Is this seller on this board?

AUandAG · October 21, 2013 11:22AM

Here's a link Ebay 1890cc Morgan

I sent the following message: Dear coinclub,

You guaranty this authentic but do you guaranty the grade at any other service? If not, do you guaranty the grade within two points at any other service? I've never heard of ANCS. I prefer NGC or PCGS. Let me know.
bob

If you participate here "coinclub" please respond or I'll just wait for a response to my sent Ebay message.

bob

lkeigwin · October 21, 2013 11:29AM

Not sure where you're going with this. Seller says:

"guaranteed to be genuine and authentic...grading is subjective to ones' own opinion. This coin is not graded by one of the more common grading companies. Therefore, we cannot guarantee the grade. We also cannot guarantee that this coin has not been cleaned at one time or another."

Seems to me all the seller is saying is "it's real and we guarantee that". Otherwise, all bets are off.
Lance.

coindeuce · October 21, 2013 11:32AM

ANCS. AbjectNonsenseCoinSlabbers

Moldnut · October 21, 2013 11:37AM

<< Not sure where you're going with this. Seller says:

"guaranteed to be genuine and authentic...grading is subjective to ones' own opinion. This coin is not graded by one of the more common grading companies. Therefore, we cannot guarantee the grade. We also cannot guarantee that this coin has not been cleaned at one time or another."

Seems to me all the seller is saying is "it's real and we guarantee that". Otherwise, all bets are off.
Lance. >>

Buy it if you like it, pass if you don't.

mrpotatoheadd · October 21, 2013 11:38AM

If you prefer NGC or PCGS, it might be best to restrict your searches to coins already in those holders.

braddick · October 21, 2013 11:42AM

Come on, Bob.
What's going on here with this thread?

What is your true agenda?

Alltheabove76 · October 21, 2013 12:04PM

If that an MS66 then....

I bet this coin grades AU58 at ANCS!

LanceNewmanOCC · October 21, 2013 12:05PM

.
the point is obvious as it is useless and i recognize the feeling unfortunately.

it is a reaction to the stupidity of coins like this in holders with those kind of numbers for grading. plain ridiculous.

posting here doesn't do much good but it is frustrating seeing this kind of crap and sometimes i think people need to vent. such is life.

always makes one wonder what kind of response someone would give to a couple simple questions but after hearing some of the answers i got, i just plain stopped asking.

.

rodorr · October 21, 2013 12:06PM

MS-66 Morgans are looking awfully haggard. I'm think I'm going to stick with MS-70. Boy are those buggers hard to find!!

rodorr

AUandAG · October 21, 2013 12:06PM

<< Come on, Bob.
What's going on here with this thread?

What is your true agenda? >>

Oh dang, outed.....He's the slabber, right?? Coins are not gradable at any other service, right?

Just giving them a chance to speak their piece, here on the board.

bob

NotSure · October 21, 2013 12:09PM

<< Come on, Bob.
What's going on here with this thread?

What is your true agenda? >>

Could it be because ANCS ranks lower than NTC, or is it due to the recent neg feedback he got here on an ANCS coin he recently sold? The FeedBack seems to justify the knowledge a lot of us have here, and that they are a garage slabber, and the 'CC' mintmark may just fall off if cracked for a cross. That kind of feedback wouldn't make me all warm and fuzzy. But, people still buy these things, rolling the dice on them.....sure, once in a great while, you get lucky if it's authentic and only 2 pts undergraded.

And as Bob states:

<< Here's a link Ebay 1890cc Morgan

I sent the following message: Dear coinclub,

You guaranty this authentic but do you guaranty the grade at any other service? If not, do you guaranty the grade within two points at any other service? I've never heard of ANCS. I prefer NGC or PCGS. Let me know.
bob

If you participate here "coinclub" please respond or I'll just wait for a response to my sent Ebay message.

bob >>

I wouldn't hold your breath waiting for an answer to that question, and I might doubt that if seller was here, I know I wouldn't be admitting it was me selling that crap!!

