@coinbuf said:
Silent net grade for the graffiti on the cheek.
I can’t get a clear look at the marks on the cheek and jaw - what makes you say it’s graffiti, rather than unintentional contact marks.
Look at the seller images that were posted above by @PocketChange you can clearly see this mark in that obv image. This does not appear in the image as three distinct marks but rather one continuous mark. It may in fact be a strike through, but it is the only thing I can see that would hold the grade to 64 vs 65 or better if it was considered as graffiti back when this was graded.
Thanks, I hadn’t seen that. I can’t tell for certain what caused it. But that, along with other flaws on the cheek, nose and jaw, certainly explains the 64 grade.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Wow thats alot of money.
I think the problem this coin might have is that it could grade MS63. You never know. The images are lousy. The fields look super clean but are they for sure?
I cant tell if its PL or not but I think its a longshot.
What if its got a wheel mark?
Student of numismatics and collector of Morgan dollars
Successful BST transactions with: Namvet Justindan Mattniss RWW olah_in_MA
Dantheman984 Toyz4geo SurfinxHI greencopper RWW bigjpst bretsan MWallace logger7 JWP BruceS bigjpst
JWP PROMETHIUS88
@Morgan13 said:
Wow thats alot of money.
I think the problem this coin might have is that it could grade MS63. You never know. The images are lousy. The fields look super clean but are they for sure?
I cant tell if its PL or not but I think its a longshot.
What if its got a wheel mark?
The OP said he doesn’t want to have the coin removed from the holder, so it can’t grade 63.
And if it had a wheel mark, it’s likely that it would have been noticed by PCGS.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Looks like a 64 to me. I’ve seen numerous 1936 Buffs with outstanding luster. A 64 CAC green coin is worth about $80 on GC now. It’s your money but no way is it a gold bean candidate imho.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
@coinbuf said:
Silent net grade for the graffiti on the cheek.
I can’t get a clear look at the marks on the cheek and jaw - what makes you say it’s graffiti, rather than unintentional contact marks.
Look at the seller images that were posted above by @PocketChange you can clearly see this mark in that obv image. This does not appear in the image as three distinct marks but rather one continuous mark. It may in fact be a strike through, but it is the only thing I can see that would hold the grade to 64 vs 65 or better if it was considered as graffiti back when this was graded.
Thanks, I hadn’t seen that. I can’t tell for certain what caused it. But that, along with other flaws on the cheek, nose and jaw, certainly explains the 64 grade.
I am going to review the coin for the contact marks you mentioned. But the flashy brightness of the PL luster helps conceal them somewhat
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
Pretty late to comment just since I’ve been on a different device, but that Buffalo is stunning!
This gave me the idea to finally purchase another Buffalo, so…thanks for that!!
"Another day, another Collectors Universe forum scrolling session."
- Someone, probably
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Noise on cheek and nose and in the hair make 64 seem about right. Nice luster but that is common on a 1936. Look at Coinfacts images and you'll see plenty in 64 or 65 with similar luster.
"Look up, old boy, and see what you get." -William Bonney.
@Catbert said:
OP suffers from an “ownership is worth a point” additional grade level!
LOL everyone does. However this will
be my key Buffalo type coin as it eclipses my 66 Buffalo in eye appeal. It’s frustrating to be unable to have my fellow forum members who I respect greatly to see this coin in hand. No way to convey blazing proof like appearance from a photo.
Video Link
@Catbert said:
OP suffers from an “ownership is worth a point” additional grade level!
LOL everyone does. However this will
be my key Buffalo type coin as it eclipses my 66 Buffalo in eye appeal. Its frustrating to be unable to have my fellow forum members who I respect greatly to see this coin in hand. No way to convey blazing proof like appearance from a photo.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
@Morgan13 said:
I am sure its a nice coin but the images aren't that good.
It would be worth the effort if you could get some better shots.
Id really like to see it.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
>
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Here’s the video link for coin.
Fixed.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
>
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Here’s the video link for coin.
Fixed.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your assessment. For the fun of it I had AI look at the images and they saw right away that the coin had proof or proof like properties. I didn’t influence AI. Just asked their opinion and they thought it was a labeling error and the coin was proof, which of course it is not. And are you are going to tell me that coin with this look has the appearance of a normal MS 64?? Or does it look like a higher grade coin.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
>
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Here’s the video link for coin.
