Grades revealed: GTG: 4 TrueViews
Whit
Posts: 358 ✭✭✭
Thank you for playing, folks. PCGS said
1909-IHC: 65RD
1945 Walker: 65
1892 dime: 62
1886 Morgan: 65
I was expecting 65+ or 66 on the Indian and the same on the Morgan. I thought the dime would come back 62 or 58. But the Walker … I was expecting 66 or 66+. Even with the coin in hand, I’m unable to reverse-engineer an explanation for MS65.
The retired math professor in me gives congratulations to Davidk7, Coinbuf, and TomB for having the smallest average deviation from the PCGS grades … 0.625, or 5/8 ... if my arithmetic is correct. Good night.
Whit
Hi folks; here are 4 TrueViews of coins just returned from PCGS. These were raw coins, never before slabbed, that had been in my SDB for quite a few years. Grades are not listed in case you wish to GTG and look up the certs. (Of the 4 grades, only the Barber dime's matched my own expectations. But no complaints ...)
Edited to add that the cert of the Barber is 58742893
Whit
Comments
MS65RD
MS66+
MS64
MS64
64+RD
MS65
MS63
MS64
Collector of Capped Bust Halves, SLQ's, Commems, and random cool stuff! @davidv_numismatics on Instagram
MS66RD
MS67
MS65
MS65+
65RD
66+
63
65
My Collection of Old Holders
Never a slave to one plastic brand will I ever be.
MS65RD, MS65, MS64, MS64
Interesting. I'll post the grades later this weekend.
65rd,66,63,64
MS65+ RD
MS66+
MS65
MS65+
66RD
66+
64
65
Collector, occasional seller
MS-65RD
MS-66
MS-63
MS-64
Collector
Over 100 Positive BST transactions buying and selling with 57 members and counting!
instagram.com/klnumismatics
I love the look of your IHC. Talk about blazing red! That is a fabulous coin.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
My grades based upon the images-
MS65RD
MS66
MS63
MS64+
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
That 45 half is very nice - MS67.
65RD
67
58
66
TTT
I am in no position to judge all your coins but I assume you will be getting one of those stickers put on your Indian cent. James
Very nice coins; but not enough pop and sizzle for higher grades.
All four are very beautiful coins that anyone would enjoy as part of their collection. I would send the walker to CAC with a note asking if not a gold bean why. Unless there is something not seen in the TV PCGS whiffed on that coin. Even if he doesn't give it a gold bean, JA's thoughts might help to understand the given grade. The TV makes it look 66+ and I'm usually the conservative one here.
My Collection of Old Holders
Never a slave to one plastic brand will I ever be.