Options
Lucky Estate Sale Find
I purchased 3 commems in a pamphlet along with 2 raw Morgans at an estate sale. I knew the Morgans were key/semi-key dates, though there was a good chance they were inauthentic or harshly cleaned.
I sent the two Atietams along with the two Morgans to PCGS.
Well, I just got the grades back today and I am blown away!!!
I consider this beginner’s luck and do not expect to get this fortunate in the future.



33
Comments
!
Nice score!
Gary TheGasMan - Retired Hank Hill
Cool
Those Antietams are beautifully original. Very nice score.
Congratulations.
You said “I purchased 3 commems in a pamphlet..” and that you submitted the two Antietam’s. What was the third commem and why didn’t you submit it?
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Congrats love those! Were these the only coins??? Were there others?
Oh - YOU SUCK! big time brother. Heck just the 95 S is a heck of a score.
WS
Super Mega score depending on what he paid for them.
DPOTD-3
'Emancipate yourselves from mental slavery'
CU #3245 B.N.A. #428
Don
Lovely Antietam! Not to be crass but if you decided to sell. Let me know! Their appearance is very much what I like!
The third coin in the pamphlet was a Cleveland. I didn’t submit it because when I looked up the values it was ~$100 in about every grade below 67, and I never dreamed any of the coins would grade 67. But looking at it now, it also seems it doesn’t ‘belong’ in the pamphlet, so somehow it got added. 🤔
Any advice on this would be helpful, thanks!
’
Wow! TWO MS67s at an estate sale? You SUCK!!!
Coingrats!!!
Here are your TrueViews:
Originally, there would have been five Antietam’s in the tabbed holder.
The reverse of the Cleveland looks nice. Can you show us what the obverse looks like?
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Is it worth grading? Thanks
Looks like a nice unc, but for the Cleveland I'd say probably not worth it. If you hit a 67 again, SURE, but odds seem fairly stacked against that...
My guess is no, as I don’t see it grading higher than 66. But I’ve been wrong plenty of times before. Let’s see if we can get some other opinions.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
From the pictures, I wouldn't bother with the Cleveland. I don't see the eye appeal of a 67. The slightly flasher area in front of Cleaveland's mouth has me wanting to take a closer look for an old wipe mark, too.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
Nice score and great grades on those Antietams!
That toning doesn’t appeal to me, but some find it attractive.
Don’t think the Cleveland would grade higher than a 65-66.
The Cleveland is attractive but just does not have the look to grade at the 67 level. I am not certain it gets to 66 without seeing in hand. But coins are not about numbers on slabs and should be enjoyed for what they are and are not. The Cleveland has an original look that others may not share.
The 1895-S Morgan is attractive for the same reason. I suspect you could easily get $1100-1200 for this one.
Congrats
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
Looks like dirt on it from circulating to me. I don't see how this piece deserves an MS grade so I'm thinkin' you be wrong on this one.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
But it's already well established that you are a terrible grader, have no idea what you're talking about, and you constantly spout off with the certainty of the ignorant.
So, I don't think anyone cares what you think because your numismatic thoughts are bereft of any redeeming qualities.
Nice coins and results OP! I make the Cleveland a 65.
chopmarkedtradedollars.com
There you go with that unbecoming projection of yourself again. Tough nut to crack, as I've said before, but it can be done.
I was speaking with mr. Feld, not you lermish. Do you do his talking for him on Sundays?
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
Those Antietam's are LOVELY! Congratulation!
Coin Photography
I posted that I don’t think the coin would grade higher than 66. So if, like you think, it’s been circulated (meaning it should grade considerably lower than 66) how was I wrong?
That aside, (putting it nicely) it appears that you have a difficult time grading toned coins. You recently graded a gem Barber dime AU and now, you’ve graded the Cleveland half dollar circulated. Did you happen to notice that everyone else who assessed it thought far better of it than you did? If you look at the pictures of the Cleveland and compare them to the Antietam’s before they were graded, you should see that all three coins look like they have dirt on them. It’s toning, not dirt from circulation.
I suspect that the Cleveland is tab-toned, as the Antietam’s were, though not attractively so, as they are.
No need to reply, but if you do, don’t hold your breath waiting on another reply from me.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
No breath-holding going on here.Those Cleveland coins certainly don't get any awards from me as among the best examples of the minter's art. Flatly struck, no details in the bust to write home about. Aren't there fully struck examples of this design out there? Far as I'm concerned a choice (or gem) coin should be fully struck. There are a few exceptions to this rule but not many.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
You got some great deals and I'm shocked the Morgans graded so well. I was at a pawn shop yesterday that had bought an "1894" and an "1895" Morgan and I had to inform them they were not real. Sure enough they ran them through the silver machine and confirmed it.
Dirt from circulation? Are you joking, or just attention seeking? If neither, then I think there is no one who could benefit more from an in-person ANA grading course than yourself.
I think it L@@KS like it has dirt on it from circulating. I wish people would read what I write more carefully. As for ANA grading course, what do they do throw away the book when it comes to teaching folks how to grade Clevelands?
