sure IS an idea I do not like, no matter who the seller might be.
You have a right to express your opinions on this site without having the site bullies cream you for your opinion. They of course have the right to their opinions as well and if they want to argue that if fine. Body slam you,no!!! I am glad to see you followed up with more information but I don't think you owe anyone an apology. I think someone owes you one. Everyone on this forum was a "newbie" at one time. Also this "status" in no way indicates the level of numismatic knowledge attained by someone who just happened to join the forum recently. Welcome
This young YN comes on with a good idea and gets scalded because of one persons greed. Yes, greed!
I think Mr. Boom owes a whole lot of apologies on this one!
PURPLE!
Welcome to the boards. Please excuse others who offend.
I agree with the whole notion that TPG like SGS PCC others are
dishing out MS & PF 70's like there's no tomorrow. This is ruining
the hobby for many new collectors and some old one too. Nothing turns
you off more then to find out you bought and VERY Overgraded coin
thinking because it slabbed it's a good buy.
Keep a thick skin and keep posting,
Again Welcome and I like the way you think.
Smitty
P8nt, a lot of what you say is true. But bidding in an auction just to post negative feedback is wrong. I've had it happen to me, and it is not a pleasant experience. Say what you will about aboncom and SGS, but don't try to correct a wrong with a wrong.
<< <i>I think Mr. Boom owes a whole lot of apologies on this one! >>
Surely you jest!
Let's get this straight, like RIGHT NOW... I could give a rat's behind about SGS graded coins or this ridiculous seller that claims everything is a Perfect 70. Anyone, including the seller, that actually believes that every single coin he has to offer is perfect is either Numismatically and or Mentally challenged. This has nothing to do with particulars and everything to do with Principle.
My position is simply this. It is not acceptable to instigate a conspiracy for any and every one to leave unwarranted negatives. Two wrongs do not make a right. If you want to run him out of town, take it to eBay or a higher level and make your case.
To my fellow senior members I say that excusing such "misconduct" is just as disturbing. If and when I am wrong, I will be the first to stand up and admit it...PUBLICLY! Conversely, I WILL NOT apologize when I feel strongly enough to state my position in a Public Forum. Obviously, I have been misunderstood but there will be no apology from me regarding my position on this issue.
This is NOT about a particular seller or grading service. If you have an issue with any seller there is a right way to go about things and a whole bunch of wrong ways. THIS proposal is definitely a WRONG way! End of argument. Enough said.
- Marcus Tullius Cicero, 106-43 BC
Boom...Calm down, BRO.
Tom
Boom,
somebody hi jack your account here ?
So un like you to rip people !
Proof
Proof- I thought Russ was your hero??
Russ and i are tight !
Proof
<< <i>Why don't you buy some of those MS and PF 70 coins from him, like more people around here do but don't care to admit, crack those babies out, send them to PCGS and make yourself some serious money. >>
Gawd, I literally cannot stop laughing!
<< <i>Russ and i are tight ! >>
HMM...I'm not quite sure how to take that one.
Russ, NCNE
BTW, I'd still like to know who on this forum buys SGS and cracks them out and resells for serious money..
This is a perfect example...an EXTREME example of taking the "Grading is subjective" argument to the limit. Taking matters into one's own hands, inciting a conspiracy and quite possibly causing the seller damages could lead to litigation for said damages with the Courts' seeing this "Grading is subjective" as the deciding factor.
Better to have something like "Greysheet help please."
U.S. Nickels Complete Set with Major Varieties, Circulation Strikes
U.S. Dimes Complete Set with Major Varieties, Circulation Strikes
- Marcus Tullius Cicero, 106-43 BC