I normally don’t sell coins… but

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 4:45AM

I’m funding a large purchase. Can anyone review my pricing and let me know if I’m way off? The majority are attractively toned albeit not crazy neon (some are).

*im not attempting to sell in this post or by pm or anywhere just yet *

jmlanzaf · February 21, 2026 5:02AM

Probably reasonable, but some of those prices are going to be hard to actually achieve. I don't see any bargains on there. The RB Lincolns are going to be hard unless they are toners. A 1963 RB Lincoln is, on its own with no toning premium, a $15 item at retail. The Walkers, depending on toning, are priced at full retail as are the Buffs.

The appropriateness of the pricing is going to depend on the selling venue. I don't think they'll sell quickly at those prices - unless, again they have exceptional toning. If I want to pay full retail for a 1937-D or 1938-D Buff, I have my choice of hundreds of them at any time of any day.

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 5:05AM

@jmlanzaf said:
Probably reasonable, but some of those prices are going to be hard to actually achieve. I don't see any bargains on there. The RB Lincolns are going to be hard unless they are toners. A 1963 RB Lincoln is, on its own with no toning premium, a $15 item at retail. The Walkers, depending on toning, are priced at full retail as are the Buffs.

The appropriateness of the pricing is going to depend on the selling venue. I don't think they'll sell quickly at those prices - unless, again they have exceptional toning. If I want to pay full retail for a 1937-D or 1938-D Buff, I have my choice of hundreds of them at any time of any day.

They are all toners

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 5:17AM

cheezhed · February 21, 2026 5:21AM

Some nice coins on that list

jonruns · February 21, 2026 5:25AM

If they were my coins and I needed the money I'd send them all to GC and get a check. Or start on Ebay for $0.99. A lot of work to price and sell 50 coins individually. Maybe $15K total?

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 5:27AM

https://youtube.com/shorts/dYxMofcZtHM?si=XcSTYhWqiNaW_N--

291fifth · February 21, 2026 5:36AM

Expect to be disappointed.

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 5:37AM

@jonruns said:
If they were my coins and I needed the money I'd send them all to GC and get a check. Or start on Ebay for $0.99. A lot of work to price and sell 50 coins individually. Maybe $15K total?

I have someone interested in buying all at once. I just was curious if I was way off. I’m not expecting my asking price since haggling is how the game works.

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 5:41AM

@291fifth said:
Expect to be disappointed.

I’m prepared. Lol

jmlanzaf · February 21, 2026 5:51AM

@AlanSki said:

@jonruns said:
If they were my coins and I needed the money I'd send them all to GC and get a check. Or start on Ebay for $0.99. A lot of work to price and sell 50 coins individually. Maybe $15K total?

I have someone interested in buying all at once. I just was curious if I was way off. I’m not expecting my asking price since haggling is how the game works.

That is not usually the best way to maximize returns, unless it is a single coherent collection.

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 5:55AM

@jmlanzaf said:

@AlanSki said:

@jonruns said:
If they were my coins and I needed the money I'd send them all to GC and get a check. Or start on Ebay for $0.99. A lot of work to price and sell 50 coins individually. Maybe $15K total?

I have someone interested in buying all at once. I just was curious if I was way off. I’m not expecting my asking price since haggling is how the game works.

That is not usually the best way to maximize returns, unless it is a single coherent collection.

I understand but he’s reasonable. I’ve sold $6k+ to him before

rte592 · February 21, 2026 6:05AM

Sounds like you have a good plan...out with the old, in with the new.
Let us know how you did on the lot and what new coin you picked up.

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 6:14AM

@rte592 said:
Sounds like you have a good plan...out with the old, in with the new.
Let us know how you did on the lot and what new coin you picked up.

No coins. Paying off a few things and buying another truck. My kids truck is a rust bucket money pit that needs to be replaced sooner than later. My bank account will thank me.

Walkerfan · February 21, 2026 6:46AM

1934 S WLH in 66 is worth a lot more than $1100.

A 65 is worth at least $2000, so a 66 would be worth about $4000.

Just for reference, PCGS retail is $2600 and $5500, respectively.

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 7:05AM

@Walkerfan said:
1934 S WLH in 66 is worth a lot more than $1100.

A 65 is worth at least $2000, so a 66 would be worth about $4000.

