Options
What do you think the four best investment coins are?
I'll start:
1893-S Morgan VG and better
1909-S VDB Cent MS grades
1916-D Dime F and better
1916 Standing quarter
David
1893-S Morgan VG and better
1909-S VDB Cent MS grades
1916-D Dime F and better
1916 Standing quarter
David
0
Comments
David
Mike
Lincoln Wheats (1909 - 1958) Basic Set - Always Interested in Upgrading!
Registry 1909-1958 Proof Lincolns
I agree with your list. I'll go further and say in any Certified grade, because they aren't making them anymore and they will get harder to find as the years roll by and more people get into the hobby.
That's why I have a 93-S in for certification right now that is at best G-4....
Ken
Personally I'd rather hunt areas less traveled if you are looking solely at trying to double your money. As collector coins without regards to future value, those 4 picks are great for holding value.
Though I think in this market we have the potential to see key date coins in popular series actually retreat in value when this upmove is finally over.
My 4 choices...nice orig toning and strictly graded of course! Remember this is only for trying to make more money...not keep what you got. And there is always risk in that kind of play. Hence these are speculator type coins that have a fairly decent demand from high end collectors too. What a coincidence, it's all 19th c. type.
No motto half MS65 or PF65 (esp 1854-55 MS)
Trade dollar MS65
Bust dime MS65 (small size)
PF65 stars obverse dime or half dime
1854/55 Arrows 25c MS65 (sorry couldn't do just 4)
roadrunner
<< <i>Sample Slabs
Sample Slabs
Sample Slabs
Sample Slabs
Cameron Kiefer >>
<< <i>Lincolncentman, I'll take the counterpoint on this one. I think those 4 choices are marginal picks due to the advances they have already seen. They aren't "rare" either as thousands of specimens abound. >>
Those coins don't need to be rare in order to be a good investmment. Scarcity and rarity helps but popularity is what counts. I agree that the 1893-s Morgan is not rare, but Morgans are a very popular coin series. I believe it is reasonable to assume that they will be in the future as well.
<< <i> personally hate this hot market but my perspective is that of a long time collector and the prices seem nuts. On the other hand new money coming in looks at this market with much different eyes. Last week I bought an 1864 PR-64 NGC Seated dime priced at a little under the current market for a few hundred dollars. There were only a little over 400 of these minted, and maybe less than 300 in all grades still in existence. To someone new in the market to buy one of only 300 of anything on the planet has to seem like a great opportunity even at twice the price >>
OTOH there is a reason this buyer was able to buy that coin for a few hundred dollars. Apparently collector interest is somewhat limited so if you are looking at investor type coins I would separate them into a popular or esoteric category and go from there. When the time comes to sell your investment you want a ready market; you don't want to spend 6 months looking for a buyer.
PR65 stars obv. dime or half dime
1857 Proof FE cent (esp. cam)
1887 red proof IHC (esp cam)
MS63 or better S mint $5 Indians
True Deep Cameo 1965 and 1966 SMS Washingtons.
True Deep Cameo 1965 and 1966 SMS Jeffersons.
True Deep Cameo 1965 and 1966 SMS Lincolns.
Russ, NCNE
Tyler
I'd pick coins in a popular series that have the best value per population rarity. If you look at Buffalo Nickel prices before grading companies, 21-s was actually the best date, but pops proved 26-s and other dates were tougher, and all values slowly shifted from more historical values to values correpsonding to pops. Other series sort have yet to do this. Some early Lincolns and Indian Cents have amazingly low pops relative to price. I'm only going to say dates I already have
I hate it when you see my post before I can edit the spelling.
Always looking for nice type coins
my local dealer
I had one chance as I took $$ out of the stock market to buy these coins.
1916-D 10c NGC MS-67FB
1921 50c PCGS MS-66 (Lee)
1945 10c NGC MS-67FB
1955/55 DDO PCGS MS-65RD
I bought others as well but did not think any of them as "investment coins."
Some of these coins have risen in value beyond my expectation. Do I think these four coins are still good "investments?"
Only if they are coins that you wanted for your collection anyway.
Never buy a coin that does not excite you just for the sake of investment. You need to buy what strikes your fancy...............all important!
Do I think these are still great coins? Indeed. Investment? Hard to predict.
