You Heard It Here First Folks (silver Kennedy Set coins related)

Kudbegud · December 12, 2014 2:47PM

Finally see grades for my one set. No email notice yet. USPS tracking shows received 11/7. Actually checked in 11/10. Just over 30 days in process. Ship back Monday or Tuesday. Get to me Friday or Saturday, 12/20.

1...530175...2014-W...50C...50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Reverse PR...USA...PR69
2...530173...2014-P...50C...50th Anniversary Set, Silver...USA...PR70DC
3...534990...2014-S...50C...50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Enhanced Mint State...USA...MS69PL
4...530180...2014-D...50C...50th Anniversary Set, Silver...USA...MS69

Bochiman · December 12, 2014 3:02PM

200?

Mitch, I agree...it looks tough on these. I would LOVE to have a nice 70 set...the RP and enhanced look cool. The timing just isn't there for me right now, so that's why I kept the raw.
At least I didn't chase the rainbow for me on these personally. If that were the case, I would just purchase one of your sets on the BST as you have taken all the risks and done all the work.

wondercoin · December 12, 2014 7:32PM

"Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 30904582 530174 2014-W 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Reverse PR USA PR70
1 2 30904583 530174 2014-W 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Reverse PR USA PR69
1 3 30904584 530174 2014-W 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Reverse PR USA PR69
2 1 30904585 530169 2014-P 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA PR69DC
2 2 30904586 530169 2014-P 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA PR69DC
2 3 30904587 530169 2014-P 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA PR68DC
3 1 30904588 534988 2014-S 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Enhanced Mint State USA MS69PL
3 2 30904589 534988 2014-S 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Enhanced Mint State USA MS69PL
4 1 30904590 530179 2014-D 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA MS69
4 2 30904591 530179 2014-D 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA MS69
4 3 30904592 530179 2014-D 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA MS68"

This result is not terribly surprising to me. As I alerted everyone who sent me a private email (with the detailed explanation why), this is to be expected, not the raw figures in the pop report.

Wondercoin

Kudbegud · December 13, 2014 2:13AM

Enhanced Population Update

Look at all the new designations. Label-steria seems to be taking over.

70 DMPL continues to be the rarest mint product for the Enhanced version in the set.

cointime · December 13, 2014 2:59AM

Casman / ET AL,
I remember seeing that place on the coin before sending it off to PCGS. It looked to me as if the finish was a little darker in that spot (like the opposite of a break in the frost of a cameo coin) and of course the TV photo enhanced it - I do not believe it is a milk spot. You know as bad as I would have liked to have gotten more 70's, taking into account the quality and handling at the US mint with PCGS grading ( as Mitch is saying ) I was not shocked at the grades. I mean really, when you pick up a 69 coin you want to say "nice" and a 70 should be "wow" - I like that

Hence the reason we want an impartial persons opinion. In fact I am please with the grades and TV.

Just a quick personal note: I know there is much discussion on the Enhanced S minted coin, but my favorites are the RP and the closer to business strike the D mint coins. Also I chose the standard label, cause I do not like to turn the coin over to read the label - just a personal preference.

Ken

claychaser · December 13, 2014 3:03AM

<< <i>Don't rub it in guys. I picked up another roughly 75 sets today and went 0/75. I am now at least just 1/250+ sets! Luck of the drawl here. But, this shows the type of standard being applied on these! Wondercoin >>

Naw - its' my keen sense of grading . . . NOPE! Just send in everything I had and hoped for the best ....

wondercoin · December 14, 2014 3:53AM

Interesting... The NGC version of the Enhanced Kennedy DPL in 70 grade is driftly closer to the $500 mark on ebay now with the recent sales. I think we will need a few more PCGS sales before determining a reasonable current range of value on the PCGS DMPL coins.

Wondercoin

7over8 · December 14, 2014 9:07AM

I haven't made any pcgs dmpl's but made several Ngc dpls in 70
Ngc dpls are showing very good contrast --but it is deeper than pcgs pls

wondercoin · December 14, 2014 5:24PM

7/8 ... I have also created a pile of PCGS-MS70PL coins that are far nicer (depth of cameo) than the typical 70PL coin. So, far "that and 10 cents gets me a cup of coffee".

Wondercoin

Casman · December 20, 2014 1:51AM

Grades posted last night.

