Options
Man, I get tired of returning coins.
Two for two on my last purchases.
Photos that conceal flaws that should be obvious to the casual observer if the seller exposes them. Both coins had fair return policies, and both were coins I'd love to own if as described. Why conceal the problem knowing they'll be coming back? I look, research, compare, and scrutinize the photos at good magnification and contrast, hoping to get a fair idea what the coin looks like, only to receive a coin that in no way resembles the coin in the photo. Two in a row now that had obvious hairlines from a good scrub that were perfectly obscured by the angle and lighting. OK, a trip to the post office, purchase a money order, mail payment, wait 10 days, and open the envelope only to see dull areas in the field or on the devices that are hairlined to h-ll. Now, email the sellers, another trip to the post office, and wait to see if my money is returned, hoping the whole time the seller is more honest than the photos indicate. Come on guys......!
Ok, rant over, but really, I wonder how many times this happens? Every seller wants to get all they can for their coin when they sell, but a some point, minimizing or concealing flaws in a photo really begins to look like deception. It sure leaves a rotten taste in my mouth. I won't mention the sellers names, because I am not sure everyone who looks at a coin knows what they see and that would be unfair, but I'd love to know how often it happens to the rest of you. I usually return about 10% of my purchases, but lately, I seem to be seeing more problems than usual. What percentage do you return?
Ok, rant over, but really, I wonder how many times this happens? Every seller wants to get all they can for their coin when they sell, but a some point, minimizing or concealing flaws in a photo really begins to look like deception. It sure leaves a rotten taste in my mouth. I won't mention the sellers names, because I am not sure everyone who looks at a coin knows what they see and that would be unfair, but I'd love to know how often it happens to the rest of you. I usually return about 10% of my purchases, but lately, I seem to be seeing more problems than usual. What percentage do you return?
Developing theory is what we are meant to do as academic researchers
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
0
Comments
"Senorita HepKitty"
"I want a real cool Kitty from Hepcat City, to stay in step with me" - Bill Carter
I feel your pain. When I was building my proof Kennedy set, there were days when I returned every coin that came in for problems that somehow slipped the seller's mind when they were listing the coin. Usually peripheral haze. I still have three that I need to replace that I got stuck with buying them from sellers with no return policy.
Russ, NCNE
1) make sure return policy is in place
2) write seller on every coin you are interested in and ask if coin has hairlines or problems not seen. LET THEM KNOW that coin will come back if coin has hairlines and or undisclosed problems. Most sellers would rather avoid the headache too if they know you are serious.
3) number 2
4) number 3
5) number 4
Tyler
Stman, can't say yet, but here's one that is.
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
I guess no guts no glory huh?
Although I do work for a dealer I still buy from other dealers for my personal collection. I'd say that return rate even after asking plenty of question ahead of time still runs about 30%. I'm pretty particular and often one person's idea of a nice coin is not the same as mine or vice versa. As long as they don't mind returns and I'm upfront about the possibility, I'm more than glad to take a look. I do hate those weeks though when postage seems to run a bit high.
Coin went for 2900.00 Ms-63+ money (Buyer obviously did not ask for better photo's as I did.
<< <i>Tonelover... does BS mean Bluesheet? >>
That was the nicest way I could put it. Actually I bit my tongue for that reply.
Tonelover, I fully agree. To be honest, when I bid on those coins it was with larceny in mind.
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
In my last batch from PCGS, I discovered that some of my proofs had a bit of haze I missed when they were in the US Mint trays.
They still graded PR69DCAM. I went through all of my 2001 mint clad proof sets, and half have the same haze. I pulled them out and put them into the junk bin. I"ll probably break them open and have the good coins ones graded. I'm not sure what to do with the rest.
The only thing I can figure out (since none of my other sets have them, much older and younger, stored in same place) is that I kept them
in the original package from the mint, a USPS priority mail "paperboard" package. The earlier ones I took out of the boxes,
and the newer ones ship in cardboard.
But my point is I can't imagine selling these to someone without a full disclosure and at a reduced price. PR69DCAM or not, they
aren't what I want, and they arent what I sell. Period. Why risk people not completely happy with you for a few bucks?
Lurking with intent to loom
Plus, I have a much easier time re-selling certified coins than I do re-selling raw coins.
Numonebuyer
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
I believe there are many dealers/sellers that count on people being too lazy to return a coin they are disappointed with. This is especially true when the coin isn't terribly expensive.
I purchased two "PQ" 1937-D certified MS66 Buffalo's that were less than eye catching (haze, faint fingerprint), but after having to pay $6 shipping for each purchase, sending them back (another couple of bucks) just wasn't cost effective.
Keep harassing those sellers every chance you get.
I do bid when I see something that I really need and if I really need it I'll bid to win, bargains be damned. Problem I have is that I'm too particular and most of the sellers aren't. I have come to grips with that fact and no longer spend the time there that I used to.
This is not meant to be a blanket statement about every seller, particularly the fine members here.
Besides, Warren Mills has been keeping me pretty busy as of late with some real beauts that have satisfied my cravings. For now at least!
I've been burned too many times by whizzed au coins, cleaned coins, etc.
<< <i>Don,
I feel your pain. When I was building my proof Kennedy set, there were days when I returned every coin that came in for problems that somehow slipped the seller's mind when they were listing the coin. Usually peripheral haze. I still have three that I need to replace that I got stuck with buying them from sellers with no return policy.
Russ, NCNE >>
<< <i>. I guess they got tired of all the people who think an auction is an approval service. >>
<< <i>Russ, NCNE >>
From this thread about restocking fees.
catid=26&threadid=194788&highlight_key=y&keyword1=restocking">Restocking Fees
So.......which is it?
You can't think many advertisers deliver raw coins that make the grade? An "expert collector" would
already know that. There is good reason PCGS makes money. Most any coin of reasonalble value
will be in a slab. Coins with big spreads between grades that are raw are probably sucker coins.
Oh wait..........maybe there are dealers out there who really do sell coins below maket value???????????
They must be really big dealers who make it up in volume? Find a real dealer and quit fishing.
You will be glad in the end.
Rusty
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
<< <i> To be honest, when I bid on those coins it was with larceny in mind.
How many oysters does one usually have to go through to find a pearl? (and i'm talking about real oysters with real pearls.) Surely it's a fairly high ratio, or else pearls wouldn't be so expensive. At least you don't have to "don" a loincloth and dive for these coins, you tell the person where to send them and -poof- there they be... until you send them back, of course.
Ironically, on a more serious note, a funny thing I've found is that I tend to return more expensive items, as i am expecting a whole lot more from a thousand dollar coin than I am from a $50 one.
hopefully the high relief will turn out a pearl....
z
To the contrary, I have found a lot of peals, but always in person. From 30 years experience, the secret became obvious,
find an honest dealer and do your business with them. I know they are rare, but there are a few who just want an
honest deal for both. Concentrate on quality. That even means in VG, make sure the coin has no problems at all. Nice no
problem circ coins are just as easy to sell as any 65. We still find the majority of collectors want to put the coin in a book.
Best of luck to you.
Rusty