I prefer yo think in terms of what would be hard to replace at the price price level.
Others coins I like and bought.
1942-S 50c PCGS MS-66
1942/1 10c in any grade
1972 DDO 1c in MS-64RD or better
the best......obw rolls.
<< <i>I prefer yo think in terms of what would be hard to replace at the price price level. >>
Like, for example, true deep cameo 1965 and 1966 SMS coins.
Russ, NCNE
That is indeed the litmus test.
The second test is that the collector has to like such coins for his collection.
I remembered how tough it was to find those Deep Cameo SMS coins. Impossible is closer to the reality.
I go nuts for the deep cam SMS quarters.
<< <i>Russ:
That is indeed the litmus test.
The second test is that the collector has to like such coins for his collection.
I remembered how tough it was to find those Deep Cameo SMS coins. Impossible is closer to the reality.
I go nuts for the deep cam SMS quarters. >>
These are great coins. Another grossly underappreciated area is PL moderns circulation issues.
Most of these are ugly so people tend to avoid them but the attractive ones are unbelievable and
most are rare.
You were very fortunate to find those great 4 coins back in 1997 and have the foresight to buy. I thought the coin market was on the threshold of teetering over for good at that time. I wasn't buying anything and stayed away from the Eliasberg sale which in hindsight was completely inane. The Norweb sales of 1987-1988 lit off the 1988-1990 bull market. The Eliasberg sale lit off the 1997-date bull market. Curiously, we are into a 6-7 year run of increasing prices, with most of coming in the last 1-2 years.
Some coins that have not yet gone up in price in this market but have good records in the past:
MS 65 RD copper type: half cents, large cents, 2c pieces. These have
not really budged yet. And gradeflation hasn't hit them quite as
much as silver coins. The half cents are much tougher than the
large cents and don't sell for much more.
MS65 nickel type: 3c nickel, Lib and Shield nickels
No drapery seated quarter in MS63 or 64: try to find a decent one!
I've been looking for a legit 64 for 15 years. Seen maybe 6-10
dogs in that time.
Barber type in MS65: hasn't really taken off yet
Seated type in MS65: hasn't really taken off yet
Most classic commems in nice 65 or 66: still waiting
roadrunner
The 1825 half cent, Cohen 1 variety, in AU or Unc.
1907-S Barber half in XF or AU.
1913-S Lincoln in MS64RD or MS65RD.
Since that's way out of my league, common date Morgans graded by either NGC or PCGS from 65-68 seem pretty reasonable. Some of the 67s are bouncing around between $850-$1100. And a couple of the 68s are $3000-$3500. The PLs aren't that much more in the common dates either. Looking at the Heritage Auction tonight, some even look like they've come down in price. I managed a MS66PL, MS67, and a MS68 before I busted my budget.
So, this is my pick now. I'm going to start buying common date PCGSMS67 mercury dimes. Some are under $100 with 3 dates under $50. And some of the FBs are under $200. I'm not sure what the pop report for the common date mercs are, But, there must be a whole lot of them for some to be under $50. And who knows if there are more that can be graded that high, but I'm going to buy about 10 of them anyway.
I got smoked by hanging on to some MS66 FB Mercs in 1990. They dropped by 60% as more and more got made. I suspect MS67 Mercs today will fare the same...just too common. MS66 and 67 Morgans are sharply up in price. 67's were $450 and are now $750 and higher. They have experienced strong growth already. The 65's have gone from $75 to $120, a nice move too. I predicted a price of $125 back over a year ago. We are now there.
Since those 67's are probably the 66's from the 1989 era, they are closing in on their all-time highs. These tend to be speculative coins that run up a lot in good times...but they might fall like stones at the first sign of any trouble.
roadrunner
<< <i>What? No Ike's?
Top notch investment coin!
... MS Bust gold, any southern gold and any pre 1818 type in MS
MS 65 RD copper type: half cents, large cents, 2c pieces. These have
not really budged yet. And gradeflation hasn't hit them quite as
much as silver coins. The half cents are much tougher than the
large cents and don't sell for much more.
MS65 nickel type: 3c nickel, Lib and Shield nickels
No drapery seated quarter in MS63 or 64: try to find a decent one!
I've been looking for a legit 64 for 15 years. Seen maybe 6-10
dogs in that time.