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
Everyone's unique in their own way.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
I think people read what you wrote carefully enough. In addition to saying “ Looks like dirt on it from circulating to me.”, you wrote “ I don't see how this piece deserves an MS grade…”
You’re placing too much grading emphasis on strike and could benefit from taking a coin grading class (if you’d listen to the instructors).
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
I got out my "Official A.N.A. Grading Standards for United States Coins." Pages 363-367 covers "First Points of Wear" for the various commemorative coins:
*General Note: Issues marked with an asterisk should be carefully examined as they are often found with signs of handling or abrasion.
There is no asterisk seen for the "CLEVELAND" issue in my fifth edition guidebook.
CLEVELAND
Obverse: Hair behind Cleaveland's ear.
Reverse: Top of compass.
I don't understand how the toned
Cleveland commemorative pictured here can be graded accurately with any precision whatsoever using the images provided, especially with such scant information as seen in the official A.N.A. guide.
Where's the luster that an issue like this in mint state condition should have? I'm not seeing even a hint of original mint luster peeking through.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
Finally, some nuggets of insight in one of your posts.
That is correct, you don't understand.
Also correct. We have empirical and anecdotal evidence that you don't understand how to grade nor how to interpret images. Remember the PCGS/CAC 65 Barber from two weeks ago that you thought was a 55?
Every single time you are wrong. EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. Maybe stop writing like you have any knowledge or expertise and your experience will be a lot better. You might even learn something. I doubt it but anything is possible.
chopmarkedtradedollars.com
Why is your user profile private?
"My guess is no, as I don’t see it grading higher than 66. But I’ve been wrong plenty of times before. Let’s see if we can get some other opinions."
My advise here is if you don't want to hear opinions that you can't always give your nod of approval to don't call for them.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
A> @mr1931S said:
All opinions are welcome and many of them are informed ones.
As @DisneyFan asked, why is your user profile private?
Edited to add: If you’re going to give advice, dont say it’s advise.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
And then, there are the others...
Congrtats
Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value. Zero. Voltaire. Ebay coinbowlllc
Not private. Where are you getting that my profile is private? I don't even have the option to make my user profile private even if I wanted to.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
@mr1931S
I like your simplicity of thought and expression.
You have never been known to use a word that might send a reader to the dictionary.
Edited to add: If you’re going to give advice, dont say it’s advise.
Advise is the better word to use, in my opinion. I'm taking action by using "advise". Advice is the wrong word. You are being advised by me. Do you say ever say you "adviced" another?
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
^^This has got to be the funniest post I've read here today.^^
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
Based on what I'm seeing in my official A.N.A. grading guide 5th edition and in light of member remarks about this piece's "mint-stateness", I can go MS-62 as my opinion of the Cleveland's number grade. It's not a terrible looking coin by any means. I would even consider buying it as an MS-62 for my third party graded MS-62 collection.
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel
You could give a politician lessons in how to dig in, ignore the actual point, and stubbornly insist you're right when you're so clearly, demonstrably, and ridiculously wrong. Your opinion is absurdly misguided. And, as you continue to demonstrate with every post, @mr1931s is always wrong about everything.
@dval2929 - I'm really sorry your excellent thread got derailed by this nonsense.
chopmarkedtradedollars.com
You’re clearly very confused.
No, I don’t say I “adviced” another because advice is a noun (and “advised” is a verb).
So when you wrote “My advise here is…” is dead wrong.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
And this was a great thread...
I agree. And I apologize for my role in trying to reason with a certain poster, which led to additional replies from him. My communications with that person have now ended.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Looks like that particular Cleveland was born a bit ugly id call it a 64
Great estate finds! Re: Cleveland: MS 64-65 - Toning not as attractive as the Antietam coins, nick on the compass on the reverse. Maybe a light scratch on the back of the hair in the obverse?
Man what a score! When I grow up someday I’d like to score like that. 😬😂
I'm BACK!!! Used to be Billet7 on the old forum.
Glad you fixed that.
I made a typo and then decided to check your knowledge of grammar. Test concluded. You earn an "A" from me on grammar knowledge, mr. Feld.
My final opinion of the Cleveland's grade is MS-62. Your guess, another opinion, is MS-66. Would be very interesting if the owner sent this piece to our host for grading/encapsulation and then published the results, which would be considered official, here.
My vision is to launch "The Great Grading Challenge." This could be the pilot episode. The grading challenges would be akin to the food challenges one sees on the Food Channel only here it's one amateur grader pitted against another. It could be a lot of fun in addition to being instructional. The contestants change so it's not like everyone would be bored to tears with the same two contestants for every challenge. A badge could be awarded by our host for contestants who participate in TGGC. The spirit to be maintained is to have fun and learn not "L@@K, I'm a better grader than so-and-so and here's the evidence."
The inspiration for my idea of a grading challenge here comes from observations I've made by watching episodes of the long-running TV gameshow "The Price Is Right."
”Isn't learning fun?"
The Learning Channel