1937 Buffalo what grade would you assign

Kkathyl

What grade would you assign this Nickel

Insider2

Hi. Looks XF/AU. Post it on the US coin forum where it will be seen by more folks!

dagingerbeasttt

I agree AU. Nice looking nickel

ChrisH821

Interesting that we have grades from F15 to AU50+

Insider2

Sure is, If you open up a grading guide, anyone posting Fine or below is incorrect and anyone posting AU and above is also incorrect. I originally posted XF/AU. Some might sell this as an AU-50. That does not mean it is a "true" AU. Too much wear IMO. That leaves VF and XF.

I think it would be a big help to all of us if you give a reason for your grade opinion. I'll do it later.

ChrisH821

Wait, what? How did my post end up above ones before mine? Ah the "answers" get pushed to the top... interesting and noted

AstroJoe

VF

BobSav

45, but I suck at grading buff's I always seem to get it wrong.

jclovescoins

Def not AU...XF 40

YQQ

F15, sorry
But I must say I have no idea about grading US nickels.

Rexford

xf40