Barber type in MS65: hasn't really taken off yet
Seated type in MS65: hasn't really taken off yet
Most classic commems in nice 65 or 66: still waiting
roadrunner
specifically....................
1,,,,,,,,superb gem matte proof RED 1909 lincoln cent
2........... superb gem satin proof 1936 buffs exceptionally toned even better
in generAL
1,,,,,,,,choice to gem proof type coins pre 1916 evenmoreso exceptionally eye appeal toned and/or strong to deep cameo contrast
2..............choice to gem mintstate type coins pre 1916 evenmoreso exceptional eye appeal original white thick skinned coins and/or toned coins
3................ gem and higher early commems evenmoreso exceptionally eye appealling original white coins and/or nicely toned greatly toned surfaces
4,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,superb gem short set walkers evenmoreso exceptionally eye appealling rainbow toned coins with thick original white skins............... rare birds!
5......... choice to gem proof large and half cents ................. classic head and/or pre 1840 even better
classic coins like these are unsung yet unappreciated american treasures
6.............most nice eye appealling type coins pre 1916 fine to xf
7............gem and higher early s mint non fbl franklins with amazing color
michael
<< <i>Uncle Wiggly, I like the idea of major rarities, but I don't have the $1+ Mill needed to play. Those rarities did indeed drop in price during the 1980's (or was it the early 90's?). I recall a 10-20% drop in 1804 dollars. They don't always go up but they have a great long term track record.
I got smoked by hanging on to some MS66 FB Mercs in 1990. They dropped by 60% as more and more got made. I suspect MS67 Mercs today will fare the same...just too common. MS66 and 67 Morgans are sharply up in price. 67's were $450 and are now $750 and higher. They have experienced strong growth already. The 65's have gone from $75 to $120, a nice move too. I predicted a price of $125 back over a year ago. We are now there.
Since those 67's are probably the 66's from the 1989 era, they are closing in on their all-time highs. These tend to be speculative coins that run up a lot in good times...but they might fall like stones at the first sign of any trouble.
roadrunner >>
roadrunner,
I don't have that type of money either, but if I did I still think that would be the way to go. And, I don't mean just having enough money to buy a 1-5 kind of a rarity, but be able to handle it financially, especially if you needed to hold it for awhile. I read a article titled "The Day the Bubble Burst" by Robert R.Van Ryzin. It talked of the mania of the high prices in the late 80s (1881S MS65 $ rose to $500 retail value!) and the bubble burst in late 1990 on into late 1991. This quote is of particular interest on why the prices got so high in the late 1980s. "It wasn't so much how many coins were minted anymore, or how many survived, but how many had been encapsulated by grading services in a given grade." I don't know how much of that holds true today.
Since the late 1980s differences between today's grading companies is more defined. Instead of a bunch of grading companies hitting the scene in a short time with all sorts of grading standards where if it said MS65, then it must be, we have distinct lines drawn around the grading companies. Aside from a scam, no one today is going to pay for or be offered a PCGSMS65 81S $ under the pretense it might be the last one you'll see. There won't be a zoom to $500. Affordability of the common date Morgans even into MS68 for some dates as compared to the rest is taking more of these off the market into collections. So there is value being added with the decreased availabilty. But, there's still enough availabilty for speculation! 81S MS67s moved up about $200 in 2 months, but have since retreated about $125-50. But the low has been above the previous low the majority of the time for the past year. The PLs are becoming scarce but nowhere near rare. MS68PLs have quickly disappeared. Their value should increase the most for commons. I don't have a clue about DMPL or DPL for commons. I wonder what one of the PCGSMS69 1881S Morgans would sell for if brought to the market right now. I believe the last reported price in the price guide is $40,000.
Well, as for MS67 Mercs in common dates. You talked me out of it. Thanks!
An interesting look back in time!!
I have found power in the mysteries of thought.
It is always a question of knowing and seeing, and not that of believing.
Our virtues, and our failings are inseparable, like force, and matter. When they separate, man is no more.
.
2. Saint Gaudens $20 MS65 and up
3. MPL's
4. Confederate Coinage
<< <i>1901-S barber quarter in Fine or VF, give yourself a decade or two to find one though.
Tyler >>
ReEdited: 5/19/08 - 10:30 PM.
