In your humble opinion.....Grade My '67 Aaron

Mintacular · January 27, 2018 5:34PM

Have gotten some great advice this year from experienced PSA members, so if I haven't thanked you in those posts before....THANKS! Anyway, one more, The '67 Aaron from a local card show. I think a 7. Could it be higher? My concern is the back which is o/c. Tiny wear on corners/edges. Your thoughts, and would you pay over/under $35 for> (what i paid.)

AaronfromKy · January 27, 2018 5:40PM

If it isn't trimmed(I'm not saying it is) I would say an 8(OC) or a 6.

JBrules · January 27, 2018 6:11PM

Looks to be a solid PSA 8. The centering on the back for a PSA 8 or PSA 9 only needs to be 90/10 so I do not see it being OC. The top right (Front) corner is what concerns me the most.

handyman · January 27, 2018 6:28PM

Back is not a problem if all esle is fine. This card always has a OC back like the Mays from this set. Many 9s are 95-5 on the back it seems.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/1967-TOPPS-200-WILLIE-MAYS-PSA-9-SET-BREAK/202198153745?hash=item2f13f2fa11:g:gbIAAOSwEUdaZUIS
Back looks just like almost all the others.
Shoudl grade high.

Dand522612 · January 27, 2018 7:45PM

Yep, don’t care about the back at all. Sweet card! I’d say minimum 7 possible +

Kkathyl · January 27, 2018 8:31PM

8 but hard to see color in pics. Nice card

mrpeanut39 · January 27, 2018 9:27PM

Just posted this in Matt0224's thread since I saw his thread first. Originally graded an 8, buyer bumped it to an 8.5. So centering won't be an issue for this card.

Edited to add scan of front.

secretstash · January 28, 2018 3:32AM

Can we see the front? @mrpeanut39

OP, @Mintacular I think it will land into a 7, albeit a very sharp looking one. That back corner top right bothers me, but since it is unseen from the front, I think you can still end up landing higher also. GL!