Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

Reeding Error, Wear or Ground Down? 2016 Quarter

2»

Comments

  • Options

    Proof will be in the pudding spoon fellers lol. I see what most miss, down to a forensic level. Here's a snippet, metal leaves trace identity, once you by force , stamp metal, it holds the evidence property of that stamping until said metal is melted down and re sheeted. And if one looks just hard enough, and with all light angles , and digital camera, phone cameras for that matter, you can find trace evidence of prior forging. It's a property of metal, so if you say, just heated metal to " re form it" to a blank piece of metal , that had been previously pressed , unless you turn that metal into a flow state, there's trace to self evident evidence of its prior state............

  • Options

    So circulated coins .......look at those coins ........look at them again, a little longer, a little closer, around all of design elements, in the fields as well ........very interesting to say the least

  • Options

    And what denomination had the most minted? The penny you say, what denomination has the most errors. The penny you say.........

  • Options
    jmlanzafjmlanzaf Posts: 43,421 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Terrywhite05 said:
    Wow, really? The answers just get worse lol. No it wasn't a hammer. And the people saying spooned , REALLY , mean with a spoon. Lol That's how ridiculous that answer sounds , just as a hammer. Any of y'all ever worked with metal? There's absolutely zero chance of getting a coin to look like the one in this feed , smacking it with anything by hand. You could spatula, butter knife, tater peeler, or any kitchen utensil it to death and never get a coin to look like the one in this feed. It wasn't sanded or ground to look like that as well. That would leave evidence on the metal guys. Very obvious evidence. The coin is obviously pressed, with lots of pressure. It's the only way to get it round , smooth with crisp edges and no sand or grind lines in it, and for the people who will say they see a flat spot right in the middle, thats a light reflection, and makes that spot look flat kinda, it's not actually flat right there. Look at the coin better. And y'all should really think about your answers before you guys western dual fast spit them out like y'all's lives depend on it. Think through what you're telling people . Because it's incorrect

    No, it's correct. There was even a video provided. You resurrected a 7 year old thread. So, yes, we were much faster on the draw than you were. Guess the 7 years didn't help you get the gun out of the holster.

    All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.

  • Options
    jmlanzafjmlanzaf Posts: 43,421 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @IkesT said:

    @Terrywhite05 said:
    Hey I don't need members to establish me as an authority on anything to do with coins. I've been a coin collector for 33 years and I know what I'm talking about. I've worked with metal for years as well. Not to mention I will have a full length article published in coin world magazine sometime in 2027 of a bombshell theory I have about coins and the minting process that's going to shake up the coin collecting hobby. I'm just a regular Joe off the street so to say and yet I'm getting a full length article with pics published in coin world magazine. Not a snippet, not a comment section, or mention. All of you guys will know who I am and my theory and credibility after it comes out.

    Yes, I'm sure your theory will take the numismatic community by storm, just like all of your other bombshell theories.

    I take it you are not taking his nebulous claims of a Coin World article seriously. I mean, no troll would ever claim authority with absolutely nothing specific to back it up. :wink:

    All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.

  • Options

  • Options

    I'm different, I don't claim things and not have proof to back up what I'm claiming. That's been more core message through this whole interaction on this feed guys. When you seek truth , not agreeance, you find what we're told in life doesn't add up when you look at the evidence without biased beliefs. Biased is hard for people to let go of because they have to come to the fact they've been compromised when assessing something. Look at the evidence guys, not what is told , printed or sold as facts. Find the facts find truth.

  • Options
    MsMorrisineMsMorrisine Posts: 40,333 ✭✭✭✭✭

    ask them about spooning

    Current maintainer of Stone's Master List of Favorite Websites // My BST transactions
  • Options
    jmlanzafjmlanzaf Posts: 43,421 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Terrywhite05 said:
    I'm different, I don't claim things and not have proof to back up what I'm claiming. That's been more core message through this whole interaction on this feed guys. When you seek truth , not agreeance, you find what we're told in life doesn't add up when you look at the evidence without biased beliefs. Biased is hard for people to let go of because they have to come to the fact they've been compromised when assessing something. Look at the evidence guys, not what is told , printed or sold as facts. Find the facts find truth.

    Maybe you should look at the video evidence of spooning...Just saying.

    All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.

  • Options
    CregCreg Posts: 1,782 ✭✭✭✭✭

    You’ll need an editor.

  • Options
    IkesTIkesT Posts: 4,768 ✭✭✭✭✭

    If I were either of the individuals at Coin World and I happened to see Terry here on his little posting spree, I might be having second thoughts right about now...