Just for reference, PCGS retail is $2600 and $5500, respectively.

Good catch… it’s a typo. It’s a 64

Walkerfan · February 21, 2026 7:26AM

@AlanSki said:

@Walkerfan said:
1934 S WLH in 66 is worth a lot more than $1100.

A 65 is worth at least $2000, so a 66 would be worth about $4000.

Just for reference, PCGS retail is $2600 and $5500, respectively.

Good catch… it’s a typo. It’s a 64

Yeah, that sounds more like it.

DisneyFan · February 21, 2026 10:08AM

@jonruns said:
If they were my coins and I needed the money I'd send them all to GC and get a check. Or start on Ebay for $0.99. A lot of work to price and sell 50 coins individually. Maybe $15K total?

And have GC select coins to submit to CAC. You are leaving money off the table by not doing that.

MFeld · February 21, 2026 10:12AM

@DisneyFan said:

@jonruns said:
If they were my coins and I needed the money I'd send them all to GC and get a check. Or start on Ebay for $0.99. A lot of work to price and sell 50 coins individually. Maybe $15K total?

And have GC select coins to submit to CAC. You are leaving money off the table by not doing that.

That could be leaving money on (not off) the table.

TPring · February 21, 2026 10:17AM

@AlanSki said:

... and buying another truck. My kids truck is a rust bucket money pit that needs to be replaced sooner than later.

I predict that this won't be the last time that you pay for your kid's things.

jonruns · February 21, 2026 1:52PM

Dave Ramsey would tell you to keep your coins.

jmlanzaf · February 21, 2026 2:19PM

@jonruns said:
Dave Ramsey would tell you to keep your coins.

Lol. I think Dave Ramsey would tell you not to buy the truck for your son. Beyond that, I'm not sure.

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 3:51PM

@jmlanzaf said:

@jonruns said:
Dave Ramsey would tell you to keep your coins.

Lol. I think Dave Ramsey would tell you not to buy the truck for your son. Beyond that, I'm not sure.

Dave would probably say sell the coins and keep the guns. Or maybe that’s just me saying that…

Cougar1978 · February 21, 2026 4:10PM

Where are your prices bs CDN Bid?

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 4:15PM

@Cougar1978 said:
Where are your prices bs CDN Bid?

I don’t care about CDN bid. I’m not a dealer. Dealers won’t sell to me at CDN prices.

oldglorycoins · February 21, 2026 4:32PM

I recommend that your son buy his own truck

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 5:45PM

@oldglorycoins said:
I recommend that your son buy his own truck

Right, because there’s so many opportunities for a 16 year old to work in a town of 300 people. Should he ride a bike to the next town of 3000 people that’s a 15 minute car ride when it’s -20 outside?

safari_dude · February 21, 2026 6:06PM

@AlanSki said:

@oldglorycoins said:
I recommend that your son buy his own truck

Right, because there’s so many opportunities for a 16 year old to work in a town of 300 people. Should he ride a bike to the next town of 3000 people that’s a 15 minute car ride when it’s -20 outside?

Whoa….is it up hill both ways? 🤔🤪😂 I kid. Helping your son is a good thing. 😉

AlanSki · February 21, 2026 6:11PM

> @safari_dude said:

@AlanSki said:

@oldglorycoins said:
I recommend that your son buy his own truck

Right, because there’s so many opportunities for a 16 year old to work in a town of 300 people. Should he ride a bike to the next town of 3000 people that’s a 15 minute car ride when it’s -20 outside?

Whoa….is it up hill both ways? 🤔🤪😂 I kid. Helping your son is a good thing. 😉

Actually it kinda is with the hills.

Downtown1974 · February 21, 2026 6:16PM

Dave Ramsey would approve of you selling coins to pay cash for a truck. It’s giving your income to banks he doesn’t like.

AlanSki · February 27, 2026 6:07PM

Little update. $12,000 sold so far to one person. Not bad for 6 days.

AlanSki · March 5, 2026 11:43AM

Sold another $6300 to the same person.

World67 · March 5, 2026 12:24PM

hickoryridge · March 5, 2026 4:59PM

@AlanSki said:
Sold another $6300 to the same person.

from what i've seen you post,that buyer should be happy

I normally don’t sell coins… but

Comments

Leave a Comment