Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

Show me your Improperly Annealed Coins for Confirmation/Discussion/Evaluation

Main purpose -add information for my SEM/EDS & XRF study next year.

Primarily a collector of error coins over the next decade after collecting for 40 years. Have collected & studied every coin series in the Western Hemishere - yes - even ...

Comments

  • Options
    WQuarterFreddieWQuarterFreddie Posts: 3,358 ✭✭✭✭✭

    $1 Trump Coin non privy

  • Options

    The 2026 Trump $1 Semiquincentennial coin is struck from the same manganese-brass clad alloy used for modern Sacagawea and Presidential dollars. Although its golden appearance leads some collectors to assume it contains gold, the coin is actually composed primarily of copper with approximately 6% zinc, 3.5% manganese, and 2% nickel. This alloy was selected for its durability, distinctive color, and resistance to circulation wear, giving the coin a metallic appearance similar to other modern golden U.S. dollar issues.

    From a metallurgical perspective, the Trump dollar should exhibit characteristics nearly identical to those of Sacagawea and Presidential dollars. XRF analysis is expected to show a copper-rich alloy with measurable zinc, manganese, and nickel, while SEM/EDS examination would reveal a relatively uniform distribution of these elements throughout the surface. Unlike bronze Lincoln cents, no tin is present, and unlike clad dimes, quarters, and half dollars, there are no copper-nickel outer layers.

    Based on the behavior of manganese-brass dollar alloys and the improper-annealing color progression observed in other copper-containing coinage, a reasonable prediction for the long-term color pathway would be: bright gold → deeper gold → amber-gold → light brown → medium brown → dark brown, with isolated dark gray areas potentially developing in regions exposed to elevated humidity, contaminants, or prolonged environmental exposure. Unlike bronze cents, which often develop red and chocolate-brown tones due to copper oxidation and the presence of tin, the manganese-brass alloy tends to retain a more golden-brown appearance through much of its aging process. If studied by SEM/EDS, progressively darker surfaces would be expected to show increasing oxygen levels and lower metal-to-oxygen ratios, reflecting gradual surface oxidation rather than alloy segregation. This makes the Trump dollar an interesting modern specimen for examining oxidation-driven color evolution in manganese-brass coinage, with its likely progression paralleling that of older Sacagawea dollars as they age in circulation and storage.

    Primarily a collector of error coins over the next decade after collecting for 40 years. Have collected & studied every coin series in the Western Hemishere - yes - even ...
  • Options

    Describe your coin based on this preliminary evaluation.

    Primarily a collector of error coins over the next decade after collecting for 40 years. Have collected & studied every coin series in the Western Hemishere - yes - even ...
  • Options

    As with the Sacagawea we may some initial green hues in the first oxidation state from MnO seen in some IA error SACs in my collection. Normally a golden/green hue. Your piece is more advanced IMO if I am seeing brown coloration.

    Primarily a collector of error coins over the next decade after collecting for 40 years. Have collected & studied every coin series in the Western Hemishere - yes - even ...
  • Options
    WQuarterFreddieWQuarterFreddie Posts: 3,358 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Wow! Awesome analysis. My coin's obverse and reverse appears brown.

    I submitted my coin as an error and it is currently at PCGS for grading.

    I will provide updates as I receive them.

    Thank you.

  • Options

    I have several Sacagawea Dollars with brown toning which IMO are IA Errors. None are in slabs. Of the slabs I have seen they are reddish/brown or of an intermediate/late intermediate oxidative states in this ternary (i.e., four metal) alloy.

    Primarily a collector of error coins over the next decade after collecting for 40 years. Have collected & studied every coin series in the Western Hemishere - yes - even ...
  • Options
    WQuarterFreddieWQuarterFreddie Posts: 3,358 ✭✭✭✭✭

    My coin came directly from a US Mint $100 bag and I placed it immediately in the cardboard 2×2.

    I sent it to PCGS to authenticate it more then "grade" it.

    Looking forward to the results!

  • Options
    WQuarterFreddieWQuarterFreddie Posts: 3,358 ✭✭✭✭✭

    I found two IA Trump coins
    This is the side view.....

  • Options
    Clackamas1Clackamas1 Posts: 1,764 ✭✭✭✭✭

    I once sold about $80 face of annealing errors to Fred at the Portland ANA back in the day. Took the money and bought a nice 65RB 1868 Indian head 1C.