Fixed.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your assessment. For the fun of it I had AI look at the images and they saw right away that the coin had proof or proof like properties. I didn’t influence AI. Just asked their opinion and they thought it was a labeling error and the coin was proof, which of course it is not
AI is built off of a large data set where there's no guarantee of the quality of the information it receives, meanwhile @MFeld has an incredible amount of knowledge and experience. I'd take Mark's assessment over AI that may have been trained on your prior posts any day.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
>
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Here’s the video link for coin.
Fixed.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your assessment. For the fun of it I had AI look at the images and they saw right away that the coin had proof or proof like properties. I didn’t influence AI. Just asked their opinion and they thought it was a labeling error and the coin was proof, which of course it is not
AI is built off of a large data set where there's no guarantee of the quality of the information it receives, meanwhile @MFeld has an incredible amount of knowledge and experience. I'd take Mark's assessment over AI that may have been trained on your prior posts any day.
Do you see the proof like appearance or that the coin has a look of a much better grade than 64?
@TomB said:
Looks like a great coin, but better shots would certainly be appreciated by all. The holder is also my favorite of the blue insert series as these were issued from around October, 1998 through February, 2002. The cert number, which I know they were not issued sequentially, is also consistent with a 1999 submission as I have some I submitted at that time with numbers around the same range.
@TomB said:
Looks like a great coin, but better shots would certainly be appreciated by all. The holder is also my favorite of the blue insert series as these were issued from around October, 1998 through February, 2002. The cert number, which I know they were not issued sequentially, is also consistent with a 1999 submission as I have some I submitted at that time with numbers around the same range.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
>
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Here’s the video link for coin.
Fixed.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your assessment. For the fun of it I had AI look at the images and they saw right away that the coin had proof or proof like properties. I didn’t influence AI. Just asked their opinion and they thought it was a labeling error and the coin was proof, which of course it is not. And are you are going to tell me that coin with this look has the appearance of a normal MS 64?? Or does it look like a higher grade coin.
You're uninformed and unwilling or unable to learn.
It's a nice coin and you have seen it in-hand and believe in it greatly. In such a case I would advise a client so ship it to CAC and see what they think. Good luck!
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
>
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Here’s the video link for coin.
Fixed.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your assessment. For the fun of it I had AI look at the images and they saw right away that the coin had proof or proof like properties. I didn’t influence AI. Just asked their opinion and they thought it was a labeling error and the coin was proof, which of course it is not. And are you are going to tell me that coin with this look has the appearance of a normal MS 64?? Or does it look like a higher grade coin.
You're uninformed and unwilling or unable to learn.
Harsh criticism. You are entitled to your opinion. But so am I to believe in my coin. I will send it in for an evaluation and update the forum.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
>
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Here’s the video link for coin.
Fixed.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your assessment. For the fun of it I had AI look at the images and they saw right away that the coin had proof or proof like properties. I didn’t influence AI. Just asked their opinion and they thought it was a labeling error and the coin was proof, which of course it is not. And are you are going to tell me that coin with this look has the appearance of a normal MS 64?? Or does it look like a higher grade coin.
You're uninformed and unwilling or unable to learn.
Harsh criticism. You are entitled to your opinion. But so am I to believe in my coin. I will send it in for an evaluation and update the forum.
You are entitled to your own opinions however not all opinions are created equal. Your opinion carries MUCH less weight than @MFeld and many others. This has been proven with basically every post you make on this forum.
And once again, you have purchased a perfectly nice coin, got nutty delusions of grandeur, and turned all of the experts against you.
I can't fathom why you seem to enjoy getting told (and inevitably later proven) how off base you are.
If you are so confident in your eye (lol), why not go get your gold cac FIRST, and then come back here to show off? Clearly you don't care about anyone's opinion but your own so why do you seek out these expert opinions of you always discard them immediately?
I'd be embarrassed on your behalf if I wasn't so frustrated with your behavior.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
>
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Here’s the video link for coin.