AUandAG · October 21, 2013 12:18PM

Seriously, I had not read his feedback. Didn't feel a need to go there!

bob

braddick · October 21, 2013 12:33PM

Bob, I've seen the type of coins you purchase and they are generally second to none.
Your eye for quality is your trademark.
There is no way in hell you're interested in this harshly cleaned/polished POS.

This thread topic and inquiry appear to be cloaked in sarcasm, OK- I get that, but to ask the question you did of the seller- with your tongue firmly planted in your cheek and expect to get a response is just silly.

MsMorrisine · October 21, 2013 12:35PM

Actually, read the title the negs and neutrals.

"MS/BU" is mentioned in all three.

Perhaps in your next contact you can remind him that his typing "MS/BU" is him applying an approximate grade and if he later says "grade not guaranteed" then he is saying do not trust what I type.

NotSure · October 21, 2013 1:07PM

<< Seriously, I had not read his feedback. Didn't feel a need to go there!

bob

>>

There really wasn't for me, either (ANCS, or any 'knockoff' plastic, the feedback needs to be checked to see if if it was junk , but I wanted to check for a return hobby (more like a non-) return policy. Depending on who's selling what, I check feedback a lot (but this guys account being 'private', that always sends a red-flag, not a huge one, but.....) I understand some negs can be spiteful, but I THINK, in this case (and most/all sales of ANCS, PGS, NTC, 'graded' coins, the usual 'close to the trademarked name' home slabbers), I'd think if a buyer ever had a problem with an ANCS coin, I'd tend to believe the feedback and the problem was with the coin. The seller's 'feedback left' can be telling, at times, also. Shows, on one neg feedback response he got, he won't honor any guarantee, that he won't guarantee the grade (even 'MS/BU', which he states it IS in the title,,,,,he won't guarantee authenticity, nothing. But he DOES have a 14 days 'hassle free return policy', and in the description state "NO QUESTIONS ASKED GUARANTEE…. 100% full refund if you don't agree with quality of the coin upon inspection.
If you don't agree with the quality of the coin just send it back within 14 days of the purchase date for a full refund. NO QUESTIONS ASKED"

Doesn't make any guarantees, but has a hassle-free return policy? I'd just keep moving along.

AUandAG · October 21, 2013 2:15PM

<< Bob, I've seen the type of coins you purchase and they are generally second to none.
Your eye for quality is your trademark.
There is no way in hell you're interested in this harshly cleaned/polished POS.

This thread topic and inquiry appear to be cloaked in sarcasm, OK- I get that, but to ask the question you did of the seller- with your tongue firmly planted in your cheek and expect to get a response is just silly. >>

Braddick,,,,,,oh my, oh my......I'm I so transparent??

LOL

bob

TireKicker · October 21, 2013 3:06PM

<< Not sure where you're going with this. Seller says:

"guaranteed to be genuine and authentic...grading is subjective to ones' own opinion. This coin is not graded by one of the more common grading companies. Therefore, we cannot guarantee the grade. We also cannot guarantee that this coin has not been cleaned at one time or another."

Seems to me all the seller is saying is "it's real and we guarantee that". Otherwise, all bets are off.
Lance. >>

Agreed!

droopyd · October 22, 2013 3:24AM

Not worth the bother to make the inquiry, IMHO.

morgansforever · October 22, 2013 5:50AM

Appears to be genuine with unc details and that's about it. I guarantee it will be dull and lifeless upon in-hand inspection.

roadrunner · October 22, 2013 6:26AM

The coin has been cleaned to "authentic" US coin cleaning standards. No elbow grease was left unused. That's about the worst coin I've ever seen in a MS66 slab.

That's one "Coin Club" where I'm glad I'm not a member.

Is this seller on this board?

Comments

Leave a Comment