  • Options
    JBKJBK Posts: 17,974 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @IkesT said:
    If I were either of the individuals at Coin World and I happened to see Terry here on his little posting spree, I might be having second thoughts right about now...

    I'm still not convinced they were really having first thoughts about printing it.

    Paul: "How do you want this used?"

    Jake: "Do you have any images...?"

    Maybe they were just being diplomatic, although Paul was a little more direct. 😆

  • Options

    Post pics soon as y'all spoon or dryer a coin and it looks like the coin in the feed. My article is legit and I have lots of other communication with the guys over at coin world magazine. Remember there is other coins out there like the one in the feed, same year, and it wasn't from the same spooner doing it. And why second thoughts? The fact I don't just blindly accept things as facts and look past industry explanations is why my article is going to be published. You guys should do the same.

  • Options



    _
    Here's what AI says about the coin in this feed . Which is correct. The reason I can't and wouldn't bend to the answers given guys is because if we accept blatant lies, affirm peoples lies, we're in big trouble as a society. No matter if people mock you or try to act as if you're crazy, never go along with them when it's evident something isn't true. Because I feel most of you guys know this coin was not spooned or done from a dryer yet you were ok with going along with the collective wrong narrative.
    _

  • Options
    IkesTIkesT Posts: 4,768 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @JBK said:

    @IkesT said:
    If I were either of the individuals at Coin World and I happened to see Terry here on his little posting spree, I might be having second thoughts right about now...

    I'm still not convinced they were really having first thoughts about printing it.

    Paul: "How do you want this used?"

    Jake: "Do you have any images...?"

    Maybe they were just being diplomatic, although Paul was a little more direct. 😆

    Yeah, that must be it.

  • Options

    Trust me ikesT I won't be the one eating crow pie. You can bet the farm on that.

  • Options
    jmlanzafjmlanzaf Posts: 43,421 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited November 15, 2026 6:05AM

    @Terrywhite05 said:


    _
    Here's what AI says about the coin in this feed . Which is correct. The reason I can't and wouldn't bend to the answers given guys is because if we accept blatant lies, affirm peoples lies, we're in big trouble as a society. No matter if people mock you or try to act as if you're crazy, never go along with them when it's evident something isn't true. Because I feel most of you guys know this coin was not spooned or done from a dryer yet you were ok with going along with the collective wrong narrative.
    _

    1. You're being too literal about the use of a spoon.
    2. I'd like to see the actual prompt.
    3. We all know people that have done this with some tool or other. Most haven't used an actual spoon, that was the origin of the technique by soldiers who didn't have shops.
    4. If this was broad struck, why is the rim higher than normal and eating in to the design near the edge? If it was struck as you suggest, there should be MORE space between the letters and the edge. There would not be letters cut off by the edge.
    5. Do you buy "mint errors"? I'm going to have a bunch of these to sell you.

    All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.

  • Options
    CregCreg Posts: 1,782 ✭✭✭✭✭

    We haven’t seen full views of the OP’s coin yet.

  • Options

    Seriously? If you've read this feed , you'd know that I am not being too literal. It's truly amazing how people will even try to give an out to the wrong position. Well " we didn't mean a literal spoon" yes, yes they did ! That's the whole point here guys!!!!!! Cmon! Lol like wow. The whole point here in this debate , is that coin " experts " and long time numismatists are saying, A LITERAL SPOON, made the coin in this feed. Which is utterly ridiculous. So there's no back peddling here guy. No giving a ," well it's not literal" out. Because yes this is the literal answer and belief along with a dryer made coin to boot. You guys have got to have more integrity and quit trying to pat each other on the back and saying , ok it's your turn to try and sell this position and get the win. Just wow man.

  • Options

    And speaking of integrity, im waiting to see if any of the people in this feed, some who have actually tried spooning a coin here very recently, because my gut says there has been, because I know I have, and step up and say hey, I tried to spoon a quarter because I wanted to prove this guy wrong, but to be honest, he's right, I could spoon a quarter to look anything like the coin in this feed. So that would be integrity. And if someone does that. My hats off to you and mad respect which you'd deserve.

  • Options

    Couldn't *

  • Options
    JBKJBK Posts: 17,974 ✭✭✭✭✭

    People (including me) have clearly stated that these terms are not literal. "Spooning" does not have to literally involve a spoon. There are better tools that could be used in the modern era.

