I have new found respect for Peace dollar collectors....
AUandAG
Posts: 24,936 ✭✭✭✭✭
I sent in a 1922 moustache to PCGS in the last submission that was ticky but still MS or so I thought. Got the grade: AU55....dang, just can't get those Peacies right! 0 for 3 now on my instincts on grades. Idaho Doc, et al, congrats on a great eye.
bob
PS: anyone need a 55? Yeah, spam I know.
bob
PS: anyone need a 55? Yeah, spam I know.
Registry: CC lowballs (boblindstrom), bobinvegas1989@yahoo.com
0
Comments
I used to buy 1941-45 Walkers in 64 because I knew the people who sent them in thought they were 65.
It's still the same coin........you thought it was MS.....so I bet it is a nice coin.
I used to buy 1941-45 Walkers in 64 because I knew the people who sent them in thought they were 65.
Actually do not know why I sent it in. Will get it back in a couple of days and if I'm not too embarrassed I'll post it for a GTG.
bob
Is it attributed as a variety?
Yes, VAM 12A
bob
Did you get a TV.
No, don't think I did......Too common a coin to waste $5???
bob
There are lots of sliders in the Peace dollar world. Don't feel bad. I can hold my own in the 63-67 range, but have had my own share of sour surprises from the grading room. It's a fascinating series with a wide variety of strike and luster characteristics that can be strongly date dependent. I usually evaluate a Peace dollar by thinking about how they would grade a similar looking Morgan and subtracting one point. In other words, as a Peace dollar guy, most Morgans look over-graded by a point to my eye.
+1
2 1 In Process In Process 1905 1C In Process USA
3 1 In Process In Process 1873 5C In Process USA
4 1 In Process In Process 1932-D 25C In Process USA
5 1 In Process In Process 1839 50C In Process USA
6 1 In Process In Process 1855-O 50C In Process USA
7 1 In Process In Process 1928 $1 In Process USA
8 1 In Process In Process 1927 $1 In Process USA
Most recent submission. You can guess the grades of those Peace Dollars. I'm waiting. What I wrote in my notes were MS 63 and MS 64.
They'll probably both be AU.
``https://ebay.us/m/KxolR5
1 1 In Process In Process 1864 1C In Process USA
2 1 In Process In Process 1905 1C In Process USA
3 1 In Process In Process 1873 5C In Process USA
4 1 In Process In Process 1932-D 25C In Process USA
5 1 In Process In Process 1839 50C In Process USA
6 1 In Process In Process 1855-O 50C In Process USA
7 1 In Process In Process 1928 $1 In Process USA
8 1 In Process In Process 1927 $1 In Process USA
Most recent submission. You can guess the grades of those Peace Dollars. I'm waiting. What I wrote in my notes were MS 63 and MS 64.
They'll probably both be AU.
to build the rest of the set in a comparable grade - hah!
Hmmmmmmm.
I used to buy 1941-45 Walkers in 64 because I knew the people who sent them in thought they were 65.
Using that logic, you might as well buy 58's. They're cheaper.
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
[url=https://postimage.org]
[url=https://postimage.org]
[url=https://postimage.org]