Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

Coin Indexes Can be Misleading

GazesGazes Posts: 2,315 ✭✭✭✭✭

I often see posts regarding the poor return of rare coins citing to indexes like the PCGS 3000 Index. Looking at an index may make a lot of sense for stocks but I don't get it for coins. Everything you read tells you that coins are unique and even coins of the same grade can be worth vastly different amounts. Some coins are overgraded, some undergraded, some have attractive toning and others unattractive toning, some coins are accurately graded but low end for the grade and some are high end for the grade, some are original and others not, etc. Further, a collector who takes his time and puts together a well matched set of coins usually does better at sale then just a random mishmash of collection of coins (i.e coins that make up an index). In other words, on one hand we talk about all the above mentioned items when buying a coin but then disregard them when looking at a coin index.

A share of McDonalds is always the same and you need not look at it when you buy it. Coins are very different and that is why I don't think they are well suited to be measured by an Index.

Comments

  • Options
    jmlanzafjmlanzaf Posts: 43,442 ✭✭✭✭✭

    The point of an "index" is to get a feel for a broad market. Even during the Great Depression, money was made in stocks.

    The more misleading thing would be to take a single coin and try to infer the general market conditions from that result. Take stamps. [Please, I'm drowning in them.] The broad market is moribund, yet the Inverted Jenny center line block sold for almost $2 million and we set a record for the penny magenta at (IIRC) $7 million a couple years ago. Those excellent results tell you nothing about the broad market.

    The PCGS 3000 is a measure of the broader market. Of course, some coins have gone up in the last 10 years as the index was sliding. But the broad market has been sliding.

    And I don't care how carefully you put together a set of 65 CAC common date Morgan Dollars in blast white, they ain't going up in the current market.

    All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.

  • Options
    GazesGazes Posts: 2,315 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @jmlanzaf said:
    The point of an "index" is to get a feel for a broad market. Even during the Great Depression, money was made in stocks.

    The more misleading thing would be to take a single coin and try to infer the general market conditions from that result. Take stamps. [Please, I'm drowning in them.] The broad market is moribund, yet the Inverted Jenny center line block sold for almost $2 million and we set a record for the penny magenta at (IIRC) $7 million a couple years ago. Those excellent results tell you nothing about the broad market.

    The PCGS 3000 is a measure of the broader market. Of course, some coins have gone up in the last 10 years as the index was sliding. But the broad market has been sliding.

    And I don't care how carefully you put together a set of 65 CAC common date Morgan Dollars in blast white, they ain't going up in the current market.

    My main point is an index just does not work very well with coins. We always talk about being selective, not buying the plastic or the sticker, buying original coins, etc so it makes little sense to put much weight on an index that is not selective, only looks at platstic, etc. An index may give you a feel for the broad market as you say if you buy coins sight unseen with little expertise but it certainly will not give you guidance on a collection that has been carefully assembled with only high end pieces that are original and part of a consistent collection. Finally you state that it would be "more misleading ...to take and single coin and try to infer the general market conditions." You then end your post doing exactly that (not a single coin but a single series) by trying to infer the general market conditions from one series (morgans) in a specific condition (blast white).

  • Options
    jmlanzafjmlanzaf Posts: 43,442 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Gazes said:

    @jmlanzaf said:
    The point of an "index" is to get a feel for a broad market. Even during the Great Depression, money was made in stocks.

    The more misleading thing would be to take a single coin and try to infer the general market conditions from that result. Take stamps. [Please, I'm drowning in them.] The broad market is moribund, yet the Inverted Jenny center line block sold for almost $2 million and we set a record for the penny magenta at (IIRC) $7 million a couple years ago. Those excellent results tell you nothing about the broad market.

    The PCGS 3000 is a measure of the broader market. Of course, some coins have gone up in the last 10 years as the index was sliding. But the broad market has been sliding.

    And I don't care how carefully you put together a set of 65 CAC common date Morgan Dollars in blast white, they ain't going up in the current market.

    My main point is an index just does not work very well with coins. We always talk about being selective, not buying the plastic or the sticker, buying original coins, etc so it makes little sense to put much weight on an index that is not selective, only looks at platstic, etc. An index may give you a feel for the broad market as you say if you buy coins sight unseen with little expertise but it certainly will not give you guidance on a collection that has been carefully assembled with only high end pieces that are original and part of a consistent collection. Finally you state that it would be "more misleading ...to take and single coin and try to infer the general market conditions." You then end your post doing exactly that (not a single coin but a single series) by trying to infer the general market conditions from one series (morgans) in a specific condition (blast white).

    I was not saying anything about the general market from the Morgan example. Quite the contrary. I was saying that the series is moribund and that even carefully selecting your widgets will not likely yield any increase in price.

    A coin index is no more or less effective than a stock index. All of your objections to the coin index also apply to the stock index. The S&P may be down 40% but that doesn't mean McDonald's isn't up 40% at the same time.

    An individual coin should not be priced based on the market index. [Just like a stock.] By the same token, the market should not be evaluated based on a single coin or single coin series. [Just like a stock.]

    All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.

  • Options
    jmlanzafjmlanzaf Posts: 43,442 ✭✭✭✭✭

    I should add, I'm not disagreeing with your main point. I just think it is overstated. OF COURSE an index doesn't tell you about a single item in the index. It's not supposed to.

    All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.

  • Options
    CoinJunkieCoinJunkie Posts: 8,772 ✭✭✭✭✭

    A super nice example of a fairly common coin is far less likely to buck the prevailing market trends than a true rarity that comes to market very infrequently, especially if the latter has a famous provenance. IMHO.

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file