It just seems a total waste of money sending it back in. It looks totally cleaned from your images and now the world's greatest graders, 3 of them, and a finalizer have called it as such.
Move on and your next 4 coins are on deck. Remember, buying raw coins, if you are not as skilled as a grader, will cost you a fortune at the end of the day. (Especially buying high end coins.)
So one would think a resubmit might be a waste of money. Fwiw I cracked out a very clean looking PCGS MS64 $10 Eagle a few years back as I thought it was a no brainer MS65. It then came back "altered surfaces" from both PCGS and NGC. That's when I was totally dejected and just gave up on it. Coin was shipped off to a major auction where the house sent it back in a 3rd time....and they turned it into an MS66 first shot! So much for being consistent from submission to submission. An $800 "loss" turned into a $2500 profit. You just never know what's cooking.
I have not resubmitted the 1883-CC yet. I have it put aside for now. I have not given up on it. When I feel the time is right to resubmit, I will. It more than likely will not be me who resubmits it, but rather another party on my behalf.
Originally posted by: LanceNewmanOCC Originally posted by: LanceNewmanOCC . well jt, i now embark on a much more harrowing journey with this 12 coin submission.
it will be regular service. 2 week give/take.
some risky stuff this time. all raw. my estimates.
1925 25c - 64 - bad day slider - au58fh i gotta train my eye better to sliders, across all type. 1803 1c - au detail - i fergit s-255? rev cud 11 o'clock - authenticity unverifiable - pcgs, really? - will post pics - has a rare? rev cud. cant find matching pics again. still looking 1835 1/2c - 63 - wild card - 62bn phew 1882 1c proof - 64rd - eager to see - pr63rb hmm, that's ok 1938 1c proof - 64rd - 63/65 - 64rd ok 1892 25c proof - idk, 60/62 - wild card - bad day impaired - pr58 it is what it is 1824 50c - xf, possibly details - wild card - au55 - shock. color carried this puppy, far. 1872 h10c proof - 63? no hairlines but maybe looks off but has a lil color - pr64 - yay 1871 $1 - 55 - nice coin - should be safe - au58 - ya baby! 1877-s $1 - 55+ - pl fields and great frost - should be safe - au58 - ya baby! 1853 50c a&r xf45/50 - wild card - au details - meant to add poss details in initial asses. - just fine. 1942 10c proof 65 - pr66 cost $6 - ya baby! - glad my dip didnt kill it. was hazy.
many firsts in the group for me.
will be educational and some that i sorely need.
overall, very happy. .
Nice job on the submission Lance. Tough break on the 1925 SLQ. I wish you the best on future submissions.
I have not resubmitted the 1883-CC yet. I have it put aside for now. I have not given up on it. When I feel the time is right to resubmit, I will. It more than likely will not be me who resubmits it, but rather another party on my behalf.
I have not looked at your coin for a month now and just did. It is so cleaned that even if David Hall submitted it, it would not have a chance. Time to move on.
Originally posted by: jtlee321 I have not resubmitted the 1883-CC yet. I have it put aside for now. I have not given up on it. When I feel the time is right to resubmit, I will. It more than likely will not be me who resubmits it, but rather another party on my behalf.
I have not looked at your coin for a month now and just did. It is so cleaned that even if David Hall submitted it, it would not have a chance. Time to move on.
I have not resubmitted the 1883-CC yet. I have it put aside for now. I have not given up on it. When I feel the time is right to resubmit, I will. It more than likely will not be me who resubmits it, but rather another party on my behalf.
I have not looked at your coin for a month now and just did. It is so cleaned that even if David Hall submitted it, it would not have a chance. Time to move on.
David hall does not submit coins
You have an astute command of recognizing sarcasm.
Comments
.
since it is sold, i can post it.
Great coin! I would have had a hard time parting with it, even if I did not collect Morgans!
.
well jt, i now embark on a much more harrowing journey with this 12 coin submission.
it will be regular service. 2 week give/take.
some risky stuff this time. all raw. my estimates.
1925 25c - 64 - bad day slider - au58fh i gotta train my eye better to sliders, across all type.
1803 1c - au detail - i fergit s-255? rev cud 11 o'clock - authenticity unverifiable - pcgs, really?
1835 1/2c - 63 - wild card - 62bn phew
1882 1c proof - 64rd - eager to see - pr63rb hmm, that's ok
1938 1c proof - 64rd - 63/65 - 64rd ok
1892 25c proof - idk, 60/62 - wild card - bad day impaired - pr58 it is what it is
1824 50c - xf, possibly details - wild card - au55 - shock. color carried this puppy, far.
