Thanks to a recent post, we are treated to the pictures of the 2027 and on, Kennedy Half Dollars. My question…. Will the completely resigned Kennedy Obverse, produce additional interest for the traditional Kennedy halves that were produced and were very popular to coin collectors and the general public for over sixty years ? Interesting thought.
Most half dollars weren't really worth the cost of shipping until just a few years ago. A great number of the mint set coins went circulation and are now in XF/ AU in bank rolls.
Attrition on half dollars isn't very high <2% but they were poorly made and most of them are degrade. There don't seem to be many sliders left and the highest grades are AU 50 to 55, and these aren't plentiful.
BU half rolls are pretty hot now and nobody can stock every date. For the first time I'm seeing a little activity in the 2002 to date issues. These are all very readily available because most owners have quantities but they still have potential because mintages are quite low. A lot of people sort these later date coins and spend the poor ones so that leaves even fewer of the low mintages. It will be interesting to see what they do if demand keeps ratcheting higher.
There are no daring predictions but it shows all the activity and young blood infusing the hobby and markets. I have little doubt that a lot of the interest in BU rolls is coming from younger collectors who understand how scarce they are how collectible they already are.
Most collectors are still much older than the general population and new collectors are springing up all over. Thank goodness, or we'd have no one to whom to sell our collections.
Nobody knows what their collections will look like in 50 years and this will shape the direction of the hobby and every market in it. The only prediction I'm confident to make is these collections will be different and more diverse than most of ours. There are already lots of early signs.
@HIGHLOWLEAVES said:
It is not a BU roll of modern date coins but on Ebay, a seller is asking $42.00 for a 1973 Mint Set. What is going on ?
The thing I find most remarkable is that back in the late-'70's the 1973 approached $50 (about $300 in today's money). Now most of the mint sets are gone and most of the coins are gone but $42 stands out as being high priced!
Back in 1973 nobody seemed to notice 80% of the Ikes while otherwise attractive were badly marred by scratches and gouges. The sets all traded as though they were equal. In those days collectors didn't distinguish a Gem Morgan dollar from a beat up mess so it's hard to imagine how little they cared about the fact only 1 '73 Ike in 400 was a nice Gem. They also didn't care about FB dimes or Gem '73-S cents.
In very real ways they still don't!!! The incidence of Gems in '73 mint sets hasn't dropped that much because most sets are destroyed after they've been checked for varieties and Gems and because a lot of the sets sorted out because they were better find their way back to the market. Heirs don't know the collector had set aside a few choice sets each year so they end up back in dealer inventory. Spectacular Gems stand out enough they are more likely to be pulled out but most of the nicest coins remain in the few sets that are left. Let's face it, most dealers can't be bothered to even glance at all those mint sets they buy at face value and many still end up in the till.
It's simply remarkable how few of these sets are being bought and sold. Dealer inventories are quite stable despite the fact that there are only 20 or 25 dealers doing much business in the sets. A few move product but these are not wholesale quantities but rather collector quantities. It's not like the old days and there were seven or eight wholesalers you could call up and buy a few hundred of any date and they could get more if you needed them. I just no longer see any evidence that any of these sets trade in substantial quantities. I see some wholesalers trying to acquire quantities but it's a protracted process now days. I see retailers trying to acquire to sell on TV or in promotions.
It looks like the sets belong to individuals who have no strong attraction to them and are being bought by a general public who don't know what the reality is. But the rock is still closing in on the hard place. Supply isn't infinite even though the market treats it like a bottomless well.
Sure a high percentage of the Ikes from the destroyed sets survive but it's under 50% and many of these are degraded. Among these survivors most are just run of the mill and run of the mill '73 Ikes are pretty banged up. It's a curious situation where nice coins are simply spread far and wide but people don't know it because they think there are millions of them so they don't collect them, look at them, or acknowledge they even exist.
Do coin dealers regularly inspect U S Mint Sets for Gem examples before they offer them say on EBay ? If so, would it be best to avoid those offerings if you want to build an excellent set of coins ?
A lot of dealers now days have an online presence but very very few sell mint sets. There are many reasons for this but chief among them is that there's no money in it. You can't get quantities top sell and if you do there's still not much mark up or volume because it's a very thin market.