Fixed.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your assessment. For the fun of it I had AI look at the images and they saw right away that the coin had proof or proof like properties. I didn’t influence AI. Just asked their opinion and they thought it was a labeling error and the coin was proof, which of course it is not. And are you are going to tell me that coin with this look has the appearance of a normal MS 64?? Or does it look like a higher grade coin.
You're uninformed and unwilling or unable to learn.
Harsh criticism. You are entitled to your opinion. But so am I to believe in my coin. I will send it in for an evaluation and update the forum.
You are entitled to your own opinions however not all opinions are created equal. Your opinion carries MUCH less weight than @MFeld and many others. This has been proven with basically every post you make on this forum.
And once again, you have purchased a perfectly nice coin, got nutty delusions of grandeur, and turned all of the experts against you.
I can't fathom why you seem to enjoy getting told (and inevitably later proven) how off base you are.
If you are so confident in your eye (lol), why not go get your gold cac FIRST, and then come back here to show off? Clearly you don't care about anyone's opinion but your own so why do you seek out these expert opinions of you always discard them immediately?
I'd be embarrassed on your behalf if I wasn't so frustrated with your behavior.
I have accepted criticism from you guys in the past for some purchases being exaggerated in my descriptions.
However this coin I am very certain about as I have seen enough coins to know this coin looks very different from a regular MS coins in terms of surface appearance. And I know I have never seen a MS 64 coin with this eye appeal. So I have reviewed the coin substantially to see if your expert opinions are true and I am way off. But I am seeing the coin in hand and you won’t give me the benefit of the doubt.
Anyway I do respect the experts opinions off the photos. Have you seen the video?
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
>
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Here’s the video link for coin.
Fixed.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your assessment. For the fun of it I had AI look at the images and they saw right away that the coin had proof or proof like properties. I didn’t influence AI. Just asked their opinion and they thought it was a labeling error and the coin was proof, which of course it is not
AI is built off of a large data set where there's no guarantee of the quality of the information it receives, meanwhile @MFeld has an incredible amount of knowledge and experience. I'd take Mark's assessment over AI that may have been trained on your prior posts any day.
Do you see the proof like appearance or that the coin has a look of a much better grade than 64?
I saw a video showing little motion, seemingly trying to fixate on a specific angle, but when the light changed a bit, the surfaces appeared more satiny. Flashy? Sure. Prooflike? Doubtful. Better than 64? I'm not about to grade a coin based on a small, slightly fuzzy photo or video.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
>
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Here’s the video link for coin.
Fixed.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your assessment. For the fun of it I had AI look at the images and they saw right away that the coin had proof or proof like properties. I didn’t influence AI. Just asked their opinion and they thought it was a labeling error and the coin was proof, which of course it is not. And are you are going to tell me that coin with this look has the appearance of a normal MS 64?? Or does it look like a higher grade coin.
You're uninformed and unwilling or unable to learn.
Harsh criticism. You are entitled to your opinion. But so am I to believe in my coin. I will send it in for an evaluation and update the forum.
You are entitled to your own opinions however not all opinions are created equal. Your opinion carries MUCH less weight than @MFeld and many others. This has been proven with basically every post you make on this forum.
And once again, you have purchased a perfectly nice coin, got nutty delusions of grandeur, and turned all of the experts against you.
I can't fathom why you seem to enjoy getting told (and inevitably later proven) how off base you are.
If you are so confident in your eye (lol), why not go get your gold cac FIRST, and then come back here to show off? Clearly you don't care about anyone's opinion but your own so why do you seek out these expert opinions of you always discard them immediately?
I'd be embarrassed on your behalf if I wasn't so frustrated with your behavior.
I have accepted criticism from you guys in the past for some purchases being exaggerated in my descriptions.
But I am seeing the coin in hand and you won’t give me the benefit of the doubt.
@Walkerlover said:
The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.
It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:
So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?
Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.
You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?
I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.
Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.
>
You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.
If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.
No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Here’s the video link for coin.
Fixed.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your assessment. For the fun of it I had AI look at the images and they saw right away that the coin had proof or proof like properties. I didn’t influence AI. Just asked their opinion and they thought it was a labeling error and the coin was proof, which of course it is not
AI is built off of a large data set where there's no guarantee of the quality of the information it receives, meanwhile @MFeld has an incredible amount of knowledge and experience. I'd take Mark's assessment over AI that may have been trained on your prior posts any day.