1872 h10c proof - 63? no hairlines but maybe looks off but has a lil color - pr64 - yay
1871 $1 - 55 - nice coin - should be safe - au58 - ya baby!
1877-s $1 - 55+ - pl fields and great frost - should be safe - au58 - ya baby!
1853 50c a&r xf45/50 - wild card - au details - meant to add poss details in initial asses. - just fine.
1942 10c proof 65 - pr66 cost $6
many firsts in the group for me.
will be educational and some that i sorely need.
overall, very happy.
.
line are on the reverse around the eagle.
Nick
i promise i didnt look up any more info for this cent since i got it back.
i will let you tell me wots wot.
gotta have fun.
i will say, i recognize seeing that cud in my search when grades came back but had a different image in my mind until i saw it in-hand again.
the group went to pcgs super fast after purchase. didnt image them before they went. a minor mistake.
images removed
.
Did JTLEE ever send the other coin to NGC?
Move on and your next 4 coins are on deck. Remember, buying raw coins, if you are not as skilled as a grader, will cost you a fortune at the end of the day. (Especially buying high end coins.)
So one would think a resubmit might be a waste of money. Fwiw I cracked out a very clean looking PCGS MS64 $10 Eagle a few years back as I thought it was a no brainer MS65. It then came back "altered surfaces" from both PCGS and NGC. That's when I was totally dejected and just gave up on it. Coin was shipped off to a major auction where the house sent it back in a 3rd time....and they turned it into an MS66 first shot! So much for being consistent from submission to submission. An $800 "loss" turned into a $2500 profit. You just never know what's cooking.
ok
found it. S-255
.
I'm still learning a lot about grading, and will take this opportunity to ask about what the straight
line are on the reverse around the eagle.
Nick
Those are die polish lines, very heavy ones at that.
Originally posted by: LanceNewmanOCC
.
well jt, i now embark on a much more harrowing journey with this 12 coin submission.
it will be regular service. 2 week give/take.
some risky stuff this time. all raw. my estimates.
1925 25c - 64 - bad day slider - au58fh i gotta train my eye better to sliders, across all type.
1803 1c - au detail - i fergit s-255? rev cud 11 o'clock - authenticity unverifiable - pcgs, really?
1835 1/2c - 63 - wild card - 62bn phew
1882 1c proof - 64rd - eager to see - pr63rb hmm, that's ok
1938 1c proof - 64rd - 63/65 - 64rd ok
1892 25c proof - idk, 60/62 - wild card - bad day impaired - pr58 it is what it is
1824 50c - xf, possibly details - wild card - au55 - shock. color carried this puppy, far.
1872 h10c proof - 63? no hairlines but maybe looks off but has a lil color - pr64 - yay
1871 $1 - 55 - nice coin - should be safe - au58 - ya baby!
1877-s $1 - 55+ - pl fields and great frost - should be safe - au58 - ya baby!
1853 50c a&r xf45/50 - wild card - au details - meant to add poss details in initial asses. - just fine.
1942 10c proof 65 - pr66 cost $6
many firsts in the group for me.
will be educational and some that i sorely need.
overall, very happy.
.
Nice job on the submission Lance. Tough break on the 1925 SLQ. I wish you the best on future submissions.
Originally posted by: LanceNewmanOCC
.
well jt, i now embark on a much more harrowing journey with this 12 coin submission.
.
Nice job on the submission Lance. Tough break on the 1925 SLQ. I wish you the best on future submissions.
ditto kiddo!
my next few subs will be much less harrowing.
.
I have not resubmitted the 1883-CC yet. I have it put aside for now. I have not given up on it. When I feel the time is right to resubmit, I will. It more than likely will not be me who resubmits it, but rather another party on my behalf.
I have not looked at your coin for a month now and just did. It is so cleaned that even if David Hall submitted it, it would not have a chance. Time to move on.
I have not resubmitted the 1883-CC yet. I have it put aside for now. I have not given up on it. When I feel the time is right to resubmit, I will. It more than likely will not be me who resubmits it, but rather another party on my behalf.
I have not looked at your coin for a month now and just did. It is so cleaned that even if David Hall submitted it, it would not have a chance. Time to move on.
David hall does not submit coins
I have not resubmitted the 1883-CC yet. I have it put aside for now. I have not given up on it. When I feel the time is right to resubmit, I will. It more than likely will not be me who resubmits it, but rather another party on my behalf.
I have not looked at your coin for a month now and just did. It is so cleaned that even if David Hall submitted it, it would not have a chance. Time to move on.
David hall does not submit coins
You have an astute command of recognizing sarcasm.