Whats the best coin you ever cherrypicked

mbbiker · September 10, 2002 2:05PM

Just was wondering if anyone ever cherrypicks a real rarity that can actually be sold for a profit, i have found alot of varieties from the cherrypickers guide but so few people collect those varieties it dosn't pay to buy them, has anyone really picked a salable variety?????

Also has anyone cherried a proof set for no-mint mark coins like the 68 no s dime, 71 no s nickel or things like that

Iwog · September 11, 2002 2:37PM

Cherry picked this from a dealer. Paid about $2

BBN · September 11, 2002 2:55PM

Great find IWOG!!!

richbeat · September 11, 2002 5:44PM

I was lucky enough to find several of the 1983DDR cents when I lived in Florida.

goose3 · September 11, 2002 8:43PM

I bought a PCGS 1857 Flyer and when it arrived it was the "type of 56" variety.

sometimes I'm glad PCGS doesn't do their homework on stuff like that.

fcloud · September 11, 2002 9:05PM

I picked up a 1858 double date half dime for $2 (in FINE).

paulheep · September 11, 2002 11:42PM

I found a nice 1970-s proof small date lincoln in a dealer's showcase, bought it for $45 and it made PCGS PR66 DCAM!

Paul

Conder101 · September 12, 2002 10:51PM

1802 NC-2 large cent eleventh known specimen paid $20 lists at $3000
1802 NC-1 ;arge cent for $30 lists at $250
1797 S-121a large cent 16th known specimen $30 lists at $2000
12th finest 1803 S-262 lists $1000 cost $80

Quite a few other scarce large cent varieties

tsacch · September 12, 2002 11:00PM

I got 3 1943 double eye jefferson nickles and two 1939 double monticello's from the same dealer at a mall coin show. paid about $15 for the lot. the double eyes went Anacs 64 for each and the 39's went 63 and 64....sold for lots of casssssshhhhhhhhh

gmarguli · September 13, 2002 2:16AM

I've found tons of varieties (many undocumented).

Over the years I've found probably 15-20 1968-S 25¢ DDR FS-027. These are pretty neat. I've got one left in NGC PR66 if anyone is interested.

Tons of DDO & DDR Jeffersons. This is one overlooked series.

I once purchased a 1799 1¢ off a bid board for a few dollars. People thought it was fake. Too bad for them.

Blackhawk · September 13, 2002 2:26AM

I just got the 1868 shield nickel back from ANACS that I bought off of Ebay for $12.00. It came back as a Variety 5 reverse of 1868 (FS-0002.98). It only grades out at VG-8, but it's not net graded. It's still a cool coin in that they estimate that there were only about 29,000 of this variety of reverse minted. Now the trick is to find someone that collects shield nickel varieties.

Bill

griffin6 · September 13, 2002 2:31AM

An 1858/7 flying eagle cent in the AU-55/58 for under $200... a 1914/3 nickel for $9.00. I also have a couple of 1914-D nickels that SEGS and Fivaz/Stanton recognize as 14/13-D in VG-10 and XF-40. Haven't sold these yet, but am entertaining offers (e-mail me for scans if interested).

nwcs · September 13, 2002 5:57AM

I haven't, but my brother cherry picked a 10 escudo gold (1/4 oz) coin for free once.

Tonekiller · September 13, 2002 6:20AM

1812/11 50c rainbow colors, bought raw $105 as a 1812 50c. ANACS MS 64 and in my safe.

TBT

gmarguli · September 13, 2002 6:23AM

I haven't, but my brother cherry picked a 10 escudo gold (1/4 oz) coin for free once.

