Opinions and maybe me venting a little
PROMETHIUS88
Posts: 2,820 ✭✭✭✭✭
First off, I know that we are not talking about much money (2.50) so I should just refund it and let it go, but to me it is really the principal of the matter. I had an auction for some 1962 Topps commons and listed the average grade of the lot as vg. There were some really decent cards in there. Winning bidder messages me today stating that he got the cards and there were 7 checklists that were all heavily marked so he is requesting a $2.50 refund. So, for the opinion part... if you buy a lot where the "average" grade is vg and some have marks, would you request a refund? I sure wouldn't. Second, as the seller, would you request said cards back? Funny thing is, I put every card in a penny sleeve and although I charged $7 shipping, I paid the extra and sent priority 2 day mail. I like my buyers to get their stuff in a timely manner. Anyhow, just looking to see what you all think or would do. Thanks for letting me vent!
Oh, his the link to the auction so you can see exactly how it was described.
Comments
Correct!
My two cents ...
From the title, I would read it as VG or better and I don't see the word 'average' anywhere in the listing. That said, if I had bought the lot I wouldn't be requesting a refund or even dinging DSRs when leaving feedback.
Unless graded, I avoid specific grade mentions in my listings opting for 'low-mid'/'mid'/'mid-high' grade instead.
Tell him you had to pay more than $7 to ship them, so instead of asking him to pay the difference in shiping and you pay him back the refund, just call it even!
You gotta get it off your chest so blast away here but life's better when you just do it and move on. Are you gonna remember this in 4 months? No. Then why wait 4 months?
Arthur
Why not learn a lesson from this? You should have stated that the checklists were marked.
The buyer got a good deal at that price, even if those seven cards weren't included, and he shouldn't have complained...but frankly he had a right to. So refund the $2.50 and be done with it.
Conservatively grading the lot at VG. No picture or mention of checklists, but just because they're checklists doesn't mean it's okay for them to have writing on them. Should have pictured them or had a lot of 136 with 7 free marked checklists thrown in.
Thanks for all the responses. It's good to get some different viewpoints and for sure will not make the same mistake again. It was never about the money and i'm for sure not going to lose any sleep over it!
When selling lower end lots I always say "cards may include creases, wrinkles, miscuts, marks, tears, paper loss, severe centering issues, and/or other flaws that result in a low grade." Refund and move on.
I agree with stevek
Big diff between low grade and marked CL
refund the man and move on.
1948-76 Topps FB Sets
FB & BB HOF Player sets
1948-1993 NY Yankee Team Sets
I have to agree with the buyer and doing the math, $2.50 is fair.
Pix of marked checklists or others so marked would of been best. Then no issues/misunderstanding. Kind of like "what you see is what you get". Still was a good buy for the buyer.
I do not think there was any harm meant on your end. The buyer got more than a decent deal on the cards even if the description was not all that detailed. However, the description needs to be more detailed as others have mentioned. If the description had stated that 7 free marked cards would be thrown in, I doubt he would have complained.
BST: Tennessebanker, Downtown1974, LarkinCollector, nendee
It's petty for the buyer but just be happy that you can send $2.50 and be done with it.
Looking to BUY n332 1889 SF Hess cards and high grade cards from 19th century especially. "Once you have wrestled everything else in life is easy" Dan Gable
Vent away. I'd need to do the same. I mean who cares about $2.50. I'm a child of depression era parents so I was taught to squeeze every nickel as if it was the last. But in 2018 what does $2.50 buy? Sheesh.
If I just go around the block, somehow I wind up spending 15 or 20 bucks. Not including the gas.
Hiya Tim
I hear ya. Venting is good.
I'ld rather see people verbally vent than go on a rampage.
Hire a Hitman and seek vengeance!
Lol, I refunded the $2.50 the same day. I apologized for the marked cards and asked if he was happy with the quality of the rest of the cards. His only response was "Thanks!". My only real issue was that the value of the lot was way more than what he paid for the condition of the rest of the cards and I thought it was a little petty to ask for $2.50 back. Either way, I have moved on to a more happy place!