    I originally thought you were arguing that these coins were made outside of the mint by a different method, but it seems that you are claiming they are mint errors.

    Unbelievable.

  • Options
    JBKJBK Posts: 17,974 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Terrywhite05 said:
    Couldn't *

    I would think a genius of your caliber would know how just edit their post if they needed to make a correction.

  • Options
    ldhairldhair Posts: 7,471 ✭✭✭✭✭

    The OPs last post was back in January. We may not be seeing anymore images. It would have been nice to see both faces of the coin but it's clear that the coin is just damaged. The exact cause of the damage is really not important. Calling it spooned is just fine.

    Larry

  • Options
    MasonGMasonG Posts: 7,794 ✭✭✭✭✭

    "Reeding Error, Wear or Ground Down?"

  • Options

    Hey JBK, you might of been asleep through this course. You probably missed the video, you know the one that was being touted as evidence of LITERAL SPOONING ...ONE MORE TIME FOR THE PEOPLE WAY IN THE BACK, LITERAL SPOONING/ TAPPING, ...along with navy folks , and dads who tap during TV time, as REAL , ...REAL, .... accounts of people spooning coins that come out like the coin in the feed. Let me be fair and also throw in the other but not less important option of dryer coins. Which seems to of been abandoned all together from anyone defending the ole classic "DIY dryer coin." So you probably won't do so well on the quiz ....seeing how you missed all the people defending spooning with all their spoon testimonies. And I've even said. None of you guys could reproduce the coin, with ALL available options to you as well. So I stepped outside of the two methods purposed by everyone , tapping and drying, and said y'all can't do it period . I'll wait.........

  • Options

    The pics of the coin are there in this feed and speak for themselves. What's funny is spooning and dryer have been the supposed reasons for the coins state. No one has given alternative reasons. It's "PMD" ......then crickets. If you experts know for such a fact it's PMD,then give ONE, I mean ONE, plausible scenario that could of produced the coin. No one can or will. I mean look at the ridiculous answers given. When other people in the beginning said hey my wife has one just like it, same year, and another person said me too, and another person , dcarr , said it looks way to smooth to of been tapped, no one gave anything else as a reason. It's only been stated tapped and dryer. Which if that's the best answers they can come up with, it's no wonder there's not been any other specific causes for the coins state. Because anything after those two causes as reasons would be even worse to hear I'm sure lol. "Because I said so," which is what the answer of PMD is, as an answer is just what that says, when you give nothing to back up the claim of PMD. UHHH idk it just is. Ya because we said it's PMD, ya we need nothing to say as reason for that answer. Take spoon and dry or just PMD as the official cause. That's all that's been stated. All of which are untrue and seriously lacking in any credibility or common sense. And just saying PMD, does not give anyone a PHD in their opinion which they give no following reason for stating.......

  • Options
    CregCreg Posts: 1,782 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited November 15, 2026 9:37AM

    I tapped out a clad quarter ring when I worked on a shrimp boat. The boats in the fleet stayed out ten to fourteen days at a time. One season, spooning quarters was a trend, I saw friends tapping coins at the docks, so I did it—with a tablespoon, just as they were using. I tapped it to a thickness of about a quarter inch—it took three trips. I never drilled it. Grinding, sanding, polishing and buffing would have looked like that.

    Stop wasting cred on a damaged quarter. Save the remainder to announce the publication.

  • Options

    Credibility is proven through the position of truth and sticking by it. That's why I've even continued to defend what I'm saying. Because who can have credibility if they don't hold firm when pressed or tested to see if they can earn that cred through situations or fold to peer opposition. That's why people just go along with crud , because they dont hold firm. But yes I sure will announce the article , because being credible is important.

  • Options
    JBKJBK Posts: 17,974 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited November 16, 2026 9:50AM

    @Terrywhite05 said:
    Credibility is proven through the position of truth and sticking by it. That's why I've even continued to defend what I'm saying. Because who can have credibility if they don't hold firm when pressed or tested to see if they can earn that cred through situations or fold to peer opposition. That's why people just go along with crud , because they dont hold firm. But yes I sure will announce the article , because being credible is important.

    And you have yet to prove how this anomaly could have possibly occurred during the minting process. (Hint: you can't, because it didn't.)