Many of the mint set sellers on eBay aren't typical coin dealers so much as eBay specialist who sell all manner of products with many concentrating on coins. And volumes are still low because the demands is low. In the old days you could easily buy all the unopened boxes of mint sets on eBay because there were so few, there was no premium (on most dates), and they were very cheap. A lot of the sets being sold were in unopened packages because they sometimes did get a premium especially for dates like the 1970. This strongly suggests neither the buyers nor the sellers were concerned about most varieties or any of the Gems. This no longer appears to be the case. Few sets are trading hands, prices are much higher, and premiums run high on the few unopened boxes that are seen. Everyone is looking for Gems and varieties. Wholesalers used to have mountains of sets and these were lightly picked over (some sets were checked for everything and some were checked for a few things and then rest were random. But you can't find mountains of sets anywhere any longer. The supply is taken for granted so the big retailers are the only ones with stock but I'd be surprised if they have even a couple hundred sets per date (I wouldn't know). Why build stock when all you have to do is offer bid + 10% and you'll be buried in them? I would assume retailers all check their sets at least for biggies.
No, I think the only way to have a good chance of getting a knockout Gem or well known variety is at the source; The local coin shop. Heirs bring in boxes of sets that the dealers buy for a song but it's hard to get these because a lot of dealers have ready buyers for "anything that comes in made after 1964". They're paying 5 to 20% over bid and dealers don't have to hassle with postage and 30% back of bid. They have zero customers so it even saves them the trouble of cutting up sets for the cash register. These sets end up going to the general public in many ways and I'm sure a few are wholesaled. They're going to eBay, estate sales, auctions, and gift shops. Some go to the TV sellers and places like Amazon or Walmart. They are absorbed; consumed. For the main part the buying and selling of mint sets isn't really done by coin collectors and coin dealers but others directly or indirectly related to the coin hobby.
Eventually someone will want a nice pristine 1971 mint set and won't stop looking until he has one and the whole thing will change. The dynamic of selling within the hobby and buying outside the hobby will stop and the flow reverse. Funny thing is though there will be almost no flow coming back because the sets are gone and home shoppers might not have sufficiently cared for their sets or long ago they went to the coin shop and ended up in the cash register. No matter how cheap or how expensive a 1971 mint set is offering bid +10% simply won't result in a single set and this will change almost overnight.
.
Copilot-
_"As you put it:
So long as offering bid plus 10% produces another set, price discovery is suppressed.
The moment that offer no longer produces inventory, sellers realize they are not competing with yesterday's bid sheet but with future scarcity. That is often when markets revalue very quickly."_
@HIGHLOWLEAVES said:
Do coin dealers regularly inspect U S Mint Sets for Gem examples before they offer them say on EBay ? If so, would it be best to avoid those offerings if you want to build an excellent set of coins ?
I can't overemphasize just how tiny this demand is that is overtaking the coin market. Back in the days you could buy unopened boxes of mint sets on eBay for bid plus postage it was only several boxes (of 5) a month and this was a significant fraction of the sets that were trading (~10%). Today there may be fewer sets trading but at much higher prices. In addition to eBay there are about "20" dealers that have fixed price lists for mint sets but one of the biggest of these that usually has stock and lower prices (bid +40%) has sold a total of '3" of one of the most popular old sets in the last five weeks!!!
I doubt all the sources put together are moving more than 40 or 50 of each date per month. These numbers are simply insignificant compared to potential aggregate demand. They seem impossible because even though there are no mountains of sets any longer anywhere every insider knows that if they advertise to buy (bid) then lots of sets will come in. The perception even among insiders is that they are very very common but this exists only because the demand is tiny and mintages were in the millions. Even with so few left the supply can still dwarf the demand.
As mentioned before though this supply still originates at the corner coin shops and higher and higher percentages are being diverted to other venues. When it stops it's over. There won't be any sets left to check and those left will command retail prices and contain a far lower percentage of Gems. This will be an "event" because once there aren't enough sets to keep the buyers busy not even higher prices will increase the flow.
We still imagine that all those millions of sets are there just waiting for a market but this isn't how things work. They've been sold into an unwilling market that just destroyed them because they were worth more as singles and pocket change than they were as collectibles.
Not only are there very very few 1975 mint sets left but they are all wrecks. Most of them were poorly made but now every set is tarnished. You can't find rolls of most of these coins and even if you do they'll be very poorly made from poorly adjusted worn dies and they'll be banged up. Demand just keeps ratcheting higher with a few more every month. Once it's recognized the mint sets are gone a couple of things will follow. First mint set sellers will want more money and second more people will collect moderns. The only thing suppressing demand is everyone tells them all moderns are as common as grains of sand on the beach. If this isn't true and attractive specimens are hard to find then more will want to collect them.
Bottom line; there is no supply and no demand and most buyers want registry quality coins and this is what has been driving thew market. But no supply and no demand has brought the supply down to such small number the current situation is highly unstable. It is unsustainable. The draw off continues as the draw down is nearly absolute.
