Options
Hairlines: Good Photo of What PCGS Doesn't Like on Proofs?
Can anybody post a picture or several of what the hairlines look like on proofs (moderns, Frankies and later) that PCGS lowers your grade for?
DSW
0
Comments
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
Russ, NCNE >>
You call those hairlines? Looks a little more like a swipe with 180 grit sandpaper to me.
John Marnard Keynes, The Economic Consequences of the Peace, 1920, page 235ff
<< <i>You call those hairlines? >>
Yes, they're hairlines. A very high number of Accented Hair Kennedy Halves come right out of the mint packaging looking like that. It's one of the reasons they are difficult in high grade.
Want to see them vanish?
Same coin.
Russ, NCNE
i think what the other guys are talking about is that those marks on your Kennedy seem to be from something that happened after the minting process, friction of some type. i'd say that because in the photo they appear to be connected over the coins entire surface but stop as they come to where the portrait starts. hairlines would more likely just be in the fields from die polishing, right?? what Lawman is probably wanting to see are those faint ones that can be a grade killer yet are limited to the fields and dificult to see.
of course, i could be wrong on all counts.
hey Lawman
just keep looking at proof coins while tilting them around under a strong light like a halogen. you'll see them-----eventually. it'll probably be like a lightbulb coming on in your head!!!!
al h.
Die polishing marks don't qualify as hairlines, and are raised out of the surface, as opposed to hairlines being rubbed into the surface.
I have a nice 1921 Pilgrim commemorative that is terchnically an MS-64, but was market graded down by PCGS to an MS-62 for prominent die polish markd in the fields!
___________________________
click to email me
ronsrarecoin.com
ebay auctions for ronsrarecoin-com
<< <i>I thought the hairlines were supposed to be hard to see and you had to hold them up to the light, on the night of a full moon, with a black cat bone and a mojo hand, and the jondeknokeroo. >>
If they're that difficult to detect, they're also going to be virtually impossible to image. The first image was shot at a severe angle under harsh high wattage lighting. The second image is much closer to what the coin looks like to the naked eye - at first glance.
Russ, NCNE
And, if I may ask, how did you get a dog like that to look so nice as in the second picture. I can't believe simply dipping it would do it, but you obviously have a lot of experience with Kennedy halves. Or is it just the lighting?
David
<< <i>Is that die polish then? >>
No, they're hairlines.
<< <i>Russ, you can see lines actually crossing from the fields to the devices. >>
Hairlines frequently cross devices. It is die polish lines that usually don't.
<< <i>And, if I may ask, how did you get a dog like that to look so nice as in the second picture. I can't believe simply dipping it would do it, but you obviously have a lot of experience with Kennedy halves. Or is it just the lighting? >>
Hairlines won't dip off. It's lighting and angle. I originally shot those examples to demonstrate how deceiving images of proof coins can be.
Russ, NCNE
i stand corrected!!
al h.
many earlier proof's left the mint with hairlines
easiest to see in the fields - you could think of them as nicks on a MS 64/65 Morgan
al h.
just think what taking out of cellophane from the early 50's does - you see the CAM, but can not see the hairlines through the cellophane - big drop in value from original proof box/packaging to nice hairlined proof on the Franklin which is roughly half the value of the proof set.