Do you see the proof like appearance or that the coin has a look of a much better grade than 64?
I saw a video showing little motion, seemingly trying to fixate on a specific angle, but when the light changed a bit, the surfaces appeared more satiny. Flashy? Sure. Prooflike? Doubtful. Better than 64? I'm not about to grade a coin based on a small, slightly fuzzy photo or video.
Fair enough sir. Thanks for your input. I will send it to CAC and see what happens and inform you with the results
Ive heard of upgrading to a + on modern grading in current holders.
I dont like to be negative.
Ive been following this thread.
Its unlikely that NGC and or PCGS would be off by a couple of points and miss the prooflike designation on a coin like this.
If it really does happen for you after you resubmit to PCGS I want to be the first to congratulate you.
I have no doubt you really believe what your saying.
Send it in and prove to everyone they are wrong!
You'll have the last laugh.
I wish you luck 🍀
Student of numismatics and collector of Morgan dollars
Successful BST transactions with: Namvet Justindan Mattniss RWW olah_in_MA
Dantheman984 Toyz4geo SurfinxHI greencopper RWW bigjpst bretsan MWallace logger7 JWP BruceS bigjpst
JWP PROMETHIUS88
AI is built off of a large data set where there's no guarantee of the quality of the information it receives, meanwhile @MFeld has an incredible amount of knowledge and experience. I'd take Mark's assessment over AI that may have been trained on your prior posts any day.
Do you see the proof like appearance or that the coin has a look of a much better grade than 64?
I saw a video showing little motion, seemingly trying to fixate on a specific angle, but when the light changed a bit, the surfaces appeared more satiny. Flashy? Sure. Prooflike? Doubtful. Better than 64? I'm not about to grade a coin based on a small, slightly fuzzy photo or video.
Fair enough sir. Thanks for your input. I will send it to CAC and see what happens and inform you with the results
finally, the correct OP response, gosh, I told you this days ago, it feels that long .
You better post results here
@ChrisH821 said:
Dang, 80 comments... well, "comments".
I'm lucky to get like 10, but then again, people enjoy arguing.
No, they don't.
I never see you posting coins or making any positive contribution to this forum, but you excel at tearing people down
That is so unlike you @Walkerlover Generally you are accurate in your assessments and opinions.
Here is an interesting thread I started that contradicts your statement:
@ChrisH821 said:
Dang, 80 comments... well, "comments".
I'm lucky to get like 10, but then again, people enjoy arguing.
No, they don't.
I never see you posting coins or making any positive contribution to this forum, but you excel at tearing people down
That is so unlike you @Walkerlover Generally you are accurate in your assessments and opinions.
Here is an interesting thread I started that contradicts your statement:
@ChrisH821 said:
Dang, 80 comments... well, "comments".
I'm lucky to get like 10, but then again, people enjoy arguing.
No, they don't.
I never see you posting coins or making any positive contribution to this forum, but you excel at tearing people down
That is so unlike you @Walkerlover Generally you are accurate in your assessments and opinions.
Here is an interesting thread I started that contradicts your statement:
@ChrisH821 said:
Dang, 80 comments... well, "comments".
I'm lucky to get like 10, but then again, people enjoy arguing.
No, they don't.
I never see you posting coins or making any positive contribution to this forum, but you excel at tearing people down
That is so unlike you @Walkerlover Generally you are accurate in your assessments and opinions.
Here is an interesting thread I started that contradicts your statement:
"I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread."
So switch to your Insanity Limit and stick around.
Pete
I think what most are not understanding is that the coin shows chrome like liquid surfaces which makes it brighten up under light to an extreme degree. Probably a first strike maybe from used proof dies. Anyway sent to CAC for evaluation. Will update
Comments
Thanks, I hadn’t seen that. I can’t tell for certain what caused it. But that, along with other flaws on the cheek, nose and jaw, certainly explains the 64 grade.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Wow thats alot of money.
I think the problem this coin might have is that it could grade MS63. You never know. The images are lousy. The fields look super clean but are they for sure?
I cant tell if its PL or not but I think its a longshot.
What if its got a wheel mark?
