Options
Why are some of these large cents still NC?
1868LargeCent
Posts: 335 ✭
NC literally means noncollectible. More than a few of these, mostly from the 1800s, have become far more common and fully "collectible" since the last update of Sheldon (who is going to update this already?!?! It's too important for the newest to be from the 70s). Take the 1803 NC-1. This one is an R5 and is plenty "collectable" by now, so much so, that one is on Ebay now for the gigantic price of...$125. Yeah, reeeeeaaally noncollectible all right. Quite a few 1803 S#'d varieties are rarer, most notably LD SF, the famous, rare and valuable one.
So, at what point does a variety "lose" its NC# and become an S#? The threshold of R4-R5? Or has this ever really been thought of?
So, at what point does a variety "lose" its NC# and become an S#? The threshold of R4-R5? Or has this ever really been thought of?
0
Comments
As you can tell, I'm a large cent enthusiast!
<< <i>I want to know who is going to take up the project of bringing his book into the 21st century. And whoever does, will they renumber it? It isn't that bad of a problem, was just wondering. The more pressing matter is updating the book. It's just too important not to. Whitman ought to get the rights to it, they got the rights to Judd's pattern encyclopedia and many others.
As you can tell, I'm a large cent enthusiast! >>
when will your early large cent book update be released?
.
not sure where the qty cutoff should be but if there are "too many" of a particular NC, the designation should be lost. for an nc to sit at anything under $5k and not sell is just....
.
If a new numbering were to come about, which I would not be opposed to, it would need to come about slowly and organically. It's true that even several years after EAC was published, Sheldon himself was still using the old Hays numbers to attribute and describe his early cents.
As for those more available NC's (most notably 1796 NC-4, 1800 NC-3, 1802 NC-1, 1803 NC-1), we can just call them "Now-Collectibles"
And if you aren't already a member, definitely check out eacs.org!