Should We Add War Nickels and Silver-Clad Kennedy Halves to this Set?
Charles_Morgan
Posts: 79 ✭✭✭
Hello everyone,
I wanted to open this question up to the forum. We frequently receive emails from collectors asking why our Silver Type Set, Circulation Strikes (1792–1964) does not include the silver-alloy Jefferson Nickels of 1942–1945. It's a great question. It also raises another good point: does the 1964 cutoff, marking the end of the era of circulating .900 fine coinage, fail to account for the silver-clad Kennedy Halves of 1965–1970?
I suppose you could also argue for including the silver-clad Eisenhower Dollars through the Bicentennial Set, but those issues were struck as NCLT and aren't really germane to our question.
I believe including one means including the other, but I'd like to take the pulse of the community. Should we change the set's composition to add one, both, or neither?
I'll leave this thread open through the end of November and use your feedback to make a final determination.
Manager of Numismatic Research and Programs | PCGS
Comments
I think the silver Jefferson "silvers" should be included.
I don't agree that including one means including the other simply because the set is defined as 1792-1964.
The date of production parameters are defined in the title of the set. If the set will continue to be 1792-1964 then I have no idea why silver Jefferson war nickles were originally excluded and. if they were, then they should be included. If you believe that 40% JFK half dollars should be included then change the title to 1792-1970 and act accordingly.
As an aside, one could argue for the inclusion of Columbian Exposition half dollars as they were dumped in massive numbers into circulation at face value after they were used as collateral for bank loans by the exposition. Obviously, I could see how these could continue to be excluded, but they were released for circulation at face value as well.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
If we add the 40% Kennedy halves, we would also change the date range to 1970.
Manager of Numismatic Research and Programs | PCGS
Why change when/while it's working? Like customer service phones, not recognize the top sets and provide an actual award? NO, not just 60 coins sets, make sure that the True View photos are exactly like the coin really looks like. If you change these 2 items, what's next?
I think the word silver in the name "Silver type set" is more of a generic description of the "mid range" denomination types, 10c to $1 in the early-mid 20th century (and 3c,5c early-mid 19th century), that were primarily composed of silver. I do not take the name to literally mean coins that have silver in it. I would think of the silver war nickels and 40% halves as one-offs, not too different than the one year 1943 steel cents. To me they make more sense to go in a nickels type set for the nickels, and the 1965-date type set for the halves. Would you actually ever remove them from those type sets? I doubt it. So should they have 2 homes? That doesn't make much sense either. Are you going to add all the regular issue silver types to the copper type set too since they have copper in their alloy?
I’m ok if you add all, or neither.
My collecting “Pride & Joy” is my PCGS Registry Dansco 7070 Set! Winner of the 2026 PCGS Registry Award for “The Best U.S. Type Set”!
https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/type-sets/design-type-sets/complete-dansco-7070-modified-type-set-1796-date/publishedset/213996
I think the proposal makes sense. One could get technical and claim that 1970 is not included since that was a mint set only year.
Also what is this layout for halves in the price guide?
https://www.pcgs.com/prices/detail/kennedy-half-dollar/125/most-active
Type 3 (1971-2025)
Type 1 (1964)
Type 2 (1965-70)
Type 4 (1976)
Type 5 (2014)
Why are the types not in order? You have to go all the way to the end of clad to get to the 1964-70 years. It makes no sense.
Collector, occasional seller
The set is from 1792-1964 leave it at that.
You CAN include the war Jefferson nickels and ONLY the 1964 Kennedy half
Mike
My Indians
Dansco Set
If you are keeping the set ending at 1964, perhaps it might be pertinent to add "90%" to the front of the set title. New title would be: 90% Silver Type Set, Circulation Strikes (1792–1964).
If adding 40% halves, wouldn't the set end at 1969?
collecting O-Pee-Chee (OPC) baseball cards
full-time poster on the Trading Cards forum, part-time lurker on the U.S. Coin Forum
If you add 90% silver composition only you would have to remove type 1 trimes as they are only 75% silver
Overland Trail Collection Showcase
Dahlonega Type Set-2008 PCGS Best Exhibited Set
Good point, never knew that the 1851-1853 trime was 75%. Thank you.
collecting O-Pee-Chee (OPC) baseball cards
full-time poster on the Trading Cards forum, part-time lurker on the U.S. Coin Forum