Are you sure he didn't "pocket" the 10 escudo? How does one cherry a coin for free?

lincolnSence · September 13, 2002 9:05AM

Greg - This approach seems a little harsh don't you think? If the guy stole the coin I suspect he would have said so. A better way to phrase this might have been " how did your brother acquire it for free?". Maybe next time.

andy007 · September 13, 2002 9:13AM

Got a MS63-64 1974-D DDO Kennedy for $2.

gmarguli · September 13, 2002 9:42AM

lincolnSence, if I wanted a better way to say what I wrote, I would have asked for it.

speer34 · September 13, 2002 9:47AM

Although I didn't cherrypick it, I did find a 1994 Lincoln DDR FS 039.9. While I picked the coin up at face value, I recently sold this coin for $220. Not a bad profit for checking your change

lazeroo · September 13, 2002 10:06AM

lol greg your just to funny!

ok how about these 1877 seated halves with type 1 reverse. I think I own them all lol. and never payed more than 59$ for any of them .

that is until I had to buy one from dick osborn, he always has the best in seated coinage for sale.

oh yea there all R-7 or R 8/unk .

but sometimes very rare coins are overrated. mostly because people aren't looking for them.
so low grade very rare coins may stay in curculation for years until someone actually gets hot looking for them.

braddick · September 13, 2002 10:18AM

All you guys have the great stories! Mine is a simple 2Cent coin off a bid board for $10. The previous owner thought it was polished UNC. It was really a RedBrown Proof (slabbed at PR63 w/ PCI).

In a much less fashion, just about a month ago I bid on eBay for a NGC MS68 1976-S Ike. The seller had it listed under "early commemoratives" and also spelled NGC, "NCG". The auction didn't get many hits and I was able to snipe it for about $100.00 (these usually list for about $750.00).

I also just received a board member's 1846-O, ANACS VF30 today. BIN was $210.00 and although it isn't a "steal of a deal" it is an absolutely 100% original coin and a full VF30+ Seated dollar. The "O" mint is a better date too (vs the 1846-P).

wingedliberty · September 13, 2002 10:30AM

I cherrypicked a 1945 Mercury dime. I paid $20 for it. I sent it in to PCGS and it came
back MS66FB. This happened in a recent dream.

Brian

misterR · September 13, 2002 11:13AM

88-P Kennedy halves from mint sets with rotated reverses, 74-D DDO Kennedy halves from mint sets, 79 and 81 proof T2 $1s from proof sets, 39 DDR nickel in AU, 42-D over horiz. D nickels, 82-P no FG Kennedys in Unc., 36 DDO Lincoln cents...can't remember them all...lot's more for everyone to have fun finding.

STEWARTBLAYNUMIS · September 13, 2002 11:17AM

This thread is four days old and I don't think that anyone has cherrypicked squat.Maybe I'm a little bit ambiguous about the meaning of cherrypicking.Does it mean that when you buy a coin you try and find a variety or does it mean you are picking someone off ?
Is this thread about how everyone is more knowledgeable numismatically?

merz2 · September 13, 2002 11:38AM

I have been lucky enough to have it happen twice.The first was a 1942/1 Mercury Dime.It was in a roll of dimes at a local auction.I bought the roll for $11.I sold the coin for $250.The second was a 1909 S/horizontal S.It was in MS63RB.I sold it for $350.

gmarguli · September 13, 2002 11:43AM

74-D DDO Kennedy halves from mint sets,

These are great. Nothing like finding a double die so pronounced that you can see it without a glass.

79 and 81 proof T2 $1s from proof sets

It's near impossible to find a T-2 79, but you can still get the T-2 81 from dealers that can't tell them apart.

abuell · September 13, 2002 12:05PM

About 12 years ago a local huckster/dealer had some low grade large cents. He simply told me that I wouldn't be interested in them as they were nothing special. I finally pestered him to show them to me - whoa! I recognized one of them as a 1797 NC-1 grading G 5!!! 5th known! When I asked how much he wanted for that particular coin it suddenly became VF and he wouldn't name a price. I said that the Redbook listed VF's at $350 and that I could probably do that. I could just see him salivating at the deal! Hey, I hope that he spent the $350 wisely because I sold the coin for $10,500!

Whats the best coin you ever cherrypicked

Comments

Leave a Comment