Options
Canada 1859 One Cent Variety---UPDATE Coin Graded!! Auction now live on GC Ends Sunday 10/14!!!
Was going through a collection I recently acquired and I found this 1859 Canada cent. I know there are lots of varieties for the year and I know it's "not the big one", but which one is it? Something is clearly going on inside the 9. I think it is a re-punch, but hopefully an expert out there can let me know or at least point me in the right direction.


1
Comments
If you look at the Obverse, you should have a die crack starting at the R in Regina and traveling toward Gratia. If so, the date looks like a D/P #5. Current Trends in VF-20 (hard to tell with no pics) is $500 Canadian or about 375 US
Is this the die crack you are talking about?

some additional images to help estimate a grade...
Agree with syl on the DPN9 T5. EF-45. Nice coin. Trends runs about $1,500 CAD. You'll get considerably less than that from a dealer. The photos look like there may be some porosity on the coin. If so, it is worth much less.
http://www.victoriancent.com
I dont think there is porosity on it, but poor photography skills may be more to blame for what you see. Thanks for weighing in! I thought appeared nicer than VF, but I dont know very much about grading large canadian coins.
I think that it's XF as well, now that there are some photos of the whole coin. It looks like you have a little green tinge (vertigris) to it which, again, would detract from the grade/price ... usually caused by contact with older plastic holders. Still a very nice, scarce coin.
Is an acetone soak in order then?
Acetone takes off vertigris, but you need to be careful of it (both for yourself and the coin). If you try to certify the coin later on, you may get a "cleaned" designation, but genuine. A quick acetone dip and rinse may make it look neater but I, personally, wouldn't soak it .. it's fairly pricey coin.
Cool !!!
Very nice find...

Bosox and Syl are both 100% right. IF there are any experts on the matter, these 2 are part of a very small group who can speak effectively for Canada large cents.
I believe this variety is sec0nd only to the 9 over inverted 9 and hence fairly rare.
Alright guys, thanks so much for the help! Final question, should I have it graded or keep it raw? Due to the value, I feel inclined to have it graded. Thoughts?
Don't know if a TPG Will recognize the variety.
DPOTD-3
'Emancipate yourselves from mental slavery'
CU #3245 B.N.A. #428
Don
It is listed in the PCGS Canada cent with varieties set, I think. NGC doesnt include it in their registry but appears to have a small census of them as well.
Just figured a slabbed coin would be much more marketable when it is time to sell. Not to mention, I think about slabbed coins when they are worth over $200. This one appears to be worth considerably more!
Yes, PCGS will recognize the variety. They have done so for a couple of years now. They currently have 19 in their pop report.
https://www.pcgs.com/pop/detail/victoria-1858-1901/4295
http://www.victoriancent.com
Update, my coin was sent to PCGS. Graded as AU55!!! Top Pop in the circulated world with only two better certified as mint state.
Will go auction with Great collections soon!
It is now on the PCGS website on Coin Facts too! See the professional images below.
IMO, it is a very generous 55. Wondering if a prospective buyer would share that opinion???

Just wondering how this one would compare?
it also has a clearly RP 1
this is not meant to take the OP's priority. It is a simple question how the coins would compare.
Mine is not graded at this time, but will be soon. probably ICCS.
55 seems high.
YQQ ... yours has more wear on it that the OP, especially in the hair/ear details on the Obv. The Rev shows well except for the gold spot. I'd give it a 50, but some TPG's might give it a 45.
Congrats on the grade and good luck with your sale! You should post a link of the coin when it is listed on GC.
I will be glad to post the link when it does go live. When I talked to the people at Great Collections today, they were still trying to put a figure on where to start the auction. I imagine that there are not tons of auction data to review, Perhaps more info on this thread and with the people that have posted than any other source available!
A little history lesson so everyone knows and understands the history behind this 1859 variety.
The coin that started this thread has been known for a good many years. Hans Zoell identified it back in the 60's as his variety R2b. When Jack Griffin wrote his treatise on die varieties in 1992, he had not found (or ID'd one) and was not in his pamphlet/book. When Charlton published a reprint and update of Griffin's 1992 work after Jack's death (a promise to Jack from Bill Cross at Charlton Publications), the coin WAS included and given a rarity factor of 6(on a 1-9 scale, 9 being less than 5 known). However, Charlton's Griffin reprint (Some Die Varieties of British North America and Canada), published as "Monograph One," was rife with errors .. many of the original descriptions were mismatched to the wrong photo. It CAN NOT be used as an accurate reference.
When "bosox" above and I, along with 3 others, combined our talents, research and collection populations to complete the FIRST collector-written variety guide, we condensed the old references plus added new discoveries to publish a "guide" for universal use and to be included in an annual Charlton guide . We were restricted to just 80 pages for the entire Victoria Large Cent series and it was included in the back of the 2011 (65th edition) annual Charlton Canadian Guide. It has remained the hardest to find and most expensive annual guide that Charlton has ever put out and remains the prime reference material for Victoria Large Cents, especially the 1858 & 1859 pages.
The 5 of us, by consensus, assigned a multiplier of 40 for the coin, meaning that an example would be worth 40 times what a normal 1859 would be. 40 was the 3rd highest multiplier that we assigned for the entire Vicky series .. only a single 50 and two 60 multipliers were used for the series (1859 9/6, 1881 single serif & 1882 2/1 hybrid), but many 2x-5x multipliers. Since we wrote the section in 2010, our consensus multipliers have turned out to be just about bang-on when applied across the Vicky large cent spectrum on dealer/auction sales. Also, when we wrote the section for Charlton, we assigned new "Charlton ID #'s" to some of the most recognized/collected varieties. It was with our Charlton variety section publication that the DP#3, DP#4, DP#5 and 9/6 (inverted 9) got their names and have remained as the primary ID #'s for the 1859's and TPG's. I agree with bosox above as to the trending at $1500 Cdn for what we thought would grade as an XF and think that an auction should start at about $800 US and would realize around $1,000 - $1200 US. It is a nice example of a scarce, highly sought-after coin .. scarce, but not rare, but VERY scarce in that grade. I have had 5 in my 30 year collecting career (lower grades) and one of my coins is the one illustrated in the 2011 Charton All-in-all a very nice discovery for the OP here..
Thanks for the extended explanation! Ill post the link to my auction when it goes live and we can see how your formula play out in the AU grade!
Auction is up. Lot is posted below.
https://greatcollections.com/Coin/629729/Canada-1859-Cent-DPN9-T5-KM-1-PCGS-AU-55
Good luck in the auction!
Here is my PCGS EF45 for comparison:
https://www.pcgs.com/cert/26560836
Life member #369 of the Royal Canadian Numismatic Association
Member of Canadian Association of Token Collectors
Collector of:
Canadian coins and pre-confederation tokens
Darkside proof/mint sets dated 1960
My Ebay
Syl, thank you
I am agreeing with you mostly. was thinking around 45-50. will the gold spot, which i have no idea how it kept that color, actually detract from the grade? I have other large cents with "gold" spots on both sides. some in MS.
Gene,
yours is very close to mine.
I have several of these in different grades. However, it looks like most are in the F to VF grades.
Ending in just over a week! Don't miss out!
Ending this Sunday!
Auction ends in 3 days! Lots of bidding action! Can't wait to see where this hammers!
Good luck with the auction and I think you will do quite well.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
Ends today!