Tyler,
I originally thought I had remembered a pair of 1901-S's, however,
it was a pair of 1913-S's that I had looked at last night.
There's a nice VG/Fine and a beautiful VF 30 both in PCGS holders coming up in some auction soon -
I saw the images and they're both great coins and they were on Heritage's site .
- although there's the 1901-S in PCGS MS 66 @ Hamrick's available for $145K. Nice coin - very nice.
BTW, the 1901-S PCGS AU 50 - looks XF 40ish - at DLRC which didn't sell at $42,500 last week and didn't sell again tonight at $33,500. I don't know what the reserve is, sorry to say.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
<< <i>I'll start:
1893-S Morgan VG and better
1909-S VDB Cent MS grades
1916-D Dime F and better
1916 Standing quarter
David >>
<< <i>Tough to disagree with these four. >>
IMHO, it's pretty easy to disagree with 2 or 3 of them. The 93-S is overrated and overvalued. It's not even close to rare as there are usually two dozen on eBay at any given time. It's also skyrocketed in price the past 4-5 years, how much more can it go up? The S-VDB will go up in 2009 and maybe 2010, but then come back to earth. 1916 Standing quarter has been relatively stagnant from what I've seen, but it was already extremely expensive...not sure how much higher it can go....it's priced itself out of most collectors' budgets. However, I can see 1916-D Dimes in any grade being good investments. It's a popular set and a famous coin..similar to the S-VDB I guess, but I really think the S-VDB will have a decline after the next couple years.
If I were to pick good investment coins I would say:
Large Size Capped Bust and Draped Bust quarters F/VF+
Key date Barber quarters and halves
Teens and 20s Lincoln cents in collector grades through MS.
My two cents.
The name is LEE!
a)1964 sms coins
b)proof morgan dollars
c)cameo 1936 to 42 proofs
d)proof gold pre 33'
1838-C $5 - nothing but demand from collectors of Southern gold, Classic Head gold, and first year of Charlotte Mint. Upcoming books on Classic Head gold and Charlotte gold will increase demand.
Capped Bust quarters - not many good coins, more collectors will be brought in by two upcoming books.
1807-1812 $5 AU - the entry level coin for early gold. Enormous demand for type, every collector dreams of having early gold.
1806 small stars .50 - A scarce sleeper redbook variety that is harder to find nice than 1806/inv6
edit - have to add another, pre 1982 cents. Where else can you get copper for a third of spot?
Now I am not trying to burst anyone's bubble....I'm just using the process of elimination.
<< <i>
<< <i>I'll start:
1893-S Morgan VG and better
1909-S VDB Cent MS grades
1916-D Dime F and better
1916 Standing quarter
David >>
-------------------
Me Too: The fact is 93s Morgans have just continued up and up--but
I'd add the G-4 to G-6 coins IF IF IF untampered, uncleaned---
All theses are TOUGH to find original--
So they're NOT as common as you guys think!!!
<< <i>After a thorough and objective analysis of all coin series, I have selected the best four investment coins in terms of timeliness and value. I just happen to own these four coins
1838-C $5 - nothing but demand from collectors of Southern gold, Classic Head gold, and first year of Charlotte Mint. Upcoming books on Classic Head gold and Charlotte gold will increase demand.
Capped Bust quarters - not many good coins, more collectors will be brought in by two upcoming books.
1807-1812 $5 AU - the entry level coin for early gold. Enormous demand for type, every collector dreams of having early gold.
1806 small stars .50 - A scarce sleeper redbook variety that is harder to find nice than 1806/inv6
edit - have to add another, pre 1982 cents. Where else can you get copper for a third of spot? >>
I have a feeling it won't be long until the Classic head gold becomes as coveted as the early gold. At least ones with original surfaces. There are significantly more of them but the farther in time we get the more they fit the era and mystique.
It's also skyrocketed in price the past 4-5 years
Yah, thanks. I posted that it was a winner about four year ago. Notice the date of the post? At this point, I'd say the 93-S is a good hold coin, but I dont think I'd go out and buy one specificly for the purpose of investment. At this point, I'd go with the following:
1914-D Lincoln in XF-AU or better
Semi-key AU58 Lincolns
1916-D merc is still a winner IMHO, From Full Rim G through VF35 would be my target range
1877 Indian in XF45 to AU58
-David