@dval2929 There is a harsche presence on the Forum that has infiltrated your thread. Do not be alarmed. Simply speaking its name robs it of all its power. Harsche, I speak your name. Simple as that. The harsche one is now rendered harmless.
Feel free to get creative, if you'd like. A brief incantation such as the following would also suffice:
Harsche, I denounce you. Harsche, I rebuke you. Harsche, I cast you out.
Or you could just say "Go eat a harschepuppy sandwich"; your choice.
If PCGS would sponsor a coin forum event like I envision, offering a few FREE postage-paid grading vouchers to participants of their choosing in addition to the coveted badge recognition, think how happy a development for this forum that would be.
"IkesT and lermish come on down! You're the next participants on The Great Grading Challenge!"
Wouldn't hearing that be music to everyone's ears?
@mr1931S said:
If PCGS would sponsor a coin forum event like I envision, offering a few FREE postage-paid grading vouchers to participants of their choosing in addition to the coveted badge recognition, think how happy a development for this forum that would be.
"IkesT and lermish come on down! You're the next participants on The Great Grading Challenge!"
Wouldn't that be music to everyone's ears?
Music to everyone's ears would be you stopping posting. Silence is golden.
The amount of BS that pours forth from your keyboard with every single post is just staggering.
@lermish: Bad attitude won't fly on The Great Grading Challenge. Getting "bested" by another participant and then proceeding to cop an attitude about it could, and most likely,will, result in no future invites to participate in the challenge. Like contestants are instructed to do on The Price Is Right television gameshow, maintaining a positive, happy demeanor at all times, regardless of what happens, is required of all persons identified as challenge participants. The rules for the challenge aren't many but the happy demeanor at all times rule WILL BE rigorously enforced.
While certain threads have an educational value that may extend to grading or some variety that may or may not be noteworthy, And that value is measured by what is shared whereby those that venture to provide an opinion offer a basis for that opinion. I think it has been established that some opinions are better than others based on experience and knowledge of the coin series at hand. We should make an effort not to turn this into some sort of game show as it that may turn into "The Grade is Wrong" or even worse "The Gong Show".
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
That some opinions are "better than others" is an opinion. The vision of The Great Grading Challenge is for participants, or challengers if you prefer, to focus on the coin and not trying to prove they are smarter than other challengers.
Start with raw coin. Challengers render their opinions about the coin not just blurt out a number between 1 and 70. WHY do you think the coin deserves the grade number that are giving it? A challenger's opinion can be shaped by other opinions and that's okay for the challenge. In fact, that's exactly what happened with me here in this very thread after a few exchanges with mr. Feld. Opinions other than mr. Feld's were also useful to me.
Coin sent to PCGS for grading. Results with images of the piece holdered are published here. Results from professional graders are considered official. The challenge is to be a happy, positive experience.
I hope the OP sends the Cleveland piece in for grading and publishes results here. There is no shame in being wrong or "off the mark". I guessed MS-62. MFeld guessed MS-66. We can't both be right but we can both be wrong.
@mr1931S said:
I hope the OP sends the Cleveland piece in for grading and publishes results here. There is no shame in being wrong or "off the mark". I guessed MS-62. MFeld guessed MS-66. We can't both be right but we can both be wrong.
How generous of you to offer to pay the grading fees!
@mr1931S said:
I hope the OP sends the Cleveland piece in for grading and publishes results here. There is no shame in being wrong or "off the mark". I guessed MS-62. MFeld guessed MS-66. We can't both be right but we can both be wrong.
How generous of you to offer to pay the grading fees!
Well, I don't believe I did offer to pay the grading fees. I was hoping that the host might get involved to the extent of offering FREE grading to the OP for the Cleveland piece.
I envision The Great Grading Challenge as a stimulus to enliven the forum a bit.
I suppose we could pass the hat around for donations. What you think about that? I would be in for $10 but we need about $50 total to cover postage and grading fee.
