Options
1883 3cn, business strike vs. proof
So I recently purchased a proof 1883, 3 cent nickel, and I read on CoinFacts that at least one die was used to make proofs and business strikes. So how would one (or a tpg for that matter) determine which category a particular coin would fall into? Could a coin with some proof-like qualities be graded either way with certainty? Mine is clearly a proof, but I read this and it just made me curious. Thanks!
0
Comments
.
oh boy.
my recommendation: get acquainted with the archives re: 19th century bs vs pf coinage/dies/flans.
tons of threads on the subject and this type/year specifically.
.
Look at CoinFacts. Reverse of proof has two die cracks, reverse of business strike has three die cracks.
An authorized PCGS dealer, and a contributor to the Red Book.
Proofs have squared rims whereas a business strike will have rounded rims.
Proofs, struck multiple times, will usually have stronger strikes.
Generally, you can distinguish a PL business strike from a proof by looking at the protected areas (e.g. to see if original frost/mint luster consistent with a business strike is there) and sometimes based on the depth of mirror.
@ShafferRareCoins
According to the book The Ultimate Guide to U.S. Three Cent Nickels by Allan Gifford, there were 4 proof obverse working dies, 4 proof reverse working dies, and only 1 business strike obverse die and 1 business strike reverse die used in 1883. The business strike die had a very (very!) small die maker that protrudes a tiny bit on the back of liberty's neck/hair just before the hair makes its 90 degree turn from near vertical to near horizontal. According to the book, this die marker is not on any of the proof dies.
Now, do I believe the book? Probably. The book is incredibly thorough, incredibly complete, with many, many photos. (For what it's worth, it was incredibly expensive (near $200 11 years ago) and very poorly written.) The book seems accurate, so I would believe that the business strikes of this date can be identified via the die marker. The business strike also has a slightly doubled die but so, too, do some of the dies used for the proofs. The doubling differs so this is another point of distinction. But if the die marker is small (and it is!) the date doublings are even smaller.