Options
POLL: Which coin is dipped, and which is not?
There's always a lot of discussion about whether or not one can tell if a coin has been dipped. Some say yes, some say no. Let's see how many can correctly pick which one of these has been dipped, and which has not. This is not a trick question, one has and one hasn't.


Russ, NCNE


Russ, NCNE
0
Comments
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Russ, good thread and I'm not gonna guess on this one. Just a suggestion..... you have a 1964 which is 90% silver, and a 1965 which is 40% silver. I believe to try and get a more accurate guess perhaps they should both be the same composition of silver. Only because the look and luster of the coin can look different >>
Ditto, and hard to tell from a photo anyway.
The Ludlow Brilliant Collection (1938-64)
<< <i>and I'm not gonna guess on this one. >>
So, I assume you chose option #3.
The 1965 surface is 800 fine silver. There is little to no difference in surface charatecteristics between it and the 900 fine silver of the 1964.
<< <i>Ditto, and hard to tell from a photo anyway. >>
Which is really the point of the thread. The vast majority of assertions made around here are based solely on an image.
Russ, NCNE
David
<< <i>
<< <i>and I'm not gonna guess on this one. >>
So, I assume you chose option #3.
Russ, NCNE >>
LOL, actually I didn't even look at the poll options and rarely do. But now that you mention option 3 and I read it. Yeah I choose option 3!!!!
Looking for PCGS AU58 Washington's, 32-63.
<< <i><< Ditto, and hard to tell from a photo anyway. >>
Which is really the point of the thread. The vast majority of assertions made around here are based solely on an image. >>
I see your point, but I do think there can be images that represent a coin very accurately.
<< <i>but I do think there can be images that represent a coin very accurately. >>
You're looking at two.
Russ, NCNE
These both look very nice.
I would say the 64
www.wornoutboots@yahoo.com
Russ, NCNE
When we are planning for posterity, we ought to remember that virtue is not hereditary.
Thomas Paine
hey stman
that has got to be one of the biggest reaches on a disclaimer that i've heard in a while!!!!!!!!!!! actually, the outer layer of the clad Kennedy half-dollars is 80% and not the oft thought 40%, with the difference in weight and the inner core composition accounting for the 40% overall silver designation. the resultant difference in appearance which you alledge would sway the validity of Russ' comparison is a moot point-----the coins as dipped will appear the same. i think the pictures bear that out.
as with the other thread about the equal composition coins, this only highlights the flawed thinking of those who's ignorance allows them to believe they can tell a properly dipped coin.
my suggestion, Russ, would be to take about 10-20 cartwheel Kennedy's with one dipped coin and ask the guys who think they can tell a dipped coin to pick the "dippee" out. i would imagine your correct guesses would render the discussion finished, game-set-match, after page one!!!!!!
good threads.
al h.
Ogden
Both coins are currently in at PCGS and I have both going MS66.
Russ, NCNE
Edit