  • Options

    He is #1 but lets face it - the error world and their top experts as with PCGS/NGC/ANACS has had some tough times with the word "IMPROPER." Consider the blunders of the so-called Sintered Planchet corrected by Mike Diamond in 2010 with his correspondence with the U.S. Mint and permanently buried with Roger Burdette's new book on Sintered Patterns. Just leaving my comfort zone for about a year and looking more deeply into Improper Annealing & Improper Alloy Mix Errors. Improper Annealing Errors will be my paper in May/June 2027 and Improper Alloy Mix and WOODIES/Wood Grain Effect Errors is planned for November/December 2027. John Lorenzo, Numismatist.

    Primarily a collector of error coins over the next decade after collecting for 40 years. Have collected & studied every coin series in the Western Hemishere - yes - even ...
  • Options
    KurisuKurisu Posts: 2,234 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Here are a few I've pulled and sent out for grading from my coin roll hunting...










    Coins are Neato!

    "If it's a penny for your thoughts and you put in your two cents worth, then someone...somewhere...is making a penny." - Steven Wright

  • Options

    Perfect. Showcases the brown or what I will call Oxidation State III. A brown or light gray depending on your color perspective or interpretation. Note that coins with high luster will WEAKEN the brown color in some examples. Here is why from my research/analysis so far: For Cu-Ni clad coins such as Washington quarters, Roosevelt dimes, Kennedy half dollars, and other modern clad issues, high-luster MS63-MS65 examples can visually appear less oxidized than they actually are. The reason is that mint luster consists of microscopic flow lines created during striking that reflect light in a strong cartwheel pattern. Even when oxidation has progressed into a brown or dark-brown stage (OX III), these reflective surfaces continue to return substantial light to the viewer, partially masking the true extent of oxidation.

    In Cu-Ni alloys, color is controlled not only by oxide development but also by optical effects. A highly lustrous quarter with an advanced oxide film may still appear bright brown, golden-brown, or even partially silver-gray because the cartwheel effect increases reflectivity across the surface. The underlying luster effectively competes with the darkening influence of the oxide layer. As a result, color alone may understate the actual oxidation state present on the coin.

    By contrast, lower-grade or impaired examples often have disrupted flow lines and diminished luster from circulation, contact marks, or environmental exposure. Without strong cartwheel reflection, the oxide layer dominates the visual appearance, causing the coin to look darker and more heavily oxidized. Consequently, two quarters with similar oxygen levels and similar Cu/O ratios may appear very different visually, with the more lustrous specimen looking significantly lighter.

    This optical masking effect is why SEM/EDS analysis is important when studying improperly annealed Cu-Ni clad coins. A brown MS65 quarter may actually possess oxidation levels comparable to a much darker, less lustrous specimen. Therefore, oxidation state should be evaluated from oxygen content, Cu/O ratios, and surface morphology rather than color alone, since strong mint luster can partially conceal advanced stages of oxidation.

    Primarily a collector of error coins over the next decade after collecting for 40 years. Have collected & studied every coin series in the Western Hemishere - yes - even ...
  • Options

    ANACS indeed IMO has always been in top form with IA errors. VERY NICE GROUPING!

    Primarily a collector of error coins over the next decade after collecting for 40 years. Have collected & studied every coin series in the Western Hemishere - yes - even ...
  • Options
    USSID18USSID18 Posts: 903 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Disclaimer: I'm not a dealer, trader, grader, investor or professional numismatist. I'm just a hobbyist. (To protect me but mostly you! 🤣 ) "Formerly OAKSTAR with 8,777 posts"

  • Options

    What surface disturbances do you see in Jefferson's throat area? Describe. Explain why this occurs. The explanation IN FULL is in my upcoming 2027 paper. Is this a diagnostic trait (effect) with 58-P & 59-P Black Beauties? .

    Primarily a collector of error coins over the next decade after collecting for 40 years. Have collected & studied every coin series in the Western Hemishere - yes - even ...
  • Options

    See Mint Error News Publication #97: Ylitalo, Jeff. Mint Error News Journal # 97. Featured Article – Error Coins – Improper Annealing. Page 192. It should be mentioned for clarity and consistency for the first Oxidation State (OX I) this study calls the color hue gold whereas Jeff Ylitalo calls it orange. Sometimes there is mixing of red in this stage (i.e., OX I & OX II – combined) so some may call it gold or orange depending on how much it mixes with the next advanced oxidation state OX II – red. It’s for the same reason some people call Black Beauties not so much black but brownish gray or dark brown – color perception is dependent at times on one’s opinion and perspective of color.

    Primarily a collector of error coins over the next decade after collecting for 40 years. Have collected & studied every coin series in the Western Hemishere - yes - even ...

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file