Options
1950-D Jefferson-edited
coinkat
Posts: 24,399 ✭✭✭✭✭
Opinions?
I have removed the link as there some believe that this is SPAM. To those that believe it was spam, my apologies, but consider reading the full story.
I own the coin and the intent was not to solicit the sale of a fairly inexpensive coin that will sell regardless of whether it is seen here or anywhere else, but to raise the issue of grading. For those that may not recall, I initiated a subject thread on this forum on the concept of developing a different designation for Jefferson nickels which would be along the lines of Full Monticello. The reason is simple- the portico and detail within the structure incorporates more of the design than the steps. Which is really more important? Seems we have too much older conventional thinking unwilling to consider and even accept a more comprehensive grading designation than the over hyped Full Step designation for Jefferson Nickels.
The coin pictured showed more of the structure which is the point-
The purpose of grading is to best describe the condition of the physical charateristics as to the coin's state of preservation. Grading is a science that involves continious improvement.
So ask yourself... Are we really doing that with the Jefferson Nickel series?
I think my answer to this question is clear.
I have removed the link as there some believe that this is SPAM. To those that believe it was spam, my apologies, but consider reading the full story.
I own the coin and the intent was not to solicit the sale of a fairly inexpensive coin that will sell regardless of whether it is seen here or anywhere else, but to raise the issue of grading. For those that may not recall, I initiated a subject thread on this forum on the concept of developing a different designation for Jefferson nickels which would be along the lines of Full Monticello. The reason is simple- the portico and detail within the structure incorporates more of the design than the steps. Which is really more important? Seems we have too much older conventional thinking unwilling to consider and even accept a more comprehensive grading designation than the over hyped Full Step designation for Jefferson Nickels.
The coin pictured showed more of the structure which is the point-
The purpose of grading is to best describe the condition of the physical charateristics as to the coin's state of preservation. Grading is a science that involves continious improvement.
So ask yourself... Are we really doing that with the Jefferson Nickel series?
I think my answer to this question is clear.
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
0
Comments
Nice coin........great pics..........and the seller is one of the best!
.....................................................
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
this is a good point. from MyLoftyPerch perhaps the only reason to slab a 1950-D Jefferson is for the step designation(MS65FS and higher) or a coin which has exceptional tone which will command a premium. absent that, I see this issue as being so abundant and available that an example such as the auction coin should be relatively easy to find and bought for less, probably $25 raw. the auction coin will probably sell for $60-$70 plus shipping.
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
The more qualities observed in a coin, the more desirable that coin becomes!
My Jefferson Nickel Collection
<< <i>I think for a 1950-D Jefferson Nickel in a PCGS MS65FS holder it is only average. >>
This issue comes well struck.
<< <i>
<< <i>I think for a 1950-D Jefferson Nickel in a PCGS MS65FS holder it is only average. >>
This issue comes well struck. >>
This issue also tends to be struck from beat dies - yes, not as bad as the rest of the early/mid 50's, but still. The one shown is probably a little better than average in that regard, but I would still try to find one with an earlier die state.
<< <i>I see this issue as being so abundant and available that an example such as the auction coin should be relatively easy to find and bought for less, probably $25 raw. the auction coin will probably sell for $60-$70 plus shipping. >>
I got a nicer one with awesome toning in an old National album that I figured was worth around $12-15 bucks - so this was an informative thread for me!
my understanding of "spam" is simple: an attempt under false pretense or ignorance to direct attention in hopes of personal gain. I believe that was accomplished.