Student of numismatics and collector of Morgan dollars
Successful BST transactions with: Namvet Justindan Mattniss RWW olah_in_MA
Dantheman984 Toyz4geo SurfinxHI greencopper RWW bigjpst bretsan MWallace logger7 JWP BruceS bigjpst
JWP PROMETHIUS88
The OP said he doesn’t want to have the coin removed from the holder, so it can’t grade 63.
And if it had a wheel mark, it’s likely that it would have been noticed by PCGS.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Looks like a 64 to me. I’ve seen numerous 1936 Buffs with outstanding luster. A 64 CAC green coin is worth about $80 on GC now. It’s your money but no way is it a gold bean candidate imho.
Mr Feld Would this 1936 be worth a similar amount in PL since it also is a proof year as opposed to the 1937 D which is a mint state only coin?
I am going to review the coin for the contact marks you mentioned. But the flashy brightness of the PL luster helps conceal them somewhat
I wouldn’t have thought that the 1937-D would bring nearly that much. However, whatever the value of a PL1936, I don’t think it would be negatively impacted due to the existence of 1936 Proofs.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
I don’t see much difference between the NGC 63 PL in the link you sent me. Do you see any significant difference? Maybe I should consider a crossover to NGC for PL designation only. Is that possible without any risk of the coin being reholdered if it fails? Thanks for the link BTW.
Pretty late to comment just since I’ve been on a different device, but that Buffalo is stunning!
This gave me the idea to finally purchase another Buffalo, so…thanks for that!!
"Another day, another Collectors Universe forum scrolling session."
- Someone, probably
I can’t tell from the images, but sometimes all it takes is a tiny difference for a different grade and/or designation.
Anytime you submit coins for grading there’s a risk - even if extremely small - that something will go wrong.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Noise on cheek and nose and in the hair make 64 seem about right. Nice luster but that is common on a 1936. Look at Coinfacts images and you'll see plenty in 64 or 65 with similar luster.
"Look up, old boy, and see what you get." -William Bonney.
OP suffers from an “ownership is worth a point” additional grade level!
"She comes out of the sun in a silk dress,
running like a water color in the rain...."
LOL everyone does. However this will
be my key Buffalo type coin as it eclipses my 66 Buffalo in eye appeal. It’s frustrating to be unable to have my fellow forum members who I respect greatly to see this coin in hand. No way to convey blazing proof like appearance from a photo.
Video Link
https://youtube.com/shorts/9cMKu5Xz3Wc?si=7BeknswyDQzMJJ-z
.
Is there a way to post a video on this forum?
Here’s the video link for coin.
https://youtube.com/shorts/QCqHzGvfEwU?is=BAMfxdTxtuI_5L5u
https://youtube.com/shorts/gflRZ-DV6AQ?is=Xd3wHKe0HFieQSqY
https://youtube.com/shorts/t-nzssER-z0?is=P-ADSPG804MHJ1gQ
Here’s a video
https://youtube.com/shorts/QCqHzGvfEwU?is=BAMfxdTxtuI_5L5u
https://youtube.com/shorts/QCqHzGvfEwU?is=fm0C-X8fDWWKbS8j
https://youtube.com/shorts/t-nzssER-z0?is=P-ADSPG804MHJ1gQ
These videos are private and we can’t see them
Fixed.
https://youtube.com/shorts/QCqHzGvfEwU?is=BAMfxdTxtuI_5L5u
https://youtube.com/shorts/gflRZ-DV6AQ?is=73yUXAmqs-DpCiE8
https://youtube.com/shorts/t-nzssER-z0?is=P-ADSPG804MHJ1gQ
Correction - OP suffers from an “ownership is worth a point or more” additional grade level.”
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
I was able to view the videos after multiple attempts. The coin looks highly lustrous, but not even close to PL.
I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with your assessment. For the fun of it I had AI look at the images and they saw right away that the coin had proof or proof like properties. I didn’t influence AI. Just asked their opinion and they thought it was a labeling error and the coin was proof, which of course it is not. And are you are going to tell me that coin with this look has the appearance of a normal MS 64?? Or does it look like a higher grade coin.
AI is built off of a large data set where there's no guarantee of the quality of the information it receives, meanwhile @MFeld has an incredible amount of knowledge and experience. I'd take Mark's assessment over AI that may have been trained on your prior posts any day.