Order #20873658 / Submission #5114664
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 31364981 530175 2014-W 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Reverse PR USA PR69
2 1 31364982 530175 2014-W 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Reverse PR USA PR70
3 1 31364983 530173 2014-P 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA PR69DC
4 1 31364984 530173 2014-P 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA PR70DC
5 1 31364985 534990 2014-S 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Enhanced Mint State USA MS70PL
5 2 31364986 535118 2014-S 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Enhanced Mint State USA MS69DM
6 1 31364987 530180 2014-D 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA MS70
6 2 31364988 530180 2014-D 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA MS70
6 3 31364989 530180 2014-D 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA MS69

wondercoin · December 20, 2014 1:59AM

Way to go on that DMPL Casman! How many sets did you screen to submit those coins? Wondercoin.

Casman · December 20, 2014 2:31AM

<< <i>Way to go on that DMPL Casman! How many sets did you screen to submit those coins? Wondercoin. >>

10...

, and I used my car keys to pry them out.

wondercoin · December 20, 2014 2:38AM

The car keys ... that is what I have been doing wrong!!

Wondercoin

Casman · December 20, 2014 2:44AM

Mitch, we couldn't get them out. A bunch of the guys were trying as well. I know for sure we made it through 8 sets and I got so frustrated because the keys were scratching the capsules and making it harder to screen them.

drfish · December 20, 2014 2:49AM

Butter knife works well for me

wondercoin · December 20, 2014 2:52AM

Dr. Fish ... the butter knife works great for me as well. Except I can't seem to catch a DMPL on my line that way! Maybe the car keys is the trick to get 10% DMPL's!

Wondercoin

Goldminers · December 23, 2014 12:32AM

The most recent Kennedy 2014-S DMPL went for $2,999.99 on eBay, and another now is already bid up to $3,000 with 39 bids and 5 days to go...

Casman · December 23, 2014 12:38AM

And recent sales the same night on GC @ $3,278 and $3,960 Inc the juice.

claychaser · December 23, 2014 1:36PM

<< <i>Dr. Fish ... the butter knife works great for me as well. Except I can't seem to catch a DMPL on my line that way! Maybe the car keys is the trick to get 10% DMPL's!

Wondercoin >>

-Ah ha! Now I know why no DMPL for you. The secret is using a jackknife with a pointed blade to pop 'em out. One 70-DMPL in 95 ain't bad . . .

wondercoin · December 23, 2014 1:52PM

It probably was the butter knife that killed my chances

BUT, if I hold on to my (1) coin long enough it might be worth the value of 2 or 3 coins today. It has already nearly doubled from about 4 weeks ago!!

Wondercoin

claychaser · December 23, 2014 1:54PM

dup post

claychaser · December 23, 2014 1:55PM

Mitch - which one are you thinking should be held onto?

CoinCrazyPA · December 24, 2014 2:10PM

Does anyone one know if the ones bought early on the first day of sale, have a better shot at at DMPL or are they just random?

BG · December 24, 2014 9:25PM

Logged in just now and made a bid. Hit refresh and got the following error:

500 - Internal server error.

There is a problem with the resource you are looking for, and it cannot be displayed.

pcunix · December 24, 2014 10:11PM

I had bought 3 sets and picked out the very best individuals to send off.

1 1 31387425 530169 2014-P 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA PR69DC
2 1 31387426 530174 2014-W 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Reverse PR USA PR68
3 1 31387427 534988 2014-S 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Enhanced Mint State USA MS69PL
4 1 31387428 530179 2014-D 50C 50th Anniversary Set, Silver USA MS69

I'm not surprised. I thought the 2014-S might have a shot, but I knew the RP was not going to make it. I dislike RP's anyway - I think they are ugly.

I didn't bother to pay for First Strike or the special holder. I wonder how many other plain Janes there will be

wondercoin · December 25, 2014 4:07AM

No 70's from 3 sets. Exactly the topic I discussed in my email to those who wrote me privately earlier in the month.

Wondercoin

Casman · December 27, 2014 8:48AM

<< <i>Mitch - which one are you thinking should be held onto? >>

I'd guess it's the 2014 S Enhanced PCGS 70 DMPL...There's one on Ebay now over $4K ending tomorrow night... Ended at $4,750.00

MsMorrisine · March 11, 2015 9:52AM

screwed.

0/5 on post-FS DMPLs
5/5 on post-FS PLs
4/5 on 70s

wondercoin · March 11, 2015 3:21PM

Sorry to hear that Ms Morrisine.

By the way, my son and I have written an article about these (4) pc. Silver sets which should appear on our website next week.

Stay tuned.

Wondercoin

bigole · March 11, 2015 10:36PM

I had one of these that I posted the picture of on page 2 of this thread.

I sent it in with some others to PCGS, it came back as a 69PL. The front was spectacular as shown in the earlier picture, the back not so much.

You Heard It Here First Folks (silver Kennedy Set coins related)

Comments

Leave a Comment