It's true that grading submissions can now be made without having to buy a club membership, right?
@mr1931S said:
I hope the OP sends the Cleveland piece in for grading and publishes results here. There is no shame in being wrong or "off the mark". I guessed MS-62. MFeld guessed MS-66. We can't both be right but we can both be wrong.
How generous of you to offer to pay the grading fees!
Well, I don't believe I did offer to pay the grading fees. I was hoping that the host might get involved to the extent of offering FREE grading to the OP for the Cleveland piece.
I envision The Great Grading Challenge as a stimulus to enliven the forum a bit.
I suppose we could pass the hat around for donations. What you think about that? I would be in for $10 but we need about $50 total to cover postage and grading fee.
It's true that grading submissions can now be made without having to buy a club membership, right?
How generous of you to use PCGS's money, which you have absolutely no control over!
@mr1931S said:
I hope the OP sends the Cleveland piece in for grading and publishes results here. There is no shame in being wrong or "off the mark". I guessed MS-62. MFeld guessed MS-66. We can't both be right but we can both be wrong.
How generous of you to offer to pay the grading fees!
He should, since he keeps talking about it.
He also originally said the coin looked AU.
And I already corrected him, in that I never guessed MS66 for the grade.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
@mr1931S said:
That some opinions are "better than others" is an opinion.
Wrong. That's a fact, not an opinion. Your opinion is worthless, as you have proved time and again. Therefore, @MFeld 's opinion is infinitely better than yours. QED.
@mr1931S said:
That some opinions are "better than others" is an opinion.
Wrong. That's a fact, not an opinion. Your opinion is worthless, as you have proved time and again. Therefore, @MFeld 's opinion is infinitely better than yours. QED.
Are you in for $10 to help with the grading fee for the Cleveland? Of course, the OP is under no obligation to get his coin professionally graded by our host so I might be wasting your time asking for your $ help if it's not wanted or needed.
@mr1931S said:
I hope the OP sends the Cleveland piece in for grading and publishes results here. There is no shame in being wrong or "off the mark". I guessed MS-62. MFeld guessed MS-66. We can't both be right but we can both be wrong.
My final grade is MS-62
How generous of you to offer to pay the grading fees!
He should, since he keeps talking about it.
He also originally said the coin looked AU.
And I already corrected him, in that I never guessed MS66 for the grade.
Originally I said the piece looked circulated and that it looked like it had dirt from circulating on it. I mean, the Cleveland piece was obviously (to me) struck very flatly that's why I said it looked circulated.
Where's the relief?
Let the record show that my final guess of grade for the Cleveland piece, where I actually use a number, is MS-62.
So what is your guess now, mr Feld? I'm almost 100% positive I saw in a post you made that your guess is MS-66 but that you "could be wrong." Typos happen. So,what would your guess be now, as we speak?
@mr1931S said:
That some opinions are "better than others" is an opinion.
Wrong. That's a fact, not an opinion. Your opinion is worthless, as you have proved time and again. Therefore, @MFeld 's opinion is infinitely better than yours. QED.
Comments
@dval2929 There is a harsche presence on the Forum that has infiltrated your thread. Do not be alarmed. Simply speaking its name robs it of all its power. Harsche, I speak your name. Simple as that. The harsche one is now rendered harmless.
Feel free to get creative, if you'd like. A brief incantation such as the following would also suffice:
Harsche, I denounce you.
Harsche, I rebuke you.
Harsche, I cast you out.
Or you could just say "Go eat a harschepuppy sandwich"; your choice.
If PCGS would sponsor a coin forum event like I envision, offering a few FREE postage-paid grading vouchers to participants of their choosing in addition to the coveted badge recognition, think how happy a development for this forum that would be.
"IkesT and lermish come on down! You're the next participants on The Great Grading Challenge!"
Wouldn't hearing that be music to everyone's ears?
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
Music to everyone's ears would be you stopping posting. Silence is golden.