Do you see the proof like appearance or that the coin has a look of a much better grade than 64?
Video link Tom
https://youtube.com/shorts/gflRZ-DV6AQ?is=Dsi4tco1wMmzy3Q_
https://youtube.com/shorts/QCqHzGvfEwU?is=c_vgr98GLVLDHYI4
A point, or three apparently...
You're uninformed and unwilling or unable to learn.
chopmarkedtradedollars.com
It's a nice coin and you have seen it in-hand and believe in it greatly. In such a case I would advise a client so ship it to CAC and see what they think. Good luck!
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
Harsh criticism. You are entitled to your opinion. But so am I to believe in my coin. I will send it in for an evaluation and update the forum.
You are entitled to your own opinions however not all opinions are created equal. Your opinion carries MUCH less weight than @MFeld and many others. This has been proven with basically every post you make on this forum.
And once again, you have purchased a perfectly nice coin, got nutty delusions of grandeur, and turned all of the experts against you.
I can't fathom why you seem to enjoy getting told (and inevitably later proven) how off base you are.
If you are so confident in your eye (lol), why not go get your gold cac FIRST, and then come back here to show off? Clearly you don't care about anyone's opinion but your own so why do you seek out these expert opinions of you always discard them immediately?
I'd be embarrassed on your behalf if I wasn't so frustrated with your behavior.
chopmarkedtradedollars.com
I have accepted criticism from you guys in the past for some purchases being exaggerated in my descriptions.
However this coin I am very certain about as I have seen enough coins to know this coin looks very different from a regular MS coins in terms of surface appearance. And I know I have never seen a MS 64 coin with this eye appeal. So I have reviewed the coin substantially to see if your expert opinions are true and I am way off. But I am seeing the coin in hand and you won’t give me the benefit of the doubt.
Anyway I do respect the experts opinions off the photos. Have you seen the video?
Dang, 80 comments... well, "comments".
I'm lucky to get like 10, but then again, people enjoy arguing.
Collector, occasional seller
No, they don't.
I saw a video showing little motion, seemingly trying to fixate on a specific angle, but when the light changed a bit, the surfaces appeared more satiny. Flashy? Sure. Prooflike? Doubtful. Better than 64? I'm not about to grade a coin based on a small, slightly fuzzy photo or video.
The benefit of the doubt is earned, not given.
Fair enough sir. Thanks for your input. I will send it to CAC and see what happens and inform you with the results
Ive heard of upgrading to a + on modern grading in current holders.
I dont like to be negative.
Ive been following this thread.
Its unlikely that NGC and or PCGS would be off by a couple of points and miss the prooflike designation on a coin like this.
If it really does happen for you after you resubmit to PCGS I want to be the first to congratulate you.
I have no doubt you really believe what your saying.
Send it in and prove to everyone they are wrong!
You'll have the last laugh.
I wish you luck 🍀
Student of numismatics and collector of Morgan dollars
Successful BST transactions with: Namvet Justindan Mattniss RWW olah_in_MA
Dantheman984 Toyz4geo SurfinxHI greencopper RWW bigjpst bretsan MWallace logger7 JWP BruceS bigjpst
JWP PROMETHIUS88
It hurts me when these types of threads get so much traction and then perfectly good ones like your show report disappear after a few days.
Coin Photography
finally, the correct OP response, gosh, I told you this days ago, it feels that long .
You better post results here
I never see you posting coins or making any positive contribution to this forum, but you excel at tearing people down
That is so unlike you @Walkerlover Generally you are accurate in your assessments and opinions.
Here is an interesting thread I started that contradicts your statement:
https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1118433/as-more-non-collectors-are-gathering-around-to-hoard-collect-lincoln-cents-here-is-a-chart#latest
Whatever, you tend to be rude to people with your comments.
Oh, my gosh.
Even earlier this afternoon I left a heartfelt comment on this thread (whereas others were not so kind):
https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1125997/an-upcoming-change-to-our-submission-process#latest
Everything you are accusing me of is exactly the behavior you have exhibited in your last two posts (among many others, unfortunately).
What heartfelt comment are you referring to?
"I’ve now reached or exceeded my sanity limit for replies to this thread."
So switch to your Insanity Limit and stick around.
Pete