Comments
Thanks to a recent post, we are treated to the pictures of the 2027 and on, Kennedy Half Dollars. My question…. Will the completely resigned Kennedy Obverse, produce additional interest for the traditional Kennedy halves that were produced and were very popular to coin collectors and the general public for over sixty years ? Interesting thought.
Most half dollars weren't really worth the cost of shipping until just a few years ago. A great number of the mint set coins went circulation and are now in XF/ AU in bank rolls.
Attrition on half dollars isn't very high <2% but they were poorly made and most of them are degrade. There don't seem to be many sliders left and the highest grades are AU 50 to 55, and these aren't plentiful.
BU half rolls are pretty hot now and nobody can stock every date. For the first time I'm seeing a little activity in the 2002 to date issues. These are all very readily available because most owners have quantities but they still have potential because mintages are quite low. A lot of people sort these later date coins and spend the poor ones so that leaves even fewer of the low mintages. It will be interesting to see what they do if demand keeps ratcheting higher.
Here's one of the best articles I've ever seen about the future of collecting from Numismatic News.
https://www.numismaticnews.net/the-future-of-coin-collecting
There are no daring predictions but it shows all the activity and young blood infusing the hobby and markets. I have little doubt that a lot of the interest in BU rolls is coming from younger collectors who understand how scarce they are how collectible they already are.
Most collectors are still much older than the general population and new collectors are springing up all over. Thank goodness, or we'd have no one to whom to sell our collections.
Nobody knows what their collections will look like in 50 years and this will shape the direction of the hobby and every market in it. The only prediction I'm confident to make is these collections will be different and more diverse than most of ours. There are already lots of early signs.
The thing I find most remarkable is that back in the late-'70's the 1973 approached $50 (about $300 in today's money). Now most of the mint sets are gone and most of the coins are gone but $42 stands out as being high priced!
Back in 1973 nobody seemed to notice 80% of the Ikes while otherwise attractive were badly marred by scratches and gouges. The sets all traded as though they were equal. In those days collectors didn't distinguish a Gem Morgan dollar from a beat up mess so it's hard to imagine how little they cared about the fact only 1 '73 Ike in 400 was a nice Gem. They also didn't care about FB dimes or Gem '73-S cents.
In very real ways they still don't!!! The incidence of Gems in '73 mint sets hasn't dropped that much because most sets are destroyed after they've been checked for varieties and Gems and because a lot of the sets sorted out because they were better find their way back to the market. Heirs don't know the collector had set aside a few choice sets each year so they end up back in dealer inventory. Spectacular Gems stand out enough they are more likely to be pulled out but most of the nicest coins remain in the few sets that are left. Let's face it, most dealers can't be bothered to even glance at all those mint sets they buy at face value and many still end up in the till.
It's simply remarkable how few of these sets are being bought and sold. Dealer inventories are quite stable despite the fact that there are only 20 or 25 dealers doing much business in the sets. A few move product but these are not wholesale quantities but rather collector quantities. It's not like the old days and there were seven or eight wholesalers you could call up and buy a few hundred of any date and they could get more if you needed them. I just no longer see any evidence that any of these sets trade in substantial quantities. I see some wholesalers trying to acquire quantities but it's a protracted process now days. I see retailers trying to acquire to sell on TV or in promotions.
It looks like the sets belong to individuals who have no strong attraction to them and are being bought by a general public who don't know what the reality is. But the rock is still closing in on the hard place. Supply isn't infinite even though the market treats it like a bottomless well.
Sure a high percentage of the Ikes from the destroyed sets survive but it's under 50% and many of these are degraded. Among these survivors most are just run of the mill and run of the mill '73 Ikes are pretty banged up. It's a curious situation where nice coins are simply spread far and wide but people don't know it because they think there are millions of them so they don't collect them, look at them, or acknowledge they even exist.
Time flies.
Do coin dealers regularly inspect U S Mint Sets for Gem examples before they offer them say on EBay ? If so, would it be best to avoid those offerings if you want to build an excellent set of coins ?
A lot of dealers now days have an online presence but very very few sell mint sets. There are many reasons for this but chief among them is that there's no money in it. You can't get quantities top sell and if you do there's still not much mark up or volume because it's a very thin market.