The amount of BS that pours forth from your keyboard with every single post is just staggering.
chopmarkedtradedollars.com
@lermish: Bad attitude won't fly on The Great Grading Challenge. Getting "bested" by another participant and then proceeding to cop an attitude about it could, and most likely,will, result in no future invites to participate in the challenge. Like contestants are instructed to do on The Price Is Right television gameshow, maintaining a positive, happy demeanor at all times, regardless of what happens, is required of all persons identified as challenge participants. The rules for the challenge aren't many but the happy demeanor at all times rule WILL BE rigorously enforced.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
Mr1931S > Duracell Bunny.
While certain threads have an educational value that may extend to grading or some variety that may or may not be noteworthy, And that value is measured by what is shared whereby those that venture to provide an opinion offer a basis for that opinion. I think it has been established that some opinions are better than others based on experience and knowledge of the coin series at hand. We should make an effort not to turn this into some sort of game show as it that may turn into "The Grade is Wrong" or even worse "The Gong Show".
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
That some opinions are "better than others" is an opinion. The vision of The Great Grading Challenge is for participants, or challengers if you prefer, to focus on the coin and not trying to prove they are smarter than other challengers.
Start with raw coin. Challengers render their opinions about the coin not just blurt out a number between 1 and 70. WHY do you think the coin deserves the grade number that are giving it? A challenger's opinion can be shaped by other opinions and that's okay for the challenge. In fact, that's exactly what happened with me here in this very thread after a few exchanges with mr. Feld. Opinions other than mr. Feld's were also useful to me.
Coin sent to PCGS for grading. Results with images of the piece holdered are published here. Results from professional graders are considered official. The challenge is to be a happy, positive experience.
I hope the OP sends the Cleveland piece in for grading and publishes results here. There is no shame in being wrong or "off the mark". I guessed MS-62. MFeld guessed MS-66. We can't both be right but we can both be wrong.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
How generous of you to offer to pay the grading fees!
Coin Photography
Interesting thread. Congrats to the OP on an amazing purchase. Might be a once in a lifetime find, but who knows?
What is the mark on the lower forehead of Moses Cleveland?
Great score all around. Just curious what such estate sale would cost?
Well, I don't believe I did offer to pay the grading fees. I was hoping that the host might get involved to the extent of offering FREE grading to the OP for the Cleveland piece.
I envision The Great Grading Challenge as a stimulus to enliven the forum a bit.
I suppose we could pass the hat around for donations. What you think about that? I would be in for $10 but we need about $50 total to cover postage and grading fee.
It's true that grading submissions can now be made without having to buy a club membership, right?
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
How generous of you to use PCGS's money, which you have absolutely no control over!
Coin Photography
He should, since he keeps talking about it.
He also originally said the coin looked AU.
And I already corrected him, in that I never guessed MS66 for the grade.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
"Just Wow."
How far off a cliff this thread has followed.
Wrong. That's a fact, not an opinion. Your opinion is worthless, as you have proved time and again. Therefore, @MFeld 's opinion is infinitely better than yours. QED.
chopmarkedtradedollars.com
Are you in for $10 to help with the grading fee for the Cleveland? Of course, the OP is under no obligation to get his coin professionally graded by our host so I might be wasting your time asking for your $ help if it's not wanted or needed.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
Originally I said the piece looked circulated and that it looked like it had dirt from circulating on it. I mean, the Cleveland piece was obviously (to me) struck very flatly that's why I said it looked circulated.
Where's the relief?
Let the record show that my final guess of grade for the Cleveland piece, where I actually use a number, is MS-62.
So what is your guess now, mr Feld? I'm almost 100% positive I saw in a post you made that your guess is MS-66 but that you "could be wrong." Typos happen. So,what would your guess be now, as we speak?
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
chopmarkedtradedollars.com
You guys are out of your minds.
Why do you keep doing this to threads?