Grade the 19D Merc Dime. New Today and a Tough Date to find with a Nice Strike.

Fairlaneman · March 4, 2005 9:42AM

This coin and a 19S were purchased from a forum member. They arrived in the mail today. Both the 19D and 19S are real tough Mercs to obtain with nice strikes. Take a stab at the grade if you would like. Two different pictures are shown to let you see the strike. The coin also has a die break extending almost from top to bottom through Miss Liberty's head.

Ken

greghansen · March 4, 2005 11:35AM

Quite clearly, obviously, surely and undeniably a MS64FB.

21Walker · March 4, 2005 11:41AM

Agree......Nice Merc's..............Rick

dunerlaw · March 4, 2005 11:43AM

Super nice coins.
Both look like 64 and the 1919-d looks FB.

Fairlaneman · March 4, 2005 11:47AM

The first post was two shots of the 19D. Here is the 19S.

Ken

K6AZ · March 4, 2005 11:53AM

Ken, those are some nice Mercs. I saw the post on the BST board, so I won't cheat.

Numismanic · March 4, 2005 11:58AM

Very nice Mercs, I'll guess the '19-D grades 64FB, and the '19-S is a 64.

Fairlaneman · March 4, 2005 12:13PM

Eric one is under graded by atleast 1 point and possibly 2 on a good day. The 19D is just plain Killer strike wise. Thats all I will say for right now. I almost feel like sending more money to the seller but heck he got a very nice coin from me in this trade-a-roo. We both did well IMO.

Ken

K6AZ · March 4, 2005 12:15PM

I've been kind of busy with other coin stuff, but that was a nice looking group he put up. You don't come across nice early Mercs like that often.

XpipedreamR · March 4, 2005 12:18PM

I'll guess 64, no FB.

Fairlaneman · March 4, 2005 12:19PM

You should see the 42S I purchased raw out of that bunch. It makes these others look like dogs. That was his opinion also. One day PCGS will see it. Not for awhile though after the results on the submission these coins were in. Hmmm...is this a give away for the grade of the 19D.

Ken

mercurydimeguy · March 4, 2005 4:52PM

Ken,

Great pics

They are just BRUTAL (lately) when it comes to grading the key dates -- 18-D/S, 19-D/S...you know, the ususal suspects.

After a pretty good stab at getting a bunch of nice Mercs in to PCGS holders, having a good number serve as statistical pool from which to draw data, I would encourage everyone to hold off on submitting coins (at least Mercs) for grading.

Something is going on at PCGS -- and it's probably prudent to wait 'till things settle down.

I just got the grade in on this 18-D -- PCGS MS62FB. I didn't think it was a 65FB, but either a STELLAR 63FB or a good 64FB. I'll send it back in again in a little while (after things settle down) and let you know how it fares on a re-grade.

So based on how yours graded, Ken, imagine how nice the below are:

21906506 1925-S 10C USA MS64FB
21906507 1926-P 10C USA MS64FB
21906508 1928-P 10C USA MS65FB

Each one of these should be at least 1 point higher. If they don't find homes in the next couple of weeks they're going back in for re-grading (when things settle down a bit at PCGS).

And yes, Ken, do hold off on the 42-S -- they're barbarians over there now. If they don't put that coin in to a 67 holder I'd cry, as it would trully be a crime. Like you said, the 42-S not only makes the posted dimes look like dogs, it makes most dimes I've seen look like dogs.

Regards,

Mike.

Fairlaneman · March 5, 2005 12:38AM

Both of the coins, 19D and 19S, shown in the previous posts are MS63 coins. The 19S is but the 19D got caught on a late Friday afternoon rush. Here is my old 19D. Which would you rather have ?

Ken

greghansen · March 5, 2005 2:08AM

The new 19D if much nicer IMO since it has a much better strike on both the obv. and rev. I don't mind the toning, so I would far prefer the new over the old.

Edited to add, its kind of fun having such firm and certain opinions about a series I know nothing about.

mercurydimeguy · March 5, 2005 6:33AM

Here's the 25-S -- I have more than 6 MS66FB's that aren't as clean...there's basically nothing wrong with this coin. The surfaces are nice, the bands aren't beat up (sorry for the poor pic...the bands are nice and full). This coin graded 64FB...I was going to shoot some nicely toned 65FB's and 66FB's but I'm strapped for time.

I think the grader that got this batch simply didn't like original/nicely colored coins

Grade the 19D Merc Dime. New Today and a Tough Date to find with a Nice Strike.

Comments

Leave a Comment