Many of the mint set sellers on eBay aren't typical coin dealers so much as eBay specialist who sell all manner of products with many concentrating on coins. And volumes are still low because the demands is low. In the old days you could easily buy all the unopened boxes of mint sets on eBay because there were so few, there was no premium (on most dates), and they were very cheap. A lot of the sets being sold were in unopened packages because they sometimes did get a premium especially for dates like the 1970. This strongly suggests neither the buyers nor the sellers were concerned about most varieties or any of the Gems. This no longer appears to be the case. Few sets are trading hands, prices are much higher, and premiums run high on the few unopened boxes that are seen. Everyone is looking for Gems and varieties. Wholesalers used to have mountains of sets and these were lightly picked over (some sets were checked for everything and some were checked for a few things and then rest were random. But you can't find mountains of sets anywhere any longer. The supply is taken for granted so the big retailers are the only ones with stock but I'd be surprised if they have even a couple hundred sets per date (I wouldn't know). Why build stock when all you have to do is offer bid + 10% and you'll be buried in them? I would assume retailers all check their sets at least for biggies.
No, I think the only way to have a good chance of getting a knockout Gem or well known variety is at the source; The local coin shop. Heirs bring in boxes of sets that the dealers buy for a song but it's hard to get these because a lot of dealers have ready buyers for "anything that comes in made after 1964". They're paying 5 to 20% over bid and dealers don't have to hassle with postage and 30% back of bid. They have zero customers so it even saves them the trouble of cutting up sets for the cash register. These sets end up going to the general public in many ways and I'm sure a few are wholesaled. They're going to eBay, estate sales, auctions, and gift shops. Some go to the TV sellers and places like Amazon or Walmart. They are absorbed; consumed. For the main part the buying and selling of mint sets isn't really done by coin collectors and coin dealers but others directly or indirectly related to the coin hobby.
Eventually someone will want a nice pristine 1971 mint set and won't stop looking until he has one and the whole thing will change. The dynamic of selling within the hobby and buying outside the hobby will stop and the flow reverse. Funny thing is though there will be almost no flow coming back because the sets are gone and home shoppers might not have sufficiently cared for their sets or long ago they went to the coin shop and ended up in the cash register. No matter how cheap or how expensive a 1971 mint set is offering bid +10% simply won't result in a single set and this will change almost overnight.
.
Copilot-
_"As you put it:
So long as offering bid plus 10% produces another set, price discovery is suppressed.
The moment that offer no longer produces inventory, sellers realize they are not competing with yesterday's bid sheet but with future scarcity. That is often when markets revalue very quickly."_
I can't overemphasize just how tiny this demand is that is overtaking the coin market. Back in the days you could buy unopened boxes of mint sets on eBay for bid plus postage it was only several boxes (of 5) a month and this was a significant fraction of the sets that were trading (~10%). Today there may be fewer sets trading but at much higher prices. In addition to eBay there are about "20" dealers that have fixed price lists for mint sets but one of the biggest of these that usually has stock and lower prices (bid +40%) has sold a total of '3" of one of the most popular old sets in the last five weeks!!!
I doubt all the sources put together are moving more than 40 or 50 of each date per month. These numbers are simply insignificant compared to potential aggregate demand. They seem impossible because even though there are no mountains of sets any longer anywhere every insider knows that if they advertise to buy (bid) then lots of sets will come in. The perception even among insiders is that they are very very common but this exists only because the demand is tiny and mintages were in the millions. Even with so few left the supply can still dwarf the demand.
As mentioned before though this supply still originates at the corner coin shops and higher and higher percentages are being diverted to other venues. When it stops it's over. There won't be any sets left to check and those left will command retail prices and contain a far lower percentage of Gems. This will be an "event" because once there aren't enough sets to keep the buyers busy not even higher prices will increase the flow.
We still imagine that all those millions of sets are there just waiting for a market but this isn't how things work. They've been sold into an unwilling market that just destroyed them because they were worth more as singles and pocket change than they were as collectibles.
Not only are there very very few 1975 mint sets left but they are all wrecks. Most of them were poorly made but now every set is tarnished. You can't find rolls of most of these coins and even if you do they'll be very poorly made from poorly adjusted worn dies and they'll be banged up. Demand just keeps ratcheting higher with a few more every month. Once it's recognized the mint sets are gone a couple of things will follow. First mint set sellers will want more money and second more people will collect moderns. The only thing suppressing demand is everyone tells them all moderns are as common as grains of sand on the beach. If this isn't true and attractive specimens are hard to find then more will want to collect them.
Bottom line; there is no supply and no demand and most buyers want registry quality coins and this is what has been driving thew market. But no supply and no demand has brought the supply down to such small number the current situation is highly unstable. It is unsustainable. The draw off continues as the draw down is nearly absolute.