Want to bet this isn't going to show up on Ebay as something found in Grandpa's stuff after he passed way, being sold by someone that knows nothing about coins. Oh, and with no returns, either.
Might as well make this in to something educational for those of us with a pin's head worth of knowledge.
Auction coin:
Real 1799 Eagle:
What are the telltale signs on a fake? What I can see so far is that the stars on the fake are flatter, more spread out and not as crisp. The numbers in the date also appear to be different. What are the other things to look for?
<< <i>What are the telltale signs on a fake? What I can see so far is that the stars on the fake are flatter, more spread out and not as crisp. The numbers in the date also appear to be different. What are the other things to look for? >>
Pay close attention to Miss Liberty's facial details. They are all wrong on the bogo. Eye, nose and mouth.
Russ, now that was a good post! Excellent, instead of just saying it is bogus, explaining in detail why is very helpful. Not everyone knows how to spot a counterfiet that is not super obvious. Although I would accept that it is counterfeit, I could not have determined it on my own easily.
<< <i>Might as well make this in to something educational for those of us with a pin's head worth of knowledge.
Auction coin:
Real 1799 Eagle:
What are the telltale signs on a fake? What I can see so far is that the stars on the fake are flatter, more spread out and not as crisp. The numbers in the date also appear to be different. What are the other things to look for?
Russ, NCNE >>
All of the lettering on the fake look wrong, too close together, the neck of the eagle is not defined on the fake, the a in america on the left leg seems to disapear on the fake instead of a nice bold bottom, a whole buncha stuff now that you showed the real one!!! Thanks Russ, nice lesson.....
I'm no expert on 1799 Eagles, but I do know there were several die varities, so variations in lettering compared to a "real one," etc., isn't enough to call it a fake.
Agreed, die varieties have subtle differences in the placement and spacing of the devices and lettering, and the strike also varied on these early coins.
at first glance the auction coin looks pretty darned good, I'd like to see it in hand.
Hey! another outstanding thread. I know very little about early USA Gold, and could easily be fooled. But, to be safe, I've made a rule to never buy these types of coins except in one of the "big three" slabs.
I'm the Proud recipient of a genuine "you suck" award dated 1/24/05. I was accepted into the "Circle of Trust" on 3/9/09.
This coin is about as real as they get, it looks and feels absolutly authentic. This coin weighs 17.5 grams
It's as real as they get, but it's not real?! I was intrigued by his assessment of the weight- is that the correct weight for that brand of eagle, and do counterfeit gold coins ever get the weight right to the half gram??
My style is impetuous, my defense is impregnable !
According to the Offical PCGS guide to counterfeit detection and grading, very few early gold coins were counterfeited. This was probably due to they cost much money, and a counterfeiter would need to get a geniune one to use as a mold for the fake ones, thus destroying it. Things to look for:
Comments
Oh, and with no returns, either.
Ray
Auction coin:
Real 1799 Eagle:
What are the telltale signs on a fake? What I can see so far is that the stars on the fake are flatter, more spread out and not as crisp. The numbers in the date also appear to be different. What are the other things to look for?
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>What are the telltale signs on a fake? What I can see so far is that the stars on the fake are flatter, more spread out and not as crisp. The numbers in the date also appear to be different. What are the other things to look for? >>
Pay close attention to Miss Liberty's facial details. They are all wrong on the bogo. Eye, nose and mouth.
Tom
<< <i>Might as well make this in to something educational for those of us with a pin's head worth of knowledge.
Auction coin:
Real 1799 Eagle:
What are the telltale signs on a fake? What I can see so far is that the stars on the fake are flatter, more spread out and not as crisp. The numbers in the date also appear to be different. What are the other things to look for?
Russ, NCNE >>
All of the lettering on the fake look wrong, too close together, the neck of the eagle is not defined on the fake, the a in america on the left leg seems to disapear on the fake instead of a nice bold bottom, a whole buncha stuff now that you showed the real one!!! Thanks Russ, nice lesson.....
at first glance the auction coin looks pretty darned good, I'd like to see it in hand.
the fake one would make a great pocket piece!
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
But the more knowledgable folks here have taught me one thing in the last year.......
If someone is selling a $20,000 coin on EBay and it ain't in a slab...
It ain't a $20,000 coin.......
It ain't a $20,000 coin.......
great line!
plug in any big number in above quote and repeat when tempted.
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
<< <i>If someone is selling a $20,000 coin on EBay and it ain't in a slab...
It ain't a $20,000 coin.......
great line!
plug in any big number in above quote and repeat when tempted. >>
It's as real as they get, but it's not real?!
<< <i>is that the correct weight for that brand of eagle >>
Yep, 17.5 grams is correct.
Russ, NCNE
--------T O M---------
-------------------------
-- Uneven, weak lettering.
-- Grainy texture
-- Small lumps under magification
-- Toolmarks. (Raised lines)
-- Slippery feel
-- Uneven edge
----
On this coin the lettering is weak, the strike appears to be weaker. The lettering is un-even.That's about all I can see.
Collecting Morgans in Any Grade