  • Options

    My position has been that it wasn't spooned or a dryer coin. That what you see in that coin has to be manufactured. The distinct clear separation of the metals, the smooth surface of the side, and crisp edges. So what I've said and claimed is true. The coin had to be pressed , to create what we see in the pic. Thats where the evidence leads. The evidence points to manuf

  • Options
    LiquidatedLiquidated Posts: 433 ✭✭✭✭
    edited November 15, 2026 1:47PM

    @Terrywhite05 said:
    Do you have any idea what the edge of a quarter would look like if you spoon it death trying to make it smooth? It wouldn't be smooth nor have crisp edges.

    @Terrywhite05 said: Wow..................................this mic on?.............did everybody hear that?............this mic cant be on...........

    Lost credibility and people moved on. Spooning coins is not anything new and most people have seen them.

  • Options
    dcarrdcarr Posts: 10,354 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Terrywhite05 said:
    Dcarr, stick to what your gut and common sense tell you my friend. You were right on spot to start , then kinda back slid. You're absolutely correct, the edge is too perfectly smooth to have been tapped or spooned. That's a ridiculous answer that these supposed coin experts have been giving out as gospel. Especially Fred Weinberg. You have a laundry list of credentials proudly displayed yet you confidently give that as an answer? That blows my mind sir. It shows how people just repeat any standard narrative response in life without ever even putting in any effort to critically think or physically testing what they say as truth. I challenge every person in this feed to replicate a quarter by " spooning" or " drying" it that said those as answers so confidently and snarky about it. Because not one of you can or will. Y'all won't even be able to replicate the coin with all available options out there to you. Period. You know why? Because none of y'all can machine press a coin in the manner that it takes to make said coin in this feed. And that's why multiple of them have surfaced. Y'all really think there's these magic spooners out there that can somehow tap a quarters edge to perfection smooth by hand? Bahahahaha. I have some ocean front property in Arizona I've got for sale if so .

    .

    I run my own private mint.
    You ?

    I could take an ordinary coin and make it look exactly like yours in less than a minute.

    .

  • Options
    MsMorrisineMsMorrisine Posts: 40,333 ✭✭✭✭✭

    spooning

    i suppose a ball peen hammer would b a better choice but they are so heavy to wield

    Current maintainer of Stone's Master List of Favorite Websites // My BST transactions
  • Options

    If anyone in this feed has spooned a coin that would come out like the one in this feed, do it again, send us all some pics, debates over then right? And hammered huh? Whew , you think that's possible huh? 😂 What's the reason for spooning, tapping, hammering? It's to smooth a REEDED, edge of the quarter, correct? That would be a yes class, ok, and has the class seen the side of a reeded quarter? Oh you have , ok good. And go ahead , raise your hands and let's describe the edge of the reeded coin......now class take out your spoons, hammers, peelers and smackers, got em? Good, now see this picture of this coin? See how the clad and copper layers are razor clean in their separation layers? Ok good, now y'all smack and whack away on your quarters and I want you guys to make your quarters look just like the one in the pic. And............Go! ................ I'll cut straight to to final grades here class. All Fs, because it's not possible to hand smack a coin while keeping the metal from smearing into each other. Nor will your edges be crisp and level. Because by hand its not machine caliber and will hit off the mark and dent up the edges nullifying perfectly crisp edges. Or surface. And the day someone can produce a manufacturing quality coin by hand , pigs will surely fly .

  • Options
    LiquidatedLiquidated Posts: 433 ✭✭✭✭

    @Terrywhite05 said:
    If anyone in this feed has spooned a coin that would come out like the one in this feed, do it again, send us all some pics, debates over then right? And hammered huh? Whew , you think that's possible huh? 😂 What's the reason for spooning, tapping, hammering? It's to smooth a REEDED, edge of the quarter, correct? That would be a yes class, ok, and has the class seen the side of a reeded quarter? Oh you have , ok good. And go ahead , raise your hands and let's describe the edge of the reeded coin......now class take out your spoons, hammers, peelers and smackers, got em? Good, now see this picture of this coin? See how the clad and copper layers are razor clean in their separation layers? Ok good, now y'all smack and whack away on your quarters and I want you guys to make your quarters look just like the one in the pic. And............Go! ................ I'll cut straight to to final grades here class. All Fs, because it's not possible to hand smack a coin while keeping the metal from smearing into each other. Nor will your edges be crisp and level. Because by hand its not machine caliber and will hit off the mark and dent up the edges nullifying perfectly crisp edges. Or surface. And the day someone can produce a manufacturing quality coin by hand , pigs will surely fly .

    @Terrywhite05
    It is unfortunate that you fail to realize something so basic. There is a person on forum. NJCoin. The two of you would enjoy each other.

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file