It is sad to think that the most exciting designs that have been created employ the use of state outlines. You would have though that most people can envision the general outlines of all 50 states, or at least most of them. They make boring, dull and uninspirative artwork.
Jamie Yakes - U.S. paper money collector, researcher, and author. | Join the SPMCUS Small-Size Notes, National Bank Notes, and NJ Depression Scrip
<< <i>It is sad to think that the most exciting designs that have been created employ the use of state outlines. You would have though that most people can envision the general outlines of all 50 states, or at least most of them. They make boring, dull and uninspirative artwork. >>
I must respectfully disagree. Our esteemed boardmembers excluded, most high school graduates can't even name all 50 states or even tell you what area of the country they're in (north, east, south, west), let alone visualize an outline. I do agree however that a state outline is a pretty lame concept for the quarters.
in my opinion, when less than half of the Statehood designs show more than elementary school level artistic ability, the age of beautiful American coins is over. Are there that few talented artists in this country ?
Texas could have incorporated more inspiring symbols, ie. the Alamo, longhorn cattle, ZZ-Top. But a star on an outline of Texas ?
<< <i>Lame ... very lame. Interesting that the Lone Star isn't over Austin, but apparently Arlington, where the artist lives. (No, I don't know him.) >>
I thought it was over Fort Worth. I do like the larriat rim though.
Damn that's boring. That tears it, on Monday I'm going down to the coin shop, buying the Canada 125 Provincial/Territorial quarters, photographing them and posting them to show you how this sort of thing is REALLY done.
As a Texan, I must agree that they missed it. Lots of history, culture... heck, we were almost our own country! And it also baffles me why the star isn't over Austin. Given the unique nature of the state outline, I'll bet most folks can imagine it already.
Tom
NOTE: No trees were killed in the sending of this message. However, a large number of electrons were terribly inconvenienced.
Type collector since 1981 Current focus 1855 date type set
Blade, did you know Texas carries a clause in it's state...oh man...haha...whats it called....the papers....constitution, thats it...
Texas' constitution still carries to this day that it can succeed from the union at any time and form it's own government and be independant and self governed.
sorry to OT...just thought thats kinda cool.
No offense to Texans, but that is a boring design. Unfortunately par with the course.
I maybe the lone voice with this opinion, but heck it is the lone star state and I think the design is attractive. Sometimes less is more, my favorite quarters so far are Connecticut and Mississippi. Both are simple uncluttered and artistically attractive. Cluttering up a coin a few things a state is known for is way too busy for a coin that size. I prefer one that tells you right away that is Texas. I bet the silver proof will be very attractive. I can only hope that we get no more with a bridge or a ship on it, been done to death.
I wrote a letter to the Gov early on, asking for a little creativity (I'd seen some really neat designs proposed), and to avoid the bland star-and-state-outline that was being proposed. He wrote back the ol' form letter. The only thing I remember about it is it said I'd be proud of the design.
Yeah. Right. zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
I hope other states won't lose this opportunity and will rise to the occasion, like we in Texas did not.
<< <i>How many states have a father/son dual become president of the good ole U.S. of A.? >>
One, Massachusetts. Birthplace of John Adams and John Quincy Adams. Although both of the Bushs lived in Texas neither one was from there George H W Bush was from Massachusetts and George W Bush was from Connecticut.
And here I thought that Ga was lame with it's outline and the peach. My favorite designs so far have been Arkansas and Mississippi. Maine has a real nice design as well.
Comments
<< <i>It is sad to think that the most exciting designs that have been created employ the use of state outlines. You would have though that most people can envision the general outlines of all 50 states, or at least most of them. They make boring, dull and uninspirative artwork. >>
I must respectfully disagree. Our esteemed boardmembers excluded, most high school graduates can't even name all 50 states or even tell you what area of the country they're in (north, east, south, west), let alone visualize an outline. I do agree however that a state outline is a pretty lame concept for the quarters.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
elementary school level artistic ability, the age of beautiful American coins is over.
Are there that few talented artists in this country ?
Texas could have incorporated more inspiring symbols, ie. the Alamo, longhorn cattle,
ZZ-Top. But a star on an outline of Texas ?
What will Hawaii decide on ? A pineapple ?
Come on over ... to The Dark Side!
I can think of a dozen reasons not to have high capacity magazines, but it's the reasons I haven't thought about that I need them.
<< <i> When I think of texas I think of Ozzy peeing on the Alamo. >>
When a real Texan thinks of Ozzy, they consider what a sweet f@g-mistress Ozzy would have been to Santa Ana.
<< <i>Lame ... very lame. Interesting that the Lone Star isn't over Austin, but apparently Arlington, where the artist lives. (No, I don't know him.) >>
I thought it was over Fort Worth.
NOTE: No trees were killed in the sending of this message. However, a large number of electrons were terribly inconvenienced.
Type collector since 1981
Current focus 1855 date type set
.......hence the design choice explanation - simple, to the point - the "lone star" on the state ... and the date.
what really irks me is the dude is from where???????? aghhhhhhhh
Texas' constitution still carries to this day that it can succeed from the union at any time and form it's own government and be independant and self governed.
sorry to OT...just thought thats kinda cool.
No offense to Texans, but that is a boring design. Unfortunately par with the course.
I hate it when you see my post before I can edit the spelling.
Always looking for nice type coins
my local dealer
That star is centered over Texas Stadium, cause it's the Dallas Cowboys quarter!
I don't know what you guys are talking about. I think it's about time somebody thought to put the outline of the state on their quarter!
Yeah. Right. zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
I hope other states won't lose this opportunity and will rise to the occasion, like we in Texas did not.
Here's a warning parable for coin collectors...
How many states have a father/son dual become president of the good ole U.S. of A.?
<< <i>How many states have a father/son dual become president of the good ole U.S. of A.? >>
One, Massachusetts. Birthplace of John Adams and John Quincy Adams. Although both of the Bushs lived in Texas neither one was from there George H W Bush was from Massachusetts and George W Bush was from Connecticut.