Guess the Grade on this Aaron RC

flcardtrader

I don't own this card, however, I have lusted over it for a while to complete out my 54 set.

What grade do you think is behind the black block in the upper right of the front image?

JoeBanzai

Can't tell with this scan. Centered low. Bad upper right corner? 5-6?

Francart

PSA 4

JBrules

PSA 5

yoda99

PSA 4

baseballfan

psa 4

maddux69

4.5

tonylags

6; I bet it's an older slab

CARDSANDCOINS

5

1954

The back is pretty strong. From the scan I would say a 5

divecchia

I'm going to guess a PSA 4.

Donato

Littletweed

Hey Mike!

Looks like a 5-6, nice looking card. Congrats on almost finishing the set!

bounce

PSA 4

PROMETHIUS88

4 judging by the corner and centering.

Stingray

5.5

KbKards

PSA 4. The ebay listing shows the crease a bit better.

flcardtrader

For those of you who guess "4", what was it that made you say "4"? Would the upper right corner alone be enough for it considering it was (is) probably layering a little bit?

Kb - thanks, I have been looking for the crease or wrinkle but still cannot find it!!!!

This is definitely one of those - buy the card, not the label for me as the centering and vivid color do it for me.

Thanks for your input on this one.

Unknown

This content has been removed.

bounce

@CARDSINLOSANGELES said:
if there were a wrinkle or crease, would be a 3.

Not true. Spider wrinkles/minor creases also appear in 4 holders, just ask the T206 collectors because it happens on those all the time.

I said 4 primarily because of that corner. The T/B centering didn't bother me much and I don't think that contributed at all to the grade, meaning it didn't prevent this from being a 5 or even a 6 potentially.

That corner I suspect will always keep it in the 4 holder.

handyman

Staining by the #128?

Dand522612

Appears to be sold. I hope you got it!

divecchia

For me the grade I chose (PSA 4) was based mostly on the corner.

Donato