Options
Looking for thoughts on opportunity to purchase Franklins......
There is not much recent history on comps for these coins but looking for opinions on what one should look to pay for the following Franklins. The coins are nice in hand, but this is not my usual series.:
1949-S MS-67+ CAC Hansen Collection
1951-S MS-67+ CAC Hansen Collection
1950-D PCGS MS-66+ CAC
Brian
1
Comments
For investment? Probably not.
For the sheer joy of collecting? Sure.
These are top end coins that will cost top end dollars. Why are you interesting in buying?
The 50-D sure looks slam dunk FBL so I looked up its cert ..... MS66+FBL with a PCGS price guide of $2150
pop 36 with 10 higher
I’m curious, if it’s not your usual series, what’s the reason for your interest in the coins?
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Diversification of the collecting. Very nice coins, hard to come by without paying huge premium on Hansen coins. I have been given a price so since CAC doesn't price plus grades I was curious what people with more experience in this series thought.
This is one of the methods I use, when trying to come up with ballpark values for + grade coins, in the absence of any good recent auction comps:
1) I look at auction results for coins of the same numerical grade, but without the +.
2) I then compare those prices to the price guide value of the grading company which graded the coin, and calculate the ratio of sold price as a percentage of price guide price.
3) Next, I look up the price guide value for + grade examples.
4) I take the ratio from step 2) and apply it to the price guide value of + grade coins.
I don’t claim that this is an ideal way to estimate a + coin’s value. But often, it seems to help.
If the above is unclear and/or sounds like too much work, I’ll be happy to apply it to one of the coins in the opening post and come up with a number.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
I would appreciate an example.of your cacilation.
Below is a pretty good comp for the 1951-S PCGS MS67+/CAC. It brought $2280 in June of last year. PCGS price guide is $3500.
https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-1KQCM0/1951-s-franklin-half-dollar-ms-67-pcgs-cac
>
Here's a link to a 1950-D PCGS MS66+ (non CAC) that brought $1923.75 in May of this year, against a PCGS price guide value of $2150:
https://www.greatcollections.com/Coin/2102306/1950-D-Franklin-Half-Dollar-PCGS-MS-66-FBL-Toned
>
Here's a link to a 1949-S PCGS MS67 (non-plus) /CAC example that brought $552 in January of last year against a PCGS price guide value of $1100. The price guide value for MS67+ is $1750.
https://coins.ha.com/itm/franklin-half-dollars/1949-s-50c-ms67-pcgs-cac-cac-population-22-2-mintage-3-744-000/a/132504-27498.s
>
Below is a lnk for a 1949-S PCGS MS67+ (non-CAC) that brought $2094.75 in December of 2024. :
https://www.greatcollections.com/Coin/1517119/1949-S-Franklin-Half-Dollar-PCGS-MS-67-Toned
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
"Hansen collection", I can't say I know much about it, but there are many listed on the DLRC site (those are quite pricey coins). As for Franklins, most of the dedicated collectors, gurus, and experts either tossed in the towel years ago, sold their sets, or have since passed away. There is still a legacy of their posts from 20 or more years ago, and you can find quite good information here. I'd also recommend looking for a copy of Tomaska's book, many of the color plates feature coins that were sent him by collectors here and were included in the book. You can research the old-time Franklin dealers but I'm afraid you won't find too many leads on them; Wooten and Leber are a couple of names. If you still want to pursue Franklins, maybe stick with lower end PCGS MS65s which won't break the bank while you learn your way forward.
I find it interesting that the Franklin series is about the only one I recall that allows for Superb Gem MS67 coins to be a bit lackluster. I've viewed albeit colorful coins within the series graded MS66 or even MS67 that had muted luster.
Edited to add:
Perhaps I place too much of a premium on luster. If so, by bad.
Luster is not exactly apparent beneath all of that color.
The 49S and 51S at the top of page are top-notch quality color Franklins but not sure I'd pay a huge price for them. A handful of 58D sold on eBay in past couple of months under 500; of course, the 58D is well-known for eye-popping colors, other dates not as much. Franklins been in a bear market for some time now. That 50D in PCGS MS66+ CAC would have sold for megabucks some 20 or more years ago. Search on users Supercarcoins aka Bubbah, Foxxze, PawPaul and about a dozen other names, he was unique and eccentric but he knew Franklins very well. There's a few others also but they have not posted here in quite some time.
You can try US double mint sets issued 1948-1958 which were the source of many a color toned MS Franklin but unfortunately you won't find too many original sets still in existence today. The money coins have been long ago popped out and submitted for grading and replaced with a drab run-of-the-mill coin, so be very careful with these.
Partial shot of a 1958 board, these are the Denver coins. This is the type of toning to look for if acquiring these sets; I was buying these for 100-150 back in the day. Also proof sets for about 5 or 6 bucks (no one wanted them).
Bought this 56P in MS66 for US $144. The 56P is not known for rainbow color; in fact this one looks like someone spit tobacco juice all over it. Still, if I were looking to get started in Franklins I'd consider coins in MS66 in this price range, FBL or not.
For obscure reasons my Franklin half collecting is centered around Cameo proofs and attractively toned proofs.
For obscure reasons my Franklin half collecting efforts have centered on Cameo Proofs and eye appealing toned Proofs.
Ben looks pretty good when he is covered with thick, white frost surrounded by deeply mirrored black watery fields and/or is adorned in multicolored toning.
@yangban, agreed. Best place to find these “colorful” examples would be from these original Mint uncirculated sets. Here’s the Denver panel from my 1958 set. Zack.

That's a beautiful board and a sweet Franklin! I need to pull my sets out one of these days and go thru them; I don't have all that many, maybe 7 or 8.