Options
Counterfeit trade dollar - what about the holder?
IkesT
Posts: 4,768 ✭✭✭✭✭
Note the tooled feathers on the eagle's leg.





0
Comments
Why do you believe it is counterfeit. I am no Trade Dollar expert, we have many here, hopefully one will jump in. But it appears to me a nice one.
A nice counterfeit, you mean?
IMO it looks like a nice genuine trade dollar.
Apparently, you do not know counterfeits, nor do you know trade dollars. Also, you ignored or did not understand my comment about the tooled feathers. Need I go on?
There are some clear printing issues on these particular ICG labels. That would certainly be a red flag for PCGS labels, but I'm not all that familiar with ICG and what the base line is for their printing quality.
Does anyone happen to know if the white ICG labels shown here are a style legitimately used by ICG, and if so, is this particular example legit? The coin is currently listed on eBay, and it would be nice to inform the seller about both the coin and the holder.
Agreed, it does. Rather it did until you more than offer a simple glance.
I also concur it appears to be a well struck counterfeit as far as counterfeits go.
Agreed that it looks off. Weird stuff (casting remnants?) on left obverse denticles. On my phone and without reference material but I would strongly lean fake as well.
chopmarkedtradedollars.com
And could just be an artifact off the photo too. If that is the only questionable things on this piece which if it were fake there would be loads of other pick up points, at least with other series there are.
Since I don't now trade dollars - is this a documented Counterfeit ??
WS
An ICG label with attractive, crisp, legible printing would be a red flag for me. Their print quality problems have been chronic.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
Good question. If anyone else has seen one, it would be interesting to hear about. Keep in mind that the tooled-feather reverse might appear with other dates.
That is helpful to know; thank you.
Looks like it is trying to have a type 2M reverse, but does not look right. Here is a 76P 2M from my set.

Kaz, that is a looker, do you have an obv shot?
IkesT: Is host coin tooled or the die that impressed/struck it?
I'm thinking it would be the die but don't want to jump to the wrong conclusion.
Yes, it is the die that appears to be tooled. That's why it may be useful to be on the lookout for counterfeit trade dollars of other dates that may have been struck by the same tooled reverse die.
Here you are.

The certification number is correct. FWIW
All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.
Calling Keoj
If you wanna get him on the line you gotta insert the @ symbol...
It may be that the ICG holder itself is genuine; it doesn't appear to have raised any red flags with anyone so far.
I know we have a couple of members here who 'represent' ANACS and NGC. Is there anyone here that could answer for ICG? (I think @Insider @Insider2 @Insider3 worked with PCI, did he also work with ICG?
He does work for ICG, but is banned here.
Calling @Insider4 !