First Grades in from PCGS on my Indians
tjkillian
Posts: 5,578 ✭✭✭
The first batch of my indians have come back from PCGS, posted anyway.
PCGS Grade My Grade
1 21256759 1898 1C MS63BN MS-63BN
2 21256760 1869 1C AU55BN VF-35
3 21256761 1888 1C AU58BN MS-63BN
4 21256762 1885 1C AU55BN MS-64BN
5 21256763 1874 1C AU55BN MS-63BN
6 21256764 1862 1C MS63 MS-62
7 21256765 1875 1C MS65BN MS-65BN Formerly IGC MS-65BN Bought from Rick Snow, 1st try DNC
8 21256766 1867 1C AU58BN MS-63BN Formerly NGC MS-63BN
9 21256767 1865 1C MS63BN Plain 5 MS-63BN Formerly PCI MS-60
10 21256768 1864 1C MS63RB L on Ribbon MS-64RB Formerly NGC MS-64RB
11 21256769 1864 1C MS63RB Bronze MS-64BN Formerly NGC MS-64BN
12 21256770 1909-S 1C MS63BN Indian MS-63BN Raw
13 21256771 1900 1C MS65RB MS-65RB Bought as AU-55
14 21256772 1891 1C MS63BN MS-63RB Formerly PCGS MS-63RB
15 21256773 1895 1C MS64BN MS-64BN
16 21256774 1893 1C Artificial Color MS-63RED
17 21256775 1884 1C MS64BN MS-64BN
18 21256776 1871 1C AU55BN AU-50
19 21256777 1866 1C AU55BN AU-50
All coins were seen by Mark Feld (Coinguy1) (Thanks Mark!!) for bodybagging only. He thought they'd all get slabbed.
I guess I need to continue to work on my grading. At least very few bodybags. This is my first modern (20th century) submission.
Tom
PCGS Grade My Grade
1 21256759 1898 1C MS63BN MS-63BN
2 21256760 1869 1C AU55BN VF-35
3 21256761 1888 1C AU58BN MS-63BN
4 21256762 1885 1C AU55BN MS-64BN
5 21256763 1874 1C AU55BN MS-63BN
6 21256764 1862 1C MS63 MS-62
7 21256765 1875 1C MS65BN MS-65BN Formerly IGC MS-65BN Bought from Rick Snow, 1st try DNC
8 21256766 1867 1C AU58BN MS-63BN Formerly NGC MS-63BN
9 21256767 1865 1C MS63BN Plain 5 MS-63BN Formerly PCI MS-60
10 21256768 1864 1C MS63RB L on Ribbon MS-64RB Formerly NGC MS-64RB
11 21256769 1864 1C MS63RB Bronze MS-64BN Formerly NGC MS-64BN
12 21256770 1909-S 1C MS63BN Indian MS-63BN Raw
13 21256771 1900 1C MS65RB MS-65RB Bought as AU-55
14 21256772 1891 1C MS63BN MS-63RB Formerly PCGS MS-63RB
15 21256773 1895 1C MS64BN MS-64BN
16 21256774 1893 1C Artificial Color MS-63RED
17 21256775 1884 1C MS64BN MS-64BN
18 21256776 1871 1C AU55BN AU-50
19 21256777 1866 1C AU55BN AU-50
All coins were seen by Mark Feld (Coinguy1) (Thanks Mark!!) for bodybagging only. He thought they'd all get slabbed.
I guess I need to continue to work on my grading. At least very few bodybags. This is my first modern (20th century) submission.
Tom
Tom
0
Comments
<< <i>13 21256771 1900 1C MS65RB MS-65RB Bought as AU-55 >>
Gotta like that one! Good eye. How was the turnaround time on the order?
Russ, NCNE
Pennies make dollars, and dollars make slabs!
....inflation must be kicking in again this dollar says spend by Dec. 31 2004!
Erik
Only one BB and you weren't far off from PCGS. Good eye. Dave
I submitted the coins at the Long Beach Show on 2/27/03, they posted it 3/3/03 and shipped 4/29/03
I'm very surprised on the 1869. A high-end VF or low end XF to me.
Tom
NEVER LET HIPPO MOUTH OVERLOAD HUMMINGBIRD BUTT!!!
WORK HARDER!!!!
Millions on WELFARE depend on you!
Pennies make dollars, and dollars make slabs!
....inflation must be kicking in again this dollar says spend by Dec. 31 2004!
Erik
The Ludlow Brilliant Collection (1938-64)
Please don't take this the wrong way but - I was actually hoping at least a few coins would no-grade. My thinking is, that if I screen coins for someone (kicking out the ones I don't think will grade) and all of the submissions end up getting holdered, perhaps I was a bit too strict in my screening and others should have been submitted. Conversely, if too high of a percentage of the submissions gets body-bagged, it means I was too loose in my screening.
I'm not claiming that my method is strictly scientific, but, that is my thinking. Of the ones you showed me that you ended up submitting, I thought roughly 9 out of every 10 coins would/should get slabbed.
President, Racine Numismatic Society 2013-2014; Variety Resource Dimes; See 6/8/12 CDN for my article on Winged Liberty Dimes; Ebay
Nice coins again Tom! Sounds like you wanted to do better on a few of them, but I think you did pretty darn good overall, especially with that MS65 bought as 55 and old PCI-60 now MS63!
Keep us informed when